Do you need all the cards listed?  The decklist doesn't seem to show what you have and don't have.  I have some stuff for trade that is in your Politics deck (Grand Arbiter, Consecrated Sphinx, etc.).

Even a single negative feedback could have a huge effect on somebody here.  I think it should be reserved for people who screw you over.  If someone is dragging their feet there's nothing stopping you from sending the person a message asking them to shit or get off the pot.

Here is one idea, which is used on another forum I sometimes use: have a separate subforum devoted to feedback, and the topics are peoples' usernames.  If you have feedback for a person, you post a reply to the thread about that person (or start one if there isn't one already).  Feedback can obviously be positive or negative, and you can easily find information about an individual by just finding their thread in the feedback subforum.

Just an idea...I'm not saying it's the best answer necessarily.

Theoretically the feedback system should let people know about bad traders.  What could threads on here add to that?  (By asking that I'm not implying they couldn't, but legitimately asking how it might be better.)

I don't need Lilianas anymore.  In fact, I may have a couple for trade soon.  Still looking for Bobs though.

6

(1 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I have two Heros to trade...I'll check your list and get in touch with you.

I'm pretty sure I have a foil Melira and some of the other stuff.  I'll double-check when I get home tonight and get back to you privately.

8

(16 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Just clarify it with the person you're trading with ahead of time.  If you're both okay with using regular envelopes, more power to you.

My tradelist isn't up-to-date so take a look at my inventory.  Not everything is for trade, but a lot of it is and the worst that can happen is I'll say something's not for trade smile

Off the top of my head, though, I can say the following aren't for trade: Snapcaster, Scars lands, Damnation, Obliterators.

Thanks!

10

(16 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

SuicidalFate0 wrote:

agreed even if in a regular envelope top loaders work as well.

I strongly disagree.  I recently ordered some Koths on ebay and the seller sent them in top loaders, but in a regular envelope.  The envelope wore away and tore during shipping to the point the cards were nearly falling out of it when they arrived.  I was shocked none were missing.

Unless the person you're trading with is okay with you using a regular envelope, use sturdy packaging.  And remember to save bubble mailers because you can reuse them!

11

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

The Lich has been traded.  Thanks for the offers though.

I'm in Colorado and have Heros to trade.  Contact me if you're interested.

13

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I'd also trade it for a Huntmaster of the Fells.

14

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I opened a foil Havengul Lich today.  I'd like to trade it for a non-foil Havengul Lich and something else to make up the difference.  Contact me if you're interested.