Right now there are two different sidebars, the 'User' sidebar for settings and navigating a collection (My Favorites w/ Edit Profile, Settings, Friends; Magic The Gathering w/ Inventory, Wishlist, etc) and the 'Search' sidebar (Magic The Gathering w/ Card Database, All Decks, Top Decks, same for Warhammer and WoW).

This is confusing. It would be easier if they were combined into a single sidebar that didn't change.

Yep, we were just talking about his a few days ago. We want to come up with a better menu system.

My vote is for putting the User sidebar on top of the Search sidebar, and adding an MTG Searchbox so that one is always available.

Anyways, just my two cents, thanks for all your had work and making such a great site!