Home
Magic the Gathering Decks
29-Sep-2014 05:02
(Last edited: 29-Sep-2014 05:35)
1
Okay, I have a trade right now where I'm going to send out my Goblin Rabblemasters:
http://deckbox.org/trades/250987?s=48370
Problem is, someone just bought them in an order as well:
http://deckbox.org/orders/5225
I'm really not sure what I'm supposed to do. Presumably I cancel the order, but obviously I don't think this scenario should have been able to arise to begin with: If you have an accepted trade involving a card, that card should *not* be for sale.
Obviously the problem is that cards aren't removed from your tradelist until you actually mark them as shipped. I think this needs to be changed so that accepted trades have the cards automatically removed from the tradelist, but not necessarily the inventory (so that users can still throw out multiple trade proposals with the same cards without being bound to the first one that gets accepted.) I don't think there's too much downside to this. If one really wants I admit that I could be faulted here for not immediately removing the item from my tradelist once the trade was accepted, but that's not always going to be a reasonable expectation.
Is there any rule I should follow for how to handle this situation? Again, it seems like the right thing to do here is to cancel the order, but I don't want to make a bad assumption here, or open myself to receiving negative feedback (if that really was a risk, I'd just stop by my LGS and buy a couple Rabblemasters..)
http://deckbox.org/trades/250987?s=48370
Problem is, someone just bought them in an order as well:
http://deckbox.org/orders/5225
I'm really not sure what I'm supposed to do. Presumably I cancel the order, but obviously I don't think this scenario should have been able to arise to begin with: If you have an accepted trade involving a card, that card should *not* be for sale.
Obviously the problem is that cards aren't removed from your tradelist until you actually mark them as shipped. I think this needs to be changed so that accepted trades have the cards automatically removed from the tradelist, but not necessarily the inventory (so that users can still throw out multiple trade proposals with the same cards without being bound to the first one that gets accepted.) I don't think there's too much downside to this. If one really wants I admit that I could be faulted here for not immediately removing the item from my tradelist once the trade was accepted, but that's not always going to be a reasonable expectation.
Is there any rule I should follow for how to handle this situation? Again, it seems like the right thing to do here is to cancel the order, but I don't want to make a bad assumption here, or open myself to receiving negative feedback (if that really was a risk, I'd just stop by my LGS and buy a couple Rabblemasters..)
