Bumb

Have promo scavenging oozes, looking for tradelist stuff.  Asking $15 in trade each for them.  Titans are pretty high on my want list right now though.  Even if you don't have anything on my wishlist, feel free to hit me up and I'll look at what you have.  Mostly interested in modern/legacy/vintage though.

103

(23 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

shifty4690 is correct.  The top loaders make the envelope ridged (non-machinable).  That's why you are required to add the extra 20¢.  It is not up to their discretion.  They often don't catch it (or they are just too lazy to care).  I've had many things come postage due, and I've also have them returned.  Depending on how much you owe, you might even have to goto the post office to get the item.  Point is, you shouldn't really be cheap about it.  It's fricking 20¢, if you can't afford that much extra.  You shouldn't be playing magic in the first place.

It goes like this:

(Regular envelope with top loader and less than 1/4 thick.)
1 ounce : 66¢
2 ounces : 86¢
3 ounces : $1.06
4 ounces : becomes large envelope rate which I don't remember exactly, but around $1.50


USPS is terrible about paying attention to the weight of items.  MANY ebay sellers under value shipping because they almost never get caught and that equals more money for them.  Pretty crappy, and people wonder why USPS keeps going up and up.  Probably the same people that use priority boxes inside of brown paper and the like (which is actually a felony.  You're stealing from the USPS)

Someone... anyone

H: 4x Boros Reckoner
W: 4x Deathrite Shaman

Scan of my Boros:  http://i1364.photobucket.com/albums/r73 … 4667e7.jpg

I showed the bold print godless shrine to a guy at the local card store.  He said that "misprinted" cards can be worth more sometimes.  Anyone have experience with that?

Recently opened a box a Gatecrash, Trading all the stuff I don't need.   A few weird things were inside.  Godless shrine with text that's too dark.  Looks like it was printed in bold (didnt have another GS to compare it to, but you can see the difference vs a normal shock).  Also a Maze's end that looks similar with slightly smeared ink.  Looking for random stuff, hit me up and I'll take a look at what you have.


http://i1364.photobucket.com/albums/r73 … 56ea03.jpg
http://i1364.photobucket.com/albums/r73 … a9a463.jpg

108

(12 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Nevpicasso wrote:

They can't be worth $20 right now when they come free with the purchase of a game that's $10.  At that rate, I can get 2 of them for $20.


Maybe where you live they are easy to get.  But last time I checked, gas and time cost money.  Besides those two things, most the stores around here don't have many (if any left) for the versions that get the Scavenging Ooze.  So no, they are not worth $10.  They are at least worth the presale price of magic 2014 ones.  Don't be mad cause the 4 you have now are all the sudden less cool!

Im taking offers as well!

Trading these for a friend, so I doubt I'll be able to trade for much else.

1x Cryptic Command (Lorwyn)
1x Cryptic Command (Modern Masters)

Both are NM

Autographed (Melissa Benson) Shivan Dragon for trade (Melissa Benson)  I would say it's condition is slightly played.  Asking $20 in trade  Getting harder to find her old autographs (Unless you are willing to pay for them.)

Autographed (Christopher Rush) Granite Gargoyle: Slightly played.  Not exactly sure what to ask, but I'll take offers.

http://i829.photobucket.com/albums/zz21 … fronts.jpg
http://i829.photobucket.com/albums/zz21 … /backs.jpg

If its really needed, I can scan them.  But I wont be able to until Monday or Tuesaday.

Have a few Dream Halls to trade, wanting a few things on my wishlist/Look at your trade list.

Have a few Dream Halls to trade, wanting a few things on my wishlist/Look at your trade list.

114

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

1 left

There's always Paypal gift payments (cost zero as long as its a bank to bank payment).  The buyer still has basically no recourse as far as Paypal is concerned.  But at least they will have proof that a transaction occurred.

116

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

added pics

117

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Just wanting to know if anyone's collecting autographed cards.  Terese Nielsen typically takes FOREVER to autograph and return stuff.

Asking $3.50 in trade each. OBO

http://i829.photobucket.com/albums/zz21 … AG0635.jpg

http://i829.photobucket.com/albums/zz21 … AG0636.jpg

One Left

118

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

mtgtradingthread wrote:

Yes,  good job at reading.  I said "unless you're doing a high volume of sales which add up".

You obviously don't pay attention to Ebay. KI's auctions close near or above average retail pretty regularly. He doesn't rely on "volume", he replies on his reputation and inventory.

Please have some sort of proof where you are trying to justify your "retail prices" All you did is avoid the question by saying that TCG mid is not retail.  Okay, how about we take all the big name sellers from TCG (2k + sales) and average their selling price for VoR.  Would you consider that retail?  Because it's still looking to be more than $50

TCGPlayer mid is not "retail" because TCGplayer mid is an aggregate of retailers. TCGPlayer low is realistic retail for cards in standard. Pretending like Ebay auctions don't exist is just stupid.

Yes, I understand eBay auctions.  Obviously you have zero understanding on what "retail price" means.  Standard has nothing to do with it at all. 

Are you trying to prove me right or wrong?  "TCGPlayer mid is not "retail" because TCGplayer mid is an aggregate of retailers."  Pro tip:  Retailers sell things at "retail" price.  So, you just told me that I shouldn't take a retailers (your word) price for something, because it isn't retail. Where do you think the word retail comes from. lol.   I'm confused.  Low end sellers on TCG are mostly just people trying to sell extra cards.  They aren't exactly what most people consider "retailers" (aka businesses) per sa.  The ones with many sales would be considered "Retailers".

119

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

That's fine if you don't want to compete against auctions on Ebay, but don't pretend like they aren't an option. If people care about saving a few bucks, they're going to do that. KidIcarus sells a ton of stuff - including power, beta duals, and foreign foil staples, through auction on ebay and makes good money doing it.

And TCGplayer mid is NOT retail

Yes,  good job at reading.  I said "unless you're doing a high volume of sales which add up".

Please have some sort of proof where you are trying to justify your "retail price" All you did is avoid the question by saying that TCG mid is not retail.  Okay, how about we take all the big name sellers from TCG (2k + sales) and average their selling price for VoR.  Would you consider that retail?  Because it's still looking to be more than $50


I apologize that this thread has been completely turned into a debate.  Who ever thought selling a few trading cards would upset someone.


If anyone has cards plus + cash that they'd like to offer.  Please feel free to me up via trade or email.  I'm almost always looking for sets of shock land and Deathrite Shamans! I have a few things on my wishlist too, although it's hardly complete.

120

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

ColtonisWright wrote:

I traded my voice at $56...

http://deckbox.org/trades/97576?s=28915



At the end of the day, we're just telling you that people probably won't buy at that price on this site. You can justify your prices all you'd like, but there may be a reason why no one is biting. If you want to move them, then look around, there are many people looking for voices at full value too.


I'm not even tripping, I don't honestly even care that much.  I just think I have to defend the sellers point of view when people are getting all crazy talking about $40 is retail.  GTFO.  According to that dude, ebay auction prices are now retail.  Ya, don't we wish lol.

But thanks for the feedback!

121

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

June 20 38/shipped, 40/shipped, 39/shipped, 40/shipped, 35.66/shipped, 35.88/shipped, FOUR at 37/shipped

People don't flip out, but it's annoying that people use this forum as a resource for selling shit at retail prices.


lol you must be checking auction prices.  Sorry I didn't clarify.  Only morons sell using eBay's auction  (unless you're doing a high volume of sales which add up). I was talking about how much you can buy one right now for.  Guess what? Auctions aren't right now. It might take you a while to win at the price you want.  Compare apples to apples.  Feel free to go back and check for buy in now prices.  You typically lose 10-35% of "retail value"  buy auctioning.   Last I checked, isn't TCG mid "retail" price? The price that's $12+ more than I'm asking.  Locally, the card stores i goto all have them in the $50's.  Please let me know which retail store is selling them for $40.

122

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

frkbmr wrote:

If you're posting here to sell at TCG prices, what would be the point in us buying it from you? Why not just buy it from TCG, where we can raise a dispute if something goes wrong along the way? I'm almost willing to bet that most people that want a Voice would be willing to do it a full trade value, and not buy it at full value.

Then you'd lose that bet. I've yet to have one person offer full value even vs other standard cards via trade or email.   If you've been reading from the start, you'd see that I'm still $5 cheaper than TCG shipped.  I was only pointing out that if people post stuff for high prices people get all mad for no reason.  It's all fine though.  I can wait to sell them, or trade if someone actually offers me a a fair exchange.

123

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Not everyone is cheap, but sellers seem to be delusional about prices sometimes. If someone is going to shell out cash for Voice, which is a card that is definitely going to tank, why would they pay you retail when they can get the card for ~38 shipped on an ebay auction?

Not argue with you, but there are zero on ebay for $38 (how about you do an average selling price for the last 7 days and report back). Sure, occasionally an idiot will post one for a lot less.  But they are probably hard for cash or something. It's not the norm.  Pricing and availability is always fluctuating there.  I have had a successful eBay business for more than 3 years (nothing to do with MTG) so I know very well how things work on ebay.  Asking less than what is typical is hardly delusional.  I could be asking $45 +shipping and I would still be in line with many sellers.  but jeez, if I did that here.  People would flip the F out like I was trying to rob them.

124

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I completely understand that.  But it's confusing when MANY people have VoR in their wishlist, but then offer you 50% it's value in trade value.  That's just stupid.  Why then even have it in your wish list? It would be nice if this site could select priorities in your trade.  Some people kind of do it themselves by changing the want quantity, but that messes up searches and it's not standardized at all.

125

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Paul_K wrote:

I just sold 6 (avg $38) in the past two days so the market may not be there anymore (for purchase that is) or they find $42 just a tad bit too expensive.  This serves as informatory only.

Not to offend people on this forum, but most seem cheap lol.  Especially the people who aren't playing actually playing standard.  The people who think their legacy/modern card's monetary value is some how worth more than a standard card's value.  I do understand that they want to trade against the future value of the card, but ummm.  This isn't the future, this is today, the present.  VoR is priced the way is it because Dragon's Maze sucked as a set (for the most part).  No one's opening boxes to sell singles like they'd normally be doing.  Supply and demand.  If people weren't willing to pay in the mid $40's for them, you'd never see TCG's inventory change.  But hey, I'm just a ranting.  Have a good day!

Cheapest on TCG (NM) is $45-$46 + shipping.  So I figured $80 shipped for 2 is a decent price.  No, it's not "cheap" but I'm not hurting for cash.