I was going to put these up on ebay but decided to check here first. I have two NM-M (in cases since I got them so many years ago) Guru Lands. One is a plain, other is a mountain. I play standard, working on a RDW deck, but will trade for other stuff.

What do you value the mountain at?

There are 2 on ebay, one is 75$ the other is 100$, since they are still there I'm going to assume it is somewhere in the 60-75$ range? Anyone help me out here?

mpinsky wrote:There are 2 on ebay, one is 75$ the other is 100$, since they are still there I'm going to assume it is somewhere in the 60-75$ range? Anyone help me out here?

This may not be very popular with people, but I would value it at $100 if I were you. Star City Games has a Guru Mountain for $100. Now, if you were asking cash, I could see going with eBay prices. But, when trading a card you should try to get as much value out of
It as you can. At least I would. Lastly, these cards are HIGHLY collectible. Do not let anyone rip you off.

Just make sure you use Star City Games to price everyone's cards do that the trade is still fair.

The average on tcg player is 95 as well man. As tempted as I am to just trade you 60 bucks worth of my RDW deck, its still a rip off... Get your moneys worth! They are very sought after land. Id recomend putting in your bio(if you havent) that you have guru land. You could easily get playsets of tamiyos, snaps, caven of souls; really anything thats sought after in standard.

You guys... I like you guys. Thanks, I'm just getting back into the "scene" and found these 2 lands and figure one of them could pay for a standard simplistic RDW deck.

thanks again.

I would be willing to trade everything you need on your wishlist (I may have to hunt down the commons) except 2 Vexing Devils (I only have 2 to trade) for one of your lands. Sound good?

Guys help me out... is that good?

Money wise? No, you could get more.

Card wise? You're trading something you'd probably never use for stuff you would use.

If you go to your wishlist and click View, then "Show Value," you can see the value of all the cards on your list. He's excluding the two Vexing Devils, so you'd be getting about $60 in cards. In other words, no, it's not a good trade.

I know I am a bit biased since I am the one trying to trade but I think that you are getting rid of a card that you will never use for almost a deck.

If you think you could do better than my offer than please politely decline. It is no skin off my nose, I am just trying to be nice and make a deal.

Trust me, if we end up trading that land will sit in my binder probably until I can unload it at a star city event or Gencon.

Well yeah I'll never use it, but I'm just getting back into magic, and hey, if it's worth more than it's worth more, if you had the other 2 devils I'd do it in a heart beat.

Yeah if I had the cards that Scurvy is offering, I would make that trade in a heartbeat. Even trading a guru land for your entire wishlist is kind of a rip off, and you should try to get more.

Thanks for the honesty. I think I'll stick around here.

Fair enough. Out of curiosity, How much more (dollar wise) would I have to trade you before you would be willing to trade it off?

Everyone satys 95-100, so... 95-100.