Search options (Page 33 of 54)

I'm open to the Slaughter Games option and admit Snapcaster Mage would be a nice addition, but I don't have any and as I said in the first post, I'm not looking to break the bank here.

That's interesting regarding the ruling for Nightveil.  I can see where that'll be a headache for players and they might change it, given that it could, in theory, require you to have 2-5 different exile piles to keep track of (not including any clone abilities).

I'm thinking the Drownyard will likely go down to a 1x of, simply to offer a last-ditch backup plan.  Good catch on your part.

I hear you about the added sweepers, trust me when I say I'm not comfortable with the limited ones available in R/B/U currently in Standard.  The idea behind Dispel/Negate here was to deal with instant speed removal or counters on their part.  It'd certainly suck to try to play Bolas only to have him countered.  But I can definitely see where you're coming from there.

Thoughts on Skullcrack in the SB?  I'm not entirely sure it matters that much as a well played Bolas would make their life largely  irrelevant.  I think these spots might give way to Mutilates.  It's not ideal to clear out my creatures, but then again, I'm not so attached to them as to get killed rather than clear the board.

A few thoughts:

1) As you already identified, this isn't really the best strategy out there in standard.  It'd be great fun if you get it to work, but I don't know how likely that is.

2) I would load up on the cheaper land destroy spells rather than the high-end CMCs.  Specifically, Scorch the Fields, Survey the Wreckage, Into the Maw of Hell, and Rite of Ruin could potentially be dropped.  They're expensive and really don't give you the best payoff.  The only real reason I didn't mention the others is because they're cheaper and, in the case of Maw of the Mire and Destroy the Evidence you get more than just land destruction out of it.  Maw gives you life gain, which I think will be essential to staying alive long enough to really get anywhere.  DtE actually will end up netting you two lands in their yard.

3) I'd suggest adding some mill stuff with the "Until you hit a land" effects, i.e., Consuming Aberration/Balustrade Spy/Trepanation Blade.  They'll cost the opponent lands AND other stuff.  The aberration also provides you another possible win-con in the process.

4) I would DEFINITELY run 4x Ghost Quarter given the prevalence of the shocklands.  Several people aren't even running any basics at all these days.

5) I would try to reduce it to 2-3 colors ideally to ensure that the ironic event where you're land-screwed doesn't happen.

6) I would also suggest some more removal as you're currently only sitting at six options.  I fear you will find many instances where you need to deal with some added creature(s) and just run out of firepower.

7) I'm not sure your three artifacts really benefit you much.  The only one I'm seeing as that useful is the Gem of Becoming and you would be much better served by Gilded Lotus.

8) Don't forget that simply tapping their lands and keeping them tapped could serve the same purpose as destroying the lands in many instances.  I'm thinking specifically about Tamiyo, the Moon Sage, but anything that lets you "tap target permanent" could do the same thing.

9) I would actually suggest going with Jund colors (RBG) to give you more ramp options with green while also adding Acidic Slime to the mix.  Toss in a Conjurer's Closet and said slime will destroy at least one land per turn with no added cost.

10) Dual Casting could be of considerable use to you, pending that you find a good creature to put it on.

Anyway, I wish you the best of luck with it, but I fear many of your efforts will be wasted as I just don't see how it will be competitive.

Bumpity.  I know it's an odd one, but surely someone out there is after a Hydra.

I'm game if everyone else is.

HikingStick - I agree completely that it can be intimidating, but I think ANY discussion, good or bad is useful.  So to that end, I'm not expecting everyone to be contributing bullet pointed lists full of comments like I do or pro-level advice by any means.  Sometimes even just a suggestion of a card that comes to mind can be just the spur of imagination/perspective to help someone along on their deck.

I'm fine with people taking things slowly when it comes to participating in the forums, but this forum has more than 1,500 posts on more than 250 separate decks - surely this means there are more than 5-6 of us to offer input on deck ideas.  Further, the deck listings are easily searchable through the site.  So to that end, just a few thoughts here or there or, as LootPinata and imsully2 have already stated, even a bit of direction or added commentary on your own deck so that we know HOW to help goes a long way.  After all, I could sit here and tell you all day how I would build your deck, but that might not fit your play style and you might not enjoy it nearly as much as I would (I fall into the Timmy/Johnny player types).

I'll openly admit, I played back during Revised and then took 15 years away from the game.  I started back around the release of AVR last year and had a LOT of catching up to do ranging from how a planeswalker even works to the more detailed stack resolution and other rules.  It's a LOT to learn and I'm not expecting all the new players to know exactly what's up at all times, but every little bit helps. 

I look at this forum as a more friendly version of what you can find on Tappedout - but just like on that forum, if you want feedback on a deck, you should operate with the understanding that you need to participate and offer as much info as possible both when asking for help and when helping others.  I'm happy to offer as much input as I can, but a little more backup from the community would definitely be welcome (and you'll note those of us even commenting here are all at more than 100 posts so it's not like any of us are holding our opinions back).

I guess the first question is, what is the main purpose of the deck?  Casual play?  FNMs?  Based on the format, I'm guessing casual, at which point you can actually save a fair amount as the games aren't meant to be as competitive.

Three main thoughts:

First, what is the proposed win-condition?  Stated otherwise, how do you normally expect to win with this deck?  I'm seeing Champion of Lambholt as an option but that's only one card (not likely to be played consistently) AND what do you do if it gets killed?

Second, any mana fixing would be ideal - you can pull this off in casual play with some Simic Guildgates - as then you won't find yourself stuck with one color and not the other.

Third, I'm seeing too many one-offs in the deck.  To make a deck better, and I know card availability is key, it's best to have 3-4 of your power cards and 2-3 of utility cards, with 1 offs being cards that make life better but aren't necessary by any means for the deck to function.

Looking at your inventory, why not go with more illusions?  You have a Lord of the Unreal to provide them with hexproof.  Phantasmal Dragon is a pain to deal with when the Lord is in play.  In theory you could pick up a couple more Lords for only a few dollars to help shore up the blue creatures.  Keep in mind, though, that you cannot cast pump spells on your own illusions or you will kill them.

On the green side, you could aim for mana fixing, mana ramping, or a wealth of other options.  For the Champion, why not put together some green token creation or something like that?  Alternately, why not invest in a few more Protean Hydras?  They'll likely be pretty small to start off but can then get pretty large if you keep putting counters on them via Bond Beetles and whatnot, especially if you toss in Prey Upon or Ulvenwald Tracker and have them fight the opponent's smaller creatures (resulting in a LOT more counters)

I'm obviously just tossing out ideas at this point, but I hope you can see what I'm hitting at in the first three thoughts.  I think you could have something really fun to play with if you were to invest another $5-10.  Just identify combos that you think would be fun and run with them.  Remember that playtesting is the best, and only, way to find out if your deck will work or not for sure.

Good luck!

Dig around and let me know.  I have a trade proposed to someone at the moment, but I don't know if/when he'll respond.  If you can track it down soon I'll cancel that one and you're first in line.