Lorwyn Eclipsed
releases on January 23, 2026!

Preorder now on CardKingdom Preorder now on TcgPlayer

Lorwyn Eclipsed
releases on January 23, 2026!

Preorder now on CardKingdom Preorder now on TcgPlayer
1 total results       Page 1 of 1
You must login or register to post a new reply
Posts [ 1 to 1 ]
Trade score 0 (100%)
Members
Registered: 20-Aug-2013 00:50
First I just want to say that, coming back to MTG after 12 years, this site is freaking amazing. It beats the he11 out of every automated/scripted spreadsheet we ever hacked together back in the day, and I can't thank you enough for making it free. Cheers to you, my friends.

Now to business: I would like to propose two updates to the way mana costs are handled.

1) Filtering: This is more of a semantics issue than a bug. While browsing Magic cards via the Advanced Search, when I filter by Cost the option names are "Is smaller than" and "Is largen than" (that typo exists in the UI, incidentally). If I set the filter to "Cost is smaller than 2" I would expect to see only cards with a casting cost of 0 or 1; however, cards that cost 2 also appear in the list. I would propose that the options be changed to "Is less than or equal to" and "Is greater than or equal to" - that way it's only a UI change and no logic needs to be updated, but the law of least surprise is followed.

2) Sorting: Right now, when I sort my decks by Cost, cards seem to get sorted by their converted mana cost without any regard to the number or types of colored mana they take to cast. I don't know what the TCGPlayer data looks like, and it could be that other players don't care about this sort of thing, but when I'm considering the cost of a card, I consider colorless mana to be slightly less expensive than colored mana. In other words, if I was sorting white cards with a converted mana cost of three the order would always be: WWW > 1WW > 2W. And indeed, when you get into multicolor cards, the more colors required, the more expensive: BWG > BWW > WWW.

These are just my 2¢ on what is already a great application. Please keep up the great work! :)
-decompiler-
Posts [ 1 to 1 ]
1 total results       Page 1 of 1
You must login or register to post a new reply