Topic: Selling my Magic Collection

Hello,

I'm selling my old MTG cards.  None of my group really plays casual anymore and I have a new baby that needs things. 

A complete list of cards and sets can be found here: 
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc … sp=sharing

It's sorted by TCGPlayer low value, with the most valuable at the top.  Highlights are:

2x Gaea's Cradle
3x Natural Order
Sets (The Dark, Homelands, Fallen Empires)

As you can see, with the exception of the top 10 or so singles, most are junk rares.  Not listed are about 4,000 commons and uncommons, which range from revised to Dark Steel, with most of the concentration at each end of that range (I played around 4th/Ice Age and then played again around Onslaught/Mirrodin, with some sporadic interest in the middle).  Most of the cards not in sets are in mixed condition, from heavy play all the way up to mint.

To be clear, the prices listed aren't what I'm asking, they are just the low values based on TCGplayer so I could get a relative retail value for all the cards.  My intention was to sell the complete sets and "money" rares individually and the rest as a lot.  If you are interested in any or all of it, please feel free to make an offer.  Or if you would prefer to look through the cards we could set something up.  I'm in Rochester in the South Wedge neighborhood. 

Thanks,
Jeff

Re: Selling my Magic Collection

Thanks for the offer.  I did keep a couple decks for nostalgia and might be interested in playing sometime.  Truthfully though, the new baby is the primary reason I'm selling.  Between time and money needs, and with the cards not getting any use, I decided to give up the dream sad

Re: Selling my Magic Collection

How much for Gaea's Cradle? Natural Order? The bulk?

Re: Selling my Magic Collection

Avon wrote:

How much for Gaea's Cradle? Natural Order? The bulk?

For the Cradles, $100 each?  Millenium sells them for $150, and TCGplayer low price is $120. 
For the Natural Orders, $20 each?  Millenium sells them for $23 and TCGplayer low is $22.50. 

For both card, mine have seen some play, but the TCGplayer low price includes cards for sale in non-mint condition.

For the bulk (all commons, uncommons and rares, except the Cradles, the Natural Orders, and the sets), I don't know.  What do you think?

If you want to send me an email with an offer for any or all of it, please feel free.