FYI I just updated both my tradelist and wishlist.  Each have about $1,300 worth of cards on them so there's plenty for everyone!

Put an offer together if you think we can work something out.

haha no, I'm good.  There are plenty of days left and he can just re-post tomorrow.  I just didn't want to pass up an opportunity for such punny word play.

ErickC wrote:

Looking at my above post I realize I cannot add...
2 Liliana =16
1 Sword of FaF =9
1 Karn Liberated =3
2 Thalia = 1
=29

If by "can't add" you meant that you can't add more cards to your vote for the day then I agree tongue

On the bright side, my liliana's and SoFaF just freed up!

I agree, this seems unnecessarily complex and I'm concerned about possibly losing out on other offers while my cards are wrapped up in this for so many days.

That being said, I give you credit for trying something different so I'll bid 28 in the form of:

2x Liliana = 16
1x SoFaF = 9
2x Champion of the Parish = 1
2x Woodland Cemetery = 2

105

(0 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

It's come to my attention that one can mitigate neutral feedback by simply not providing feedback for a trade.  This bug report is, in part, also a report of the oddity that occurs when someone gives positive feedback but the other party has not yet left feedback.  The party who has not yet left feedback will have a feedback score higher than the number of trades they have completed. 

The latter issue mentioned could even be used to mitigate negative feedback leaving someone with a marred trading history to appear to have a perfect trading history.

106

(8 replies, posted in Decks and Deckbuilding)

Personally, I think it's the most enjoyable format for casual games that there is.  I think you'd like it but I understand the apprehension of your play group takes precedence.

Can I suggest Paradox Haze?

107

(8 replies, posted in Decks and Deckbuilding)

For fun you can play an EDH deck as a 100-card highlander in a FFA game like that.  You'll probably win wince nobody will touch you for the first handful of turns and then you'll start dropping bombs that they can't keep up with wink

108

(1 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

You don't say.

109

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I sent you an offer.

Here's my personal goblin build:  http://deckbox.org/sets/81028

It's legacy and has all the staple cards in the list.

Under the assumption that you aren't about to put together that list tomorrow let's take a look at your current build and talk about what can be changed reasonably.

Starting with the lands, I would drop all the non-basics and just run mountains.  Dormant Volcano and Dwarven Ruins aren't helping in the speed category since they come in to play tapped.

Moving on to the goblins, the list is fine enough.  None of them are particularly scary but they're goblins, their power is in numbers.  I am a big fan of the Ember Hauler in your list.  I think they are very useful and you should run 4 of them.  I think the Goblin Kings should be replaced by Goblin Chieftain since haste is your best weapon.  I also think you should get your hands on Spikeshot Elders (probably 4) because they are a really solid 1-drop. 

The other spells in this list are not very fantastic for a speed build IMHO.  Flinging 1/1s and 2/2s is a waste of a spell.  Fireball implies that you'll have enough mana to make it worth casting; you should be killing your opponent well before you have enough mana to justify fireball so I would drop all 4 of them.  Dragon Fodder is OK I guess.  There are better cards but there are certainly worse ones.  Goblin Scouts should probably get removed too.  5 mana is too much for a goblin deck in most cases. 

Goblin Caves and Goblin Shrine should be removed in favor of better spells.  Goblin Shrine isn't worth the spell slot and Goblin Caves isn't worth the risk.  Sure they work together but you have better things to cast on turn 3. 

Depending on whether you want to go legacy or standard dictates what cards you'd use to replace everything I suggested removing.  If you're going to stay legacy then some attainable cards that are great additions are Mogg War Marshal, Goblin Ringleader, Goblin Warchief, Gempalm Incinerator and Goblin Matron.  I highly recommend running 4 of all of them except the warchief, 3 of them is a good number.

The next card I would chase for a legacy build would be Aether Vial followed by Goblin Lackey and finally Goblin Piledriver.  The piledrivers make the deck ridiculous but they are so expensive.

If you wanted to turn the deck into a standard deck I don't have as many suggestions since standard goblins isn't exactly a popular build.  I've seen a build that ran more burn and Hellriders that did OK.  That's about all I know; I wish you luck!

A super fast goblin build is expensive but if your committed to putting it together you should decide if you want to build a legacy version or standard version.  Legacy goblins, as of the time of writing this, costs anywhere from $400 to $1000 depending on the build and sideboard options.  Standard goblins is much cheaper but is also subject to set rotation and could rotate into obscurity in the near future...

Personally, I think your build is fine enough.  There are certainly areas that could be improved but if you were going to invest money into a particular deck I don't think goblins is the right choice...

All that being said I would like to leave you with something substantive instead of a meta discussion on goblins as an archetype. So, here goes...

112

(28 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

I thought I was the best trader ever...  I'm insulted : P

The short answer is no.  Just rely on speed. 

Goblins, as a deck, is an example of an extremely aggressive archetype.  Your goal is to focus exclusively on killing your opponent through fast damage.  To that end, there is no room in the main deck for enchantment removal, artifact removal, card draw or any other type of mechanic.  You just focus on beating face.

Another way of looking at it is that if your opponent is dead their enchantments don't matter.

114

(28 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

Thank you, thank you, thank you and sorry again ><

if you are committed to adding draw spells I recommend Survival Cache.

116

(28 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

And again with April King...

117

(28 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

Sonofa!  ><

I just did left neutral feedback for user Ellusionist.  Should have been positive.  Super sorry, admins!

118

(8 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Sure, how much?

Sent you an offer for a Sorin.

120

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I have Viashino Sandscout, Defense Grid and Defender of Law.  (all legacy despite the tooltips)

It's super low priority but it would be convenient to have a review stage or something like that.  The first time I left wordy feedback it got truncated and looked pretty silly.  I don't mind being concise but it would be nice to know I've run over the character limit before I press save and can no longer change it.

122

(1 replies, posted in General Discussion)

Eh?

Commander = EDH.  Does that help?

If not, what new filters and format did you have in mind?

I believe it's 254 characters.

124

(20 replies, posted in General Discussion)

Borgin wrote:

Also, SCG and CFB have terrible, terrible prices. SCG especially, with prices for valuable cards often five or ten dollars above tcgplayer's lows.

My understanding is that buying from TCG is like buying from amazon.  Every card may come from a different vendor.  if that's true then you will pay tons of money in shipping fees when attempting to acquire many cards at once.  This probably makes SCG and CFB better in that instance but it really depends on what you're buying.

The only way to know for sure is to do the math and see what's cheaper in the end.

That's a really good thing to worry about.  No I have run in to infect issues but only because it's not prevalent in my play group.  If its a concern you could make room for removal like swords to plowshares.