Yeah, "some people" can over react to little things and then behave so inappropriately, ridiculously, and make themselves out to be such jerks that it can bring completely unrelated threads down due to "their'' poor social skills.   The funniest part is when you call 'them' out on their ridiculous behavior, they cry foul and whine so hard you would think they were shot with a real gun.   

Probably better if you just hold the boxes for now.  Keep them shrink wrapped if you are considering reselling for next time.

I need one more if you can find anything in my tradelist for it.

Living end is fun

I used to send same time with ppl higher than ten (as i was taught by marumari) but then one of my few bad trades involved a 30 FB lying to me so everyone might have a different idea of a fair threshold, although typically 40ish higher i still try to send same time. 

Also what is everyone's idea of 'trading down', I agree with a $50 for a bunch of ones is a huge trade down,  but is a 50 for 2 $25's the same? five $10's? Plus some people dont want to play eternal so if they are happy to trade them for standard, why do other people make an issue of it?  I have gotten out of legacy and traded almost everything i had for modern stuff,  while both eternal, i would argue its not that much of a diff from trading modern for standard.  modern can be reprinted, so its bound to lose value (not like standard)  but I ONLY play modern so was happy to do it.

Not really upset or anything but its kinda late 2013 now, right?

81

(43 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

for the record I only called him semi-retarded.   ;p  ok sorry i am done, even if he posts more.  If you dont want to trade with me paul thats fine, I understand but i figured I was allowed one response on the forums. he seems to have been very active in his story telling. 

as far as contacting people, i have sent email via the site every once in a while to someone who seems active but doesnt have any active trades and maybe four out of ten respond back, and maybe two of those try to make a trade happen.   low odds but not a complete waste.

Marumari mentions in another thread how difficult it is to filter through all the various people via the reddit group, or via card and I agree that its almost impossible.  Honestly I have mostly given up on it and most of my trades lately have been initiated by other people when i seem to have things they want.  I have even found myself adding more crazy things to start collecting because not much else I need and got most of the smaller stuff already.   

Anyone think that with the new greek themed theros set, people might start coming back? or even a new influx of players?   RTR seemed to have brought a fair number of people if my general impression is correct.

Great suggestions, I am kinda with Paul K on the eternal vs standard or 50 vs 10,  its traders choice and more of a market/demand issue more than an etiquette thing.

Honestly i have given up on both the front page or searching through by card,    are there any plans for filtering out badly inactive accounts?

83

(43 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Wow you really have issues.

To the rest of you, for what its worth, sorry he is wasting all your time, but how many of you have a regular store you go to?

Imagine you go to your local gaming store, you are very comfortable there, you have been there for a few years and really like the place. You have lots of friends and people you trust and consider it a great place to hang out. You see some new people who are looking for trades so you open up your folder to see if anything may work out.

Now you start a conversation about making a trade with a few guys and out of them only one has something that seems workable.  He is obviously new but seems to be interested in some of your cards so you make an offer that is Fair.  you look up the prices at TCG and use the avg for everything.   The guy first asks (in a easily to be taken as condescending way) whether your cards are MINT because HIS sure are.  You know the card is fine so you try to continue the trade, ignoring the arrogant behavior.   He starts adding cards from your folder that makes the trade a little uneven,  and asks you to accept.  You assume he is interested in a bigger trade but nothing to balance it out so you adjust it a bit, and offer another equal trade.    He repeatedly adds cards from your folder and asks you to accept the trade, even though its obvious to you that the trade is horribly uneven in his favor and he wont let you add more cards from his side.  He always changes it to something uneven and stupid.

Now at this point most of you would be wondering what the hell this joker is thinking making more and more unreasonable offers (he got worse not better) and he tells you in what can only be taken as an arrogant tone how HIS card was worth more two months ago and so you should give him a lot more in value, even though the value today is less. (its called market price dumbass)  Now you had been polite and patient with him so far but at this point you realize he is either 1. an asshole/shark that is trying to screw you over due to his arrogance, or 2.  he is an idiot that doesnt understand the basic common sense of trading and changes in market value.

What do you do? 

You could just quit the trade as usual, you have done it a hundred times before and will do it countless more, but for some reason this guy's attitude really bothered you. Perhaps the arrogance and selfish behavior makes you realize this person is a bit of an asshole and you dont like that people like him might start screwing up your fav hang out place and probably turn other people off due to his behavior (most people will ignore it as you do, shit happens and its only a failed trade,  but its always good to be warned of jerks ahead of time.)

Also, seeing as how you met the new group because someone was talking about being unable to make trades due to poor/no responses, and being someone who hangs out here a decent amount you know exactly what they are talking about, its quite possible that you also feel that while many people just quit and you wont see them again due to normal life issues, there are others who get turned off due to jerks like the guy you just met, and those people  end up quitting the site due to one or two bad apples.   (he isnt that important but every little bit hurts)

So as you choose to walk away you take the extra step (which you dont normally do) of kindly warning your fellow members that this guy is a little crazy (He really does need to chill out). You dont curse him out, but your choices are crazy or jackass, and being the  calm individual you are, you figure being called crazy is the more polite thing to do.   You dont give the guy a negative because that is a little extreme for a failed trade but still a zero is a fair warning for poor social behavior. 

Thinking back, if the person didnt want to be called crazy he shouldnt have acted like a crazy person, and when he starts cursing you out, well all you can really do is laugh about the whole thing cause its pretty damn funny.    You continue on with your other successfull trades and remember that its good to have a place where the majority of people are sensible and reasonable and not to take the bad apples too seriously.

is it an original ravnica foi? cause the RTR one is only 26 and reckoners are 12 each.  so two and change is reasonable. . .

85

(43 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I am down for a trade, but realize that deckbox is not only for trading.   its for card organization and a lot of people dont want to mail there cards but still enjoy having a great way to organize there collections.

I would love some sort of feature that allows us to screen traders seperately from other people who are not active or interested at all, and yeah seeing that someone has not logged in over two years . . well thats fine but remove it from the pool or something so it doesnt clog everything up for the rest of us.

yeah, and sent an offer but some of what i want is not showing up in your inventory

started discussion

started a talk

89

(3 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

started a talk but you have nothing in your wishlist

90

(1 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

bump

91

(1 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

as title says, need two for a deck. have a voice for trade

92

(11 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

started a trade

93

(6 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

add all the cards you want to your wishlist, i have plenty of the slivers you want but hard to figure out which ones you want if you dont have them listed.

after how many bumps can we assume no one is interested?

95

(1 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

interested, started trade

got one of each but not seeing anything in your tradelist remotely equal to it in price.

97

(2 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

yes,  add it to tradelist and then we can process it much easier

98

(0 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Need to for my new deck.  let me know if you have any for trade and find something I Have.

99

(0 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Yeah i need to finish my playset's,   if anyone has any for trade feel free to look through my tradelist for stuff.

also added plenty of stuff to my wishlist if anyone has anything i need.

I can do this