Can someone leave me Neutral Feedback insinuating I took their cards? Long story short, I never received a Scalding Tarn from someone so he eventually had to send my cards back to me (almost 2 months later). I looked today and he finally had left neutral feedback saying, "My card disappeared on this trade". Thanks ahead of time for answering.

Neutral feedback can left at the discretion of the either party. Its not something that needs to get approved or denied in order to be left and has no bearing on your overall feedback score. If the other user did not use tracking to when sending the card and it was lost by the PO, then the blame shouldnt really fall on you for the card being lost.

Thanks for the quick reply Helios. I just really didn't like the remark left...I don't want others thinking I stole something from a member. He didn't use tracking the first time and took a very long time to send my things back. I never filed a report and left him neutral feedback with no remark. It's just crappy that he turned around and did that. Kind of leaves a bad taste in my mouth :/

I had almost the exact same thing happen to me. No cards got lost, but the guy I was trading with's cards took an excessive amount of time to arrive. I left neutral because of the time and he left retaliatory neutral because I was "impatient." lol

Oh wow lol. That's ridiculous. Mods should take things like that off of your feedback. This guy received my cards within 4 days, but I still have neutral feedback for his cards getting lost.