Search options (Page 51 of 54)

First, would you mind moving the last post about the new deck to another thread?  It helps me keep things straight.  I'll happily comment on it there.

Okay, so for the flicker deck...

For the Snapcasters, I completely understand why you're using them (lord knows, if everyone else is, why not?).  Personally I've always liked breaking from the norms a bit with my decks and not going with everyone else's ideas (hence my distaste for Hellnikko's Delver deck).  However, given the straying from the flicker theme, I'm curious if you might be better served to just make this a pure artifact token generation deck, rather than trying to hang onto something that's not the key mechanic going on.  For instance, Tezzeret, the Seeker would let you pull the Blightsteel Colossus same as Shape Anew but without the fear of countering (unless they counter him, at which point you've used one of their counters and have better odds of successfully getting Shape Anew out.

The key for the Platinum Emperion is that it will almost certainly prolong the game for long enough that you could either get a Blightsteel or otherwise pull off Venser's third ability or even something else nasty.  In response to the Vault of the Archangel, the deathtouch COULD screw with the Emperion, but only if they're using it for a blocker.  If they're attacking, just let the creatures through, as your life total won't change anyway.  To that end, you could also swing a Darksteel Colossus as it's indestructible.  All three of them are golems, so they would get the flying and whatnot from the splicers too.

My other thought on including Sundial of the Infinite is obvious with the permanent exiling mechanic, but it also would make the opponent have to consider more than just Shape Anew as a target for their counterspells.  It's addition by substraction, as you're less likely to Shape Anew into Blightsteel Colossus but it will make them pay more mind to Glimmerpoint Stag, Venser, Oblivion Ring or a wealth of other things.

My reasoning for Elspeth over Gideon or the others is her third ability when mixed with a flickering mechanic.  She can completely clear the board with the exceptions of tokens and, if flickered, herself and perhaps another key permanent or two.  You dump her ability and then before it resolves Ghostly Flicker her and one of the splicers... you end up completely screwing your opponent, keeping your tokens, generating a new token, and laughing your way to victory.

Lastly, I know the ability is expensive for Nephalia Smuggler, but it ensures at least one more way to flicker things so that you can save Cloudshift for more dire circumstances (or they can help protect Deadeye Navigator).  Perhaps I'm still too hung up on flickering (as my deck isn't complete yet so I've yet to really play it), but I'm thinking that it still is at the center of something really fun.

Obviously "Control" includes a LOT of possibilities.  Could you be more specific what you struggled against?

As far as counterspells and the like are concerned, based on what you said I would imagine you'll benefit more from Turn Aside than Mana Leak or Negate.  I like how Shape Anew works for you here as Blightsteel Colossus is the only artifact there.  I would suggest adding Platinum Emperion in the place of one Colossus, as then they REALLY need to focus on removal to even try to beat you (and it's standard legal through October).  Considering the amount of flickering you have, it should be relatively easy to protect one creature, especially with the addition of Turn Aside. 

Also, if you're sitting on a Tamiyo, you might as well give her a shot in place of one of the Vensers.  After all, you can't have both Vensers out there and you might as well make them think twice regarding which planeswalker they want to focus on.

I can see where Tempered Steel could help, but 3/3 creatures en masse aren't easy to deal with on their own.  There's definitely no need for Levitation as you already have flying defense/offense with Wingcrafter and Wing Splicer.  Day of Judgement could be fun, but only if you manage to flicker your important creatures when it hits.

I'm anxious to hear how this continues to play out as you already know my Power Bill deck is similar (although still under construction as I'm getting the remaining cards).

First off, I'm with imsully on Avacyn's Pilgrim over the Llanowar Elves.  However, to be honest, I would drop either in favor of Abundant Growth, as it doesn't help the mana ramping, but helps you draw cards and can allow you to use ANY land for any color, so then if you get six of any land, you should be set to go.  I'd also find a way to include Wingcrafter to be able to make your creatures flying (even if it comes at the cost of Squadron Hawk).  Then you have the flying defense but also can generate flying offense.  The one thing I'm concerned about here is the fact that outside of Sovereigns of Lost Alara, if you don't draw Eldrazi Conscription in the first few turns, you really don't have much going on.  Perhaps you could build in a few larger creatures or some other means to ensure that you can remain competitive.  Lastly, while you have a means to make your creatures hexproof, remember that they're still free to target an enchantment on said hexproof creature.

For Cranberries, I've actually tried a copy of this deck myself with quite limited results if you start adding other cards.  While Endless Ranks of the Dead helps to generate more zombies, it could easily kill the deck's momentum, such that if you don't have another Treasure Hunt in hand, you could be up the creek for 10+ turns.  I would actually suggest including two Elixir of Immortality and taking out the Endless Ranks.  Also, how many turns are you willing to mulligan to get the right hand for this deck?  I've had to go three or four times before I have a hand with anything good.

For Land Hate, I get that it's someone else's deck design so I understand if you can't really explain the full reasoning the other person had, but I'm curious both what the win condition and typical expected play are.  I have a land destruction deck as well, but mine operates mono-red with Meekstone, Circle of Flame, Vulshok Sorcerer, Lightning Bolt, Cerebral Eruption, and a few others meant to stall the opponents' options until the land destruction really gets going.  Those can buy a LOT of valuable time since land destruction doesn't really start going until you have three or four mana at your disposal.  I do like Invader Parasite though and would recommend looking into expanding beyond Standard format.  Dual Casting and Pyromancer Ascension would also work wonders here as you can take out two lands with each spell, as opposed to only one and waiting for Charmbreaker Devils to get the spells back.  Lastly, Pillage and Stone Rain are definitely good for land destruction decks.  Check out mine at http://deckbox.org/sets/142613 and feel free to ask anything you want if it will help yours out.

Lastly, for the R/W Humans, just a few thoughts.  First, this is screaming for Mentor of the Meek, Thraben Doomsayer, Commander's Authority, and Elixir of Immortality.  The Mentors will let you rip through the deck very quickly while both the Doomsayers and Authorities will pop out added creatures (while also helping the Mentors let you cut through the deck).  Elixir will let you stay alive until you can overpower the enemy while also letting you recycle your spells.  It will give you life gain that allows you to remove Alabaster Mage.  I'll again second imsully on including another Cathars' Crusade, trust me when I say this will help make the creatures dangerous, and fast.  I'd also suggest Mad Prophet as he's another human who will help you burn through the deck, but that's up to you to decide on.

Best luck!

I see the error in my ways to begin with, as I simply assumed that an online/electronic version of the game would track your cards automatically.

I'm with mbknight on this, just go get the real cards (going outside and actually seeing other people is good for you ).

And I've found the answer to my own question...

http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=305124

So I would actually be able to let loose a bear-induced mill storm mid-combat phase by sacking the attacking creatures to Altar of Dementia... good times!

But I have a question that I'm not seeing in the WotC Bear Umbra rulings. 

A hypothetical scenario:  You have two creatures that both have the Umbra.  You tap all your lands for whatever shenanigans you want prior to the combat phase.  Then you attack with both creatures that both have the Umbra.  You untap your lands as a result of one creature with the Umbra attacking.  But could you tap the lands for mana and add those to your pool between the two Umbra effects resolving?  Then you would add X to your mana pool, where X is what is produced when you tap all your lands, and the second Umbra would untap them again for you to be able to tap again (essentially giving you a total of 3X mana in one turn).  If not, you're just untapping everything that's already untapped, which would be a bummer.

Thoughts?

The revised version of the creature removal deck looks solid.

For Enchant This, it looks good in general, but I can see where a few edits might be warranted. 

First, you only have 12 creatures, what happens if your creatures get blown up?  To that end, Asceticism would work wonders here.  It still generates +1/+1 for the Yavimaya Enchantress and +2/+2 for Ancestral Mask while ensuring that your creatures don't get blasted by simple removal spells.

Second, given that so many of your pumping enchantments are based on how many forests you have in play, you need some means by which to get forests out faster.  I'm thinking Rites of Flourishing as it will speed up the game, let you put two (or more if you have more than one out) lands down per turn and will just help speed the game up for you.

Third, I would recommend Verduran Enchantress as she will help you draw more cards.  Remember that victories can come from the degree to which you're able to keep cards coming into your hand while your opponents are sitting there top-decked.

Fourth, to speed things up a bit more, I'd suggest putting Bear Umbra into the mix.  The beauty there is that when a creature with it attacks, it untaps all your mana, meaning that you can play all you want on the front end, attack, and then dump more out after combat.  When paired with the Verduran Enchantress, that would work wonders.

Lastly, as with most mono-green decks, you need some sort of a way to make the kill when they have a sizable defense.  If you presume for a moment that Aura Gnarlid is countered or killed all four times, then what?  The other creatures are blockable without too much trouble unless you put Rancor on them.  To that end, why not throw Lure in?  It will help divert the enemy's blockers while your other creatures waltz their way in to make the kill.

So how can you include all these cards and still stay around 60 cards?  First, don't be afraid to step up to 65 cards if need be, as 24 land should be sufficient (given that nothing costs more than five to play).  Also, if you knock your counts down to three of each, you'll generate some room to add the new cards.

I hope that works out for you.  Again, most of what I've suggested is above $0.50 per card, so you should be able to swing them pretty easily.  (I think Asceticism is the only one worth more than that, and one or two of them would be sufficient).

Now for your green deck...

I'm liking the deathtouch spread throughout the deck, but I'm not really seeing the multiplayer win condition.  Normally green's strength is to mana ramp and either dump 5,000 creatures to overwhelm the enemy or one HUGE one to overpower anything in your way.  Again, I'm liking the deathtouch creatures and the lures, but I'm not seeing where you have any options if you don't have at least one Lure and deathtouch.  But I have a few questions.

First, why Birds of Paradise?  They help generate mana and are definitely flexible if you're trying to splash some other colors in, but for mono-green, why not just rock Llanowar Elves?  You could use the Birds in another deck or otherwise unload them for something more useful like a Primordial Hydra.

Second, is Lumberknot the only real power play here?  What if he were to be countered or wiped out with a non-targeting ability, i.e., Massacre Wurm?  Then what?  Asceticism would help here, as you can regen your creatures while also protecting them from removal or most other effects.

Third, you have some anti-flying stuff here, which is good, but if you're not worried about sticking to extended format, green has the best anti-flying card out there in Katabatic Winds.  Sure the phasing means it won't be in effect every other turn, but that's why you have more than one.  If you play two out on alternate turns, creatures with flying are completely useless for the remainder of the game.

Fourth, I like Greenhilt Trainee, but as currently constructed, you only have two cards that will ever get him above the necessary power for more than one turn.  There are plenty of options here.  Bear Umbra is one sweet choice.  Trusted Forcemage won't quite get him there on his own, but could definitely help.  Hunger of the Howlpack is another good one if things are dying from the deathtouch creatures.

Lastly, as a thought, I saw you had Darksteel Plate in the Altered Knight deck.  Why not put those in here?  An indestructible, lured, deathtouch creature would be quite troublesome for your opponent(s).

Alright, you'll have to forgive me for the lengthy response in advance, as there are seven decks to talk through here.  So with no further delay...

Captain America - I see what you did there with the red, white and blue.  Champion of the Parish is great and could be a monster when combined with the other humans entering the battlefield (especially with Cathars' Crusade) - Wingcrafter making it flying would also be nice.  But, I can see a number of problems with this one.  First, where do your blue mana come from?  Second, to the same end, does it really need the third color?  I get how the name works with it being three colors, but from a playing perspective, cutting it to just two colors would work wonders.  If you wanted to remove the red, Thatcher Revolt could be replaced with Timely Reinforcements that both produces human tokens that don't die at the end of the turn and it could possibly give you six life for the same cost.  Then, you can replace the Zealous Conscripts with Commander's Authority and even add another Cathars' Crusade to increase the likelihood you pull one.  Then at turn five, you're producing humans every turn that are pumping up your CotPs or everything else with Cathars' Crusade.  I can speak from experience that combo gets nasty REALLY fast.  Third, why the emphasis on flickering here?  Outside of Zealous Conscript and a few other counters for CotP, you really aren't getting as much benefit as you could.  I can see where some other spells, either for control or drawing, would be more effective here.  Fourth, I'm not a big fan of Fling, especially when all the creatures you have are so essential to the deck's functioning.  What would you fling?  One of the CotPs?  Why not just attack and keep him?  Anything smaller wouldn't really do any major damage.  If you're looking for removal, Pillar of Flame is a NICE choice - note the exiling part of it.  Lastly, and this is a theme I'll hammer on, outside of Wingcrafter bonding, where is the flyer defense?  Do you think that's enough?

Germans - I guess I can see where the deck name comes in, but that requires me to think of CoD Zombies...  I like these sorts of decks because then there isn't any way for the opponent to block.  The problem, however, is that you end up having to make them drop 60-70, which is certainly more to deal with than the 20 life you normally think about.   To offer a few thoughts based on a combo I run in my discard deck, I like working Trepanation Blade with Altar of Dementia and Keening Stone.  The idea is to take a swing with a creature, let Trepanation Blade do it's discarding damage.  Then you sack the creature before it loses that power boost to cause your opponent to drop that many more cards.  I've seen that combo result in somewhere around 10-15 cards being dropped in one fell swoop.  Then the real one you need will be Keening Stone which, as I'm sure you can imagine, snowballs VERY fast.  What I'm not seeing is why you have Vampire Hexmage in here?  Just to remove the undying counter from the Mindcrusher?  If so, why not run Power Conduit?  It's a bit dated, but it would let you remove as many of those counters as you want while also pumping up the other creatures.

Nightmare 2 - I'm seeing some familiar combos here , where is Roil Elemental?  I'm also not following why Sundial of the Infinite (and then Buried Ruin) are in here.  While I can see where you would try to end the turn before the Geist's angel goes away, combat is technically over once the opponent's turn starts, so that's no dice.  So if you can fill me in on that front, I'm curious.  My suggestions would probably be self-serving here to move you more toward my Power Bill deck, so I'll stop on this one, suffice to say I'm curious how well it plays.

Screwed Up - I like the pairing of Unwinding Clock and Chalice of Life.  I can see where that'd be, well, for lack of a better way to say it, a dick move.   You might want to consider adding Recumbent Bliss, Martyr of Sands, and perhaps most importantly, Cradle of Vitality.  Cradle is SICK as any creature with lifelink can double in size for only two mana, all while you're still gaining life.  When paired with the other life gaining things you have in there, you can definitely see where you can make your creatures grow quickly.  I actually won a very drawn out multiplayer game because of Cradle paired with Felidar Sovereign, as the vigilance and lifelink let me attack, keeping a blocker while gaining life and doubling the Sovereign each turn with the Cradle.  I would actually suggest that you drop the Leonin Relic-Warder and Fiend Hunter for some sort of flying defense (see it came up again ) like Kemba's Skyguard and something else directed toward life gain like Soul's Attendant.

Altered Knight - Why have the red even in the deck if it's only for three cards?  Why not just switch to mono-white?  I'll be a stickler here too, but again, what about the opposing flyers?  I see Leonin Skyhunter, but what if they remove those?  Then you're up the creek, right?  There are a number of white flying knights available (I'm digging Skyhunter Prowler or Skyhunter Skirmisher, or for a good laugh with your friends, Ladies' Knight ).

Spirit U/W - I know it's been done to death, but it's almost required to have Lingering Souls in here, isn't it?  Shimmering Grotto already splashes in a few black to flash it back, otherwise you could just live with it coming out once and being gone (or using another card to get it back, i.e., Elixir of Immortality, which you have in the deck already).  Some of those Adaptive Automatons you have in Altered Knight could work in here too.  I should note that this is the first deck I've seen that has a means of combatting getting top-decked.  I'm a big fan of Call to the Kindred in single creature subtype decks.

Delver - Really?  C'mon man.  Delver has been done to death by everyone.  It might work, but I'd suggest blowing it up out of spite.  If you were really going to stick to it, I would recommend centering around Runechanter's Pike and unblockable creatures like Invisible Stalker, Phantom Warrior, or even Blighted Agent.  I think that would be far more amusing than just another Delver deck.  But that's just my two cents.

Alrighty then, I've written about three pages here, so I'll shut up.  I hope some of those suggestions help.  As I'm sure you already know, playtest, playtest, playtest.  Unless you're copying someone else's deck, there's no way to know if my ideas are any better than yours.  Also, poor green and black feel neglected.