Watcheswhenup wrote:

Good evening everyone! I'm new to paper magic, having just picked the game up in the last week after a few months of playing Duels of the Planeswalkers. Anyway, I'm looking to build a Dimir mill/control deck that will be Standard legal after the Innistrad block rotates out. I know Theros will be around then, but I'm just trying to get the skeleton going, as I plan to check out FNM standard after the rotation. I'll be doing FNM Draft until then. What I've come up after a hefty dose of research online is below. Thanks in advance for any assistance.

http://deckbox.org/sets/431890

P.S., any good, cheap targeted removal that works on black creatures? Doom Blade is cheap, but I'm worried about the popularity of black because it's solid and popular in the DoTP games.

It is really hard to make a post-rotation deck pre-rotation. You basically choose not to play 1/2 of the available cards, many of which are good. You are better off not playing standard until rotation if you don't want to aquire cards that are going to rotate soon because your deck won't be as good as someone who is playing with those cards + RTR block & m14.

If you are already planning on not playing constructed until Theros comes out, why worry about it now? It is impossible to predict what decks will even be viable post-rotation. BU might be great or terrible, we won't know until we see the Theros cards. If you like blue and black, just draft it a lot have the cards available to make blue and black decks after rotation.

Giant_Glass_Box wrote:

Quite frankly, there are a lot of sites that I can use to trade cards. If this is how a "respected" member of the community conducts themselves then I really see no reason to continue to use it for that purpose.  I certainly appreciate the objective opinions given regarding this situation. I honestly see no reason for this person to have lost their mind about it.  I regret being somewhat snarky with my replies, but that is how I react when I feel like someone is trying to "game" me or to take advantage of me. And, let's be honest, that is exactly what you were attempting.  The fact that it was 'Only a $0.97 card' has no bearing on the matter whatsoever. 

I definitely agree with Sebi that it behooves all of us to be nice to people who are new to the community. Magic players are a subset of a subset of a subset of people and we can use all of the friends that we can get because, lord knows, the rest of the world sure doesn't understand.

That being said, Wally_H, you're going to do what you feel is right. Just stop acting like a jerk about it.

It isn't.  Most people on here think that while it wasn't cool of you to back out, that his absolute insistence of giving you a negative is making him the douche.  What most people here probaly think you should do is offer to trade with him. If he wants your gaze, you find something of his you want. After all, he has stated right here he doesn't want something for nothing.  Unless of course Wally is confusing the phrase "compensatory trade" with "they have to give me stuff for free"

If that is what he expects you to do, nobody is on his side. Honest. I think if I had been on the other end of the trade with you, and I was a black cat card collector, I'd have said ok.  I might have left you a neutral, but this pushing for a negative thing he is shooting himself in the foot.

You can add me to the list of people who really wouldn't want to trade with a guy like that after seeing his forum tempter tantrum.

markst3ph3n wrote:

Looking for Tarmogoyfs and Dark Confidant from Modern Masters.

Notable Haves are:
Polluted Delta
Verdant Catacombs
Wasteland
Berserk
Elspeth, Knight Errant
Mox Opal
Voice of Resurgence

Have 2 dark confidant MM lets talk

Please throw me some trades to finish this affinity deck!

130

(3 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I have 4 squirrel mob but they're in played-heavily played condition. If you are intersted let me know.

drgolovacroxby wrote:

That's all I need to finish off my squirrel deck.  I've been working so long at finishing this damn thing, so please help me get there!

I've got plenty of stuff to offer in return.  Start up a chat, and let's see what we can do!

Interested check my trades please.

Jibbers wrote:

Local store owner valued it at $90 for trade in, I'm looking to get $70 cash for it or trade it for some modern staples. It is in lightly played condition (not NM).

Get that money now son. it is about to be reprinted. trade in to your local store asap.

133

(2 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

you can link your discover card to your amazon account and use your rewards as cash at checkout with amazon. I want you to buy me a ultra pro breeding pool playmat for this information smile


Syonide wrote:

Over the past year-ish I have gotten $31.49 in discover cash back rewards which is sitting around doing nothing. I'm planning on closing my discover account soon, as I ave other better credit cards and don't need this one anymore, but I don't want to lose my points for nothing, and I don't want to buy some random thing just because.

I can't use them to buy magic cards because no online store that is affiliated with discover sells magic cards. Unlike my amazon visa, which I use the rewards to buy all sorts of cards, my discover points are useless to me for this hobby. That being said, there are a ton of store affiliated with discovers cashback program. Really just about any store you can think of is affiliated.

Here's a full list of stores.
https://www.discover.com/credit-cards/c … cover.html

If anyone is interested, I will buy something worth up to 31.49 and have it shipped to you, in return I want cards. I don't mind shipping the item first, and you can wait til it's in your possession to ship the cards out if you want.

Picture of my balance - http://puu.sh/3f7SO.png
As you can see I don't use my discover card often enough to rack up enough points to put towards a credit on my balance (minumum 50 bucks).

I'm looking for either cards on my wishlist or staples that I can trade out of pretty easily likes shocks. If interested at all open a trade with me or post here.

134

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

VampireArmy wrote:

the sets range mostly from the innistrad block all the way back to zendikar with a few older sets ive randomly found around as well.  i dont think ill put land in there as that doesnt seem fair but ill sort through them tonight.  expect a report afterwards smile im thinking 15-20 bucks for it.  i dont know how much shippng will cost but ill charge 12 if i can get away sending it through the small "if it fits it ships" box.

Honestly for 15-20 if its mostly Zendikar Block and up I would be intersted. I'm playing again after a long break (lorywn block) so getting a bunch of commons in some of the sets is something I'm trying to do on the cheap. If you really have a boatload of commons and are willing to look for some specific things I could work up a list and maybe offer a little more per card for your effort?

135

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Why would you throw them away if someone would pay you a penny a card plus shipping? It is still a net positive to your cash flow for things you'd never use.  I would take a box of 1000 commons from standard, especially if there were no more than 4x of a given card.  You have to price yourself with the market. I can buy a set of 4x commons & uncommons for $40 on ebay for each set. So if you want to throw 1000 commons in a box, your price has to be lower than a sorted group of commons and uncommons. It is still worth your while imo if it is sell or trash.

136

(2 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Is there something or someone I should contact about getting added?  I requested a few days ago and it is still pending, I tried searching on the mtg subreddit and didn't see anything.