FlameBurger wrote:

I think pin holes would be considered damaged by the vast majority of people, despite otherwise being in good condition.

That's how I put it in already, but I wanted to be sure. Thank you.

I think I can list condition for every card pretty easily, but I have one that's unique. It's an Beta (or Alpha, can't remember right now) card in rather good condition other than the pin hole someone nutz made when they pinned it to a tackboard. The hold goes in the back and comes out the front so it's not super noticable in the back, but it IS marked in that way. What do I do about that?

FastTadpole wrote:

The Deckbox Card Condition Guide
https://deckbox.org/help/card_conditions

If you like something more visual SCG has a good reference here
http://www.starcitygames.com/content/cardconditions

Thank you!

zoabdy wrote:

That scg guide is super helpful, I can upgrade a lot of my LP cards to NM. I was under the impression that any noticable wear at all downgraded them to LP

Thank you!

I'm doing my best based on card condition, but I expect for the expensive stuff, people are going to want to see them. I don't have photos uploaded yet, but I can add them. But in cases of less visible issues, what then? I have one or two with a minor crease, fold, or indent and I have one that was literally pinned to a corkboard at one point. The pinhole is pretty unnoticable on the back and has a small white mark on the front where the pin came out. What's the protocol here? I have it listed in very poor condition right now even though it's actually very good other than the pinhole.