Cards in Decks Stuck on Tradelist?

I'll start off by saying I do have Premium and that I have enabled automatically putting cards not in my decks to my tradelist.

The problem I'm having is, it seems it's randomly throwing cards in my decks onto my tradelist with no rhyme or reason. I have 6x Nythos, Shrine to Nyx all are tagged in decks, but it says I have 3 to trade from those 6. I even went as far as deleting those from my decks, then removing them from my inventory. Then adding them to deck/inventory and it still had the same result. I have 2x Bow of Nylea's in decks, it says 1 is for trade. I have 5x Fyndhorn Elves in decks, it says 1 is for trade. I'm sure it goes on and on, it just seems very random.

Is there a way to fix this besides manually tagging all of my trade? Or am I stuck with it?