Search options (Page 24 of 54)

The alternative that's starting to see a lot more constructed play is Underworld Connections.  Many people doubted it would be useful as it's three mana and doesn't actually net you a card until you can tap the land again to draw the card, but the repeated instances of card advantage is undeniable.  That and enchantment and land removal are considerably less frequent than creature removal.  As elpablo says, you could cast Altar's Reap on a mana dork to draw cards, they can Shock the mana dork at instant speed, putting theirs on top of the stack and meaning when time comes for the reap to resolve... no dork to sack.  With the Connections, you're far more likely to have success drawing cards for turns and turns and turns.

This isn't really striking me as an aggro build as much as you're going for something mid-rangey.

That being said, you really have two choices - go with the mid-range strategy and keep Farseek (but you're going to need removal or some life gain to survive very long) OR take it to an aggro build, at which point you NEED to lower the curve dramatically - as you're not really going to be pressuring the opponent in the early turns as currently constructed.

Think about how the solid aggro decks run.  It's incredibly common to have 6 power's worth of creatures on the board on turn 2.  Your deck, best case scenario could manage 5 power, one of them being a mana dork.  Not only does it require a PERFECT draw, but it will have it spread on two creatures, as opposed to the 3 for the more traditional aggro decks. 

Going Naya is fine, but I don't see you reliably being able to cast the Reckoners on T3... perhaps knock them down to 2-3x.  If you're aggro in these colors, where is Burning-Tree Emissary?  They give you the red mana you need for a T2 Domri if you manage a dork on T1.  No Elvish Mystics or Arbor Elf?  I'd also consider Voice to be more of a defensive card than an aggro one.  You could easily cut Rubblebelt Raiders as well.

As you're currently constructed I just see you being too split, especially considering the number of shocks you're going to be playing... but then again, I could be wrong.  I just don't see this performing consistently without the checklands.  Which raises the question, why aren't they in here?  You have several other cards that are rotating out... so why not them too for the time being?

I'm not going to lie, four color is definitely out of my comfort zone, but it almost seems silly not to be taking advantage of the gatekeepers from DGM (especially Saruli Gatekeepers) and Greenside Watcher.  To be honest, I'm not entirely sure Hold the Gates is as effective as Sphere of Safety or something like that.  You could easily toss in Detention Sphere, Pacifism and things of that like to up your enchantment count.  Or maybe you could do more of a control build with it.

All that being said, I know a potential finisher would be to toss in Prophet of Kruphix to maximize your ability to burn them out with Crackling Perimeter.  I could also see where Maze's End should be in here to let you tutor up the gates needed to play what's in your hand.

Am I correct that the real win-con is to smash them with Gateway Shade?  It certainly is different...

As you can tell I'm pretty much just spitballing here... let me know if any of that helps.

As long as you've put tracking on it, that's about all that you can do.  If the USPS is just bouncing it around, you might be able to ask that they simply put a stop on it and return it to you so that you could send it via UPS or another private courier.  The better question is, did the other person send you cards and did they get to you (at which point things get more complicated).

Both M13 and the entire Innistrad block (Innistrad, Dark Ascension, and Avacyn Restored) will rotate on the 27th. 

Keep in mind that any cards from those sets that have been reprinted in M14, RTR, GTC, or DGM will still be legal as they're printed in a current set.  So just because your Doom Blade is from M12 doesn't make it illegal to play, as Doom Blade is currently legal from its printing in M14.

I think post-rotation three color builds are going to be harder to operate given the departure of the checklands (and the continued presence of Burning Earth in red sideboards).  Personally I'm looking to build simple G/B with an emphasis on Reaper of the Wild, Desecration Demon, and things of that nature.  Ramping into a rather large Gaze of Granite with 1 or more Reapers out will essentially turn into a tutor effect, while also maintaining some serious board presence.

That being said, even mono-black control is looking more and more promising every day.

This is incorrect - FNM varies by location and over-time.  I used to go to a store that would cycle between standard, modern, and sealed play for FNMs.  Even having just relocated, I can say that both the stores I've scouted out also vary between drafts, standard constructed, and other formats.

What're you aiming for?  Casual play?  FNMs?  Any format preference?

Simply stating "I have four Deathrite Shamans, someone build me a deck" isn't likely to generate a lot of input - especially when you offer little to no guidance regarding what you want to play.  Even the decklist you provide isn't able to be critiqued unless we have a sense of what you're aiming for.

Not to be a stickler, but the Deckbox trading rules stipulate that you allow up to two weeks for shipping before filing a BTR.  That aside, relax a bit.  I know it can be nerve racking to ship out $20+ worth of cards in the mail with no guarantee that you'll be getting your agreed compensation in return, but alas, such are the perils of online trading. 

If the person has a high enough trade rating (more than 10) then I would imagine that, as UnstableFlux said, something probably just popped up.  Leave them a message in the trade box and feel free to privately message them, but again, just relax and let things play out.  If after two weeks you still don't have anything and the user doesn't respond, then you can go ahead with posting a BTR.

I'd had the thought of doing a tribal beast deck when Advocate of the Beast was first spoiled, but the biggest problem is that your #1 option beast is rotating, #goodbyeThragtusk.  It MIGHT still be feasible but I don't see where it will be all that competitive, as you're essentially just playing a collection of sub-par creatures that don't normally see play because of a combo with one guy that only equates to adding one counter to a creature per turn (not exactly the scariest thing in the world).  Your opponents will likely catch on after the first game and can easily just pick off the Advocates when they hit the field... trust me on this, I tried a similar thing with Slumbering Dragon when M13 hit.

That being said, if you're set on the deck idea, here are some ideas for you.

1) Elvish Mystics - not beasts, but mana rampers to help your curve.  Think T2 Advocate, T3 Rumbling Baloth.  Then you're at least attacking with a 5/5 on T4.  Still not ideal though as you could just CAST a 5/5 Deadbridge Goliath on T3... Also, Reverent Hunter could easily be a 5/5 on T2 in the right build once Theros hits.

2) Species Gorger - you NEED to remove this card.  The 6/6 body is attractive, but you HAVE to return a creature to your hand.  If the opponent is smart, they clear out your other creatures and you end up just casting and re-casting the gorger (which you really don't want to do, as you'll never be able to attack with him).  Again, I had grand ideas for Roaring Primadox in M13 and ran into the same issues.

3) Sapphire Drake - I could see as a 2x or 3x, but at 4x you're really making your curve top heavy.  Sure, it will evolve some stuff and give flying, but odds are your creatures are going to be pretty large to start with.  The flying strikes me almost like overkill in most cases.

4) Pit Fight - Decent removal, but I would suggest you use Rapid Hybridization instead.  It's cheaper, it can remove their major threats and replace them with 3/3s OR in a pinch can be used to upgrade one of your underperforming creatures.

5) Why not go with a full playset of Renegade Krasis?

6) Prime Speaker Zegana?  Evolves EVERYTHING and gets you some pretty sick card draw?

7) You don't really have one-drops.  This solidifies the need for Elvish Mystic.

8) I would actually suggest using Agoraphobia.  It's soft removal that is REALLY versatile for what you're doing.  You could either a) use it to negate one of their threats or b) reduce the power of one Renegade Krasis, ensuring that it will evolve no matter what you put onto the field.  Best of all, you can use even one copy for both purposes given that you can return it to your hand.

9) Given that you're in blue, you REALLY need some means of generating additional card advantage - whether it be Zameck Guildmage or Fathom Mage either one gives you card draw and some versatility.  I would suggest the guildmage as it can both bring things in larger, helping to trigger evolve and guarantee everything has counters, AND it can remove counters from Renegade Krasis letting it evolve.

10) Kalonian Hydra says hello (Expensive, yes.  But also perfectly suited for this deck.)

Having said all of this, if Renegade Krasis operates as the central piece behind the counter generation, you NEED to be sure that you have numerous creatures that will evolve it without any added pieces.  Rumbling Baloth will trigger it up to two times, Sapphire Drake could up to 3 times... but that's it.  Adding Zegana, Agoraphobia, and Zameck Guildmage will go a LONG way toward helping you with this.

Either way, it could be fun.  I hope some of this helps.  Good luck.

First off, if you're R/G (aka Gruul), why do you have Temple Gardens?  A normal mountain would be more effective in casting Boros Reckoner as it will never enter the field tapped and can be used to cast it.  You don't have any other white in the deck...

Second, you have nothing to actually drop with Burning-Tree Emissary other than another BTE or perhaps your one-drops.  You need to have some two drops to give you options.

Third, I don't know that I'd run Purphoros or Domri as 4x.  Not only would this require you to obtain 4x Purphoros (who is pre-ordering at like $25), but they're legendary - making ANY duplicates of either in your hand dead cards.  I could see Domri as 3x at the most and Purphoros perhaps as a 2x or MAYBE a 3x.

Fourth, I don't know that I'd run Madcap Skills in here.  Sure, it works wonders in sealed and is a monster card in the right instances, but given the small size of the creatures you're using, it's inviting you to get two-for-one'd a LOT.  Think, you put it on a BTE, they hit it with Magma Jet.  Now you're out two cards to their one.

I'd actually suggest looking at Craig Wescoe's list and then see what changes here or there that you want to make it more your flavor.  You can see his article here: http://magic.tcgplayer.com/db/article.asp?ID=11358

For cards you're leaving out from Theros, simply put, go look at Reverent Hunter, Satyr Hedonist, and Xenagos (although I'm thinking he'll be best for a more mid-rangey deck).

Did you receive cards from him?  I'm assuming your delivery confirmation states that your cards were delivered, right?  My guess would be that either Sebi or Catinca can force finish the trade.