I'm totally in agreement that there shouldn't be subforums for different deck styles. So far I have seen people asking for advice on more casual decks and personal brews than looking at tweaking a dominant deck. The people who are looking for top-tier competitive decks are already going to the sites that offer a strong community around a specific format (e.g. http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/forum.php for Legacy). If the decks are geared toward FNM or casual play then keeping everything visible in one spot is the most useful. Otherwise you're going to get people that only read the Legacy section and won't help out with other formats.
227 2013-02-01 18:36:15
Re: Signed Cards, Summer Magic and Alternate 4th Ed. (1 replies, posted in General Discussion)
So I have a few questions that hopefully some collectors out there might be able to shed some light on.
1. How do you value signed cards? I can easily see that a common card or low value rare that is signed by the artist would command a premium price. But, what about high value legacy and vintage staples? I have heard that the signature, just by the fact that it was not part of the original card, is viewed as a "Blemish" or as some type of "Damage" and therefore reduces the value of an otherwise NM card. Is there any general consensus on this, such as a % increase or decrease, or is it more of a matter of Value in the eyes of the beholder?
In a lot of cases a signature does not change the value of a card. Some artists are difficult to contact or generally don't sign cards, and those cards will get a large premium (e.g. Una Fricker or Gary Leach). Some people don't like signed cards and will say that it damages the card. Fine, don't deal with those people. There are enough people that like signed cards that you can get at least full value out of any signed card, and possibly a premium.
2. Summer Magic - What exactly is it in terms of language / edition / distribution. How do you identify cards as being from the Summer Magic set as compared to the other regular editions.
Summer edition was never officially released. The product was supposed to be destroyed, but a very limited quantity was released in the UK and Texas. You can identify Summer cards by seeing "Illus. c. 1994 <artist>" all on one line at the bottom of the card. This was supposed to be a fixed version of Revised, but it had enough errors of its own that it was never released. It is pretty much not worth checking to see if you have Summer cards. You won't have any.
3. Alternate 4th edition - Basically the same question as above. How do you identify the Alternate Edition cards form the regular 4th Edition set?
Alt. 4th was produced as an attempt to use a new printer, the US Playing Card Company, due to Carta Mundi not being able to keep up with demand for Magic. Eventually this need was eliminated when Carta Mundi opened up a new plant in Tennessee. There were several issues with the cards. The feel of the cards was different due to a different coating, the cards showed wear much more quickly due to use, and there are subtle differences with the back of the card. You can see some discussion of the differences here:
http://www.magiclibrarities.net/forum/v php?t=7321
Look for the post by AzureWinter toward the bottom of the page for a helpful image.
228 2013-01-21 18:23:51
Topic: Looking for Pernicious Deed, Burning Wish and Karakas (1 replies, posted in Trading Post)
The chief cards that I'm looking for are Pernicious Deed, Burning Wish and Karakas.
I have a decent variety available, including Arcbound Ravagers, Kiki-Jiki and Library of Alexandria (HP).
229 2013-01-14 15:10:10
Re: iDeckbox v1.0 for iPhone and iPad is AVAILABLE :-) (113 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
Thanks! Everything loads now.
230 2013-01-12 17:26:11
Re: {Standard} {Help} Mechanics of this Deck (5 replies, posted in Decks and Deckbuilding)
That looks like it should play a lot better as two colors and with the lower casting cost creatures. I would bump the mana up to 22 (probably cutting a Crossway Vampire and Bloodline Keeper) so that you don't get stuck on 3 mana. 20 land is just too little unless 3 mana is the top end of your mana curve.
231 2013-01-11 22:05:21
Re: {Standard} {Help} Mechanics of this Deck (5 replies, posted in Decks and Deckbuilding)
It seems like you have too much land without a way to spend the extra mana on late turns of a game. I'm also not entirely sold on the green aspect of the deck.
I would cut Slitterhead for three more Pulse Trackers and a Blood Seeker. Radha seems out of place, but I don't know exactly what to replace her with. I would cut Jarad's Orders for the two extra Grisly Salvage as the instant speed and lower mana cost should help you find your creatures that you're looking for. I would look for a couple more cheap vampires for the extra slots that are still open as your mana curve seems a bit lacking on the low end. It may be worth cutting a Mark of the Vampire or two as you probably don't need to cast more than one during a game.
232 2013-01-11 21:07:30
Re: iDeckbox v1.0 for iPhone and iPad is AVAILABLE :-) (113 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
Do you have any idea of the normal number of cards for a collection that is working properly?
For now I'll delete my collection and then just add back in cards that are in decks or in my trade binder.
233 2013-01-08 18:17:26
Re: iDeckbox v1.0 for iPhone and iPad is AVAILABLE :-) (113 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
Thanks for the update. I can enter my account and see that it exists, but I still only ever get my wishlist and trade list updated. I get a connection error after about a minute or two. Any idea why my inventory won't load?
234 2013-01-03 20:10:44
Re: favicon.ico (3 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
Just to follow up, everything works properly now. I like the icon.
235 2013-01-03 20:06:53
Re: favicon.ico (3 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
I'm running Firefox and when I try to load favicon.ico I get an error:
The image "http://deckbox.org/favicon.ico" cannot be displayed because it contains errors.
Hmmm..... It displays OK in Opera. I'll try restarting Firefox and see if that fixes it. It's probably just cached oddly.
Thanks for your quick response. I hate seeing empty boxes on my bookmarks bar.
236 2013-01-03 19:26:55
Topic: favicon.ico (3 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
Can you add a small icon as /favicon.ico on the web server so that bookmarks and tabs have an icon that users can associate with deckbox.org?
237 2013-01-02 16:35:17
Re: You have $50 to spend on any selection of cards. What do you buy? (10 replies, posted in General Discussion)
Assuming that you play either casual formats or Legacy, I would look at picking up any playables from the Scars of Mirrodin block that you're missing and that you like to play. This is probably the low point price-wise for cards like Green Sun's Zenith, Sword of Body and Mind, Surgical Extraction and others from this block (though maybe not yet for Sword of War and Peace).
238 2012-11-19 21:38:02
Re: iDeckbox v1.0 for iPhone and iPad is AVAILABLE :-) (113 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
I'm still having problems loading my inventory as well. I get my wishlist, but not my inventory.
239 2012-10-30 13:11:07
Re: iDeckbox v1.0 for iPhone and iPad is AVAILABLE :-) (113 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
I've been having problems downloading my inventory to the app. How do I tell if I'm running into the same server-side error as the people above?
240 2012-10-09 13:13:44
Re: Starting up a Cube (Opinion, Discussion) (3 replies, posted in General Discussion)
There are some very fun ways to do two player drafting from a cube. I would not build a special, small cube for two player drafting, but just build a regular cube. If you end up drafting with two players most of the time, that's fine, but you have the option of more people playing.
Some of the ways that I've done two player drafting are:
1. Start with 10 packs of 15 cards, deal out three piles of five cards. Each player takes one pile and the last pile is flipped face up. Take turns swapping one card in your hand for one of the face up cards. Once both players pass, keep what you have in hand, remove the five face up cards and move on to the next pack. Alternate who gets to pick first.
2. Select 105 to 150 cards from the cube and put then in face down pile. Deal out three cards face down. The first player looks at the first card and may take that card. If he does then his turn is over and a new card is dealt out to replace the pile. If he doesn't take the first card then add a card face down to that pile and move on to the next pile. Again, the player may take that card or move on to the next pile. The same choice is offered for the last pile. If the last pile isn't taken, then take the top card of the large stack of cards. Each time the pile is replaced by a single face down card or a face down card is added to the untaken pile. Alternate turns and keep going until the original stack of cards in gone.
3. Start with 150 cards from the cube in a face down pile. Deal out a three by three grid of face up cards. The first player to choose may take all three cards in any given row or column. The second person may then take any remaining row or column. Set aside the remaining cards. Alternate who chooses first.
If you're interested in building a cube I would suggest checking out the Cube forum at mtgsalvation.com:
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/forumdisplay.php?f=349
It is really valuable and a number of people that write cube articles for different MTG sites hang out there, along with a lot of other knowledgeable people.
241 2012-10-08 22:41:36
Re: Mtg: Planechase 2012 (13 replies, posted in Announcements)
Tember City isn't officially part of the Planechase release, it was only given out as a promo, and is therefore not listed by Wizards in Gatherer, which is why it also isn't listed here. There has been discussions of adding support for pulling data from other sources besides Gatherer, like magiccards.info, to handle a lot of these outlying cases, but I'm not sure of the progress on that front.
All of the other five promo planes are listed, so I guess I should contact WotC and see if I can get Tember City listed in Gatherer. Thanks for the explanation.
242 2012-10-08 20:47:47
Re: Mtg: Planechase 2012 (13 replies, posted in Announcements)
It looks like the plane of Tember City is missing, though all of the others are there. Could you add this last plane?
Thanks.
243 2012-10-08 19:03:00
Topic: Adding Happy Holidays promo cards (0 replies, posted in Site Discussion)
Could the Happy Holidays promo cards be added?
They are:
Fruitcake Elemental
Gifts Given
Season's Beatings
Evil Presents
Snow Mercy
Yule Ooze
Thanks.