76

(2 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I have a Scalding Tarn and some of the smaller things such as Daze, Inquisition, and the temple. Looking for my last Scrubland, if interested start up a trade

If willing to trade out of Inven I could use a Bloodstained Mire. Have 1x Mutavault, 2x Temple of Deceit, 1x Packrat. Start up a trade if interested

Trade started, have some of these things

I'm in need of Bloodstained Mires but didn't have much to compensate for on your wishlist - you might take a look anyway. Start up a trade if you find anything

May be interested in 1 if you're looking to take a regular sword + value towards the foil. Start a trade if you see anything

H: 2 Misty, 4 Tarn
W: 2 Goyfs

Start up a trade if interested. On mobile now but I'll check in when home

AmarusCameron wrote:

Well it is a slight tear that does not affect the name, mana cost, or picture so I guess it would be legal.

Always going to be up to the Judge. If the tear causes a small "bump" in the sleeve it's a marked card and not legal. Usually double sleeving would prevent that but still - up to the judge per event.

Bondidude wrote:

Though if that's all it is then if it were me (in either position) I would recommend either making up the value in cash (a few dollars maybe for an expensive card like that) or some amount of card value.  Whatever the difference between NM and SP or worse depending on the condition would be.

Damaged cards are typically 50% value MAX. It usually comes down to what the person is willing to pay. I consider a damaged Jitte worthless. The person you're trading has remarked that he wants it still so maybe he see's it as a 10 dollar card. Something you'll have to work out with him

My opinion:
Until in the hands of the recipient, the cards are yours and your responsibility. If a person is trading for a card in X condition and they arrive as Y, obviously it is not their fault and they wouldn't have traded for that value if at all having known these facts. Your option 2 (he just gets stuck with the Jitte) is not an option at all. You need to work out an agreement with the person you've traded. Maybe he's ok with a damaged Jitte, but only values it at $10 so you need to send additional trade to make up for it. Maybe he just wants to reverse the trade. Whatever the person decides, it should be completely their decision (to an agreeable extent).

Just reverse the situation and put yourself in the other persons shoes.

84

(4 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Started a trade up

If willing to trade the Judge Sword oLaS check my list and start up a trade

Trade started

trade started for Foil Erebos

Themaddhatter2304 wrote:

What do you value your angus at since it has some play on it?

I'd be OK trading it at its Low of 60. It's in decent shape, just has some light whitening at the edges. Can provide pics if we figure something out, start up a trade if interested.

89

(2 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Willing to trade Scrubland for shocks?

Nothing is jumping out at me on your Trade Lists, sorry.

Madoli, don't hold up buylisting on my account.

I actually play Burning Wish so the foil is intriguing, however I may hold out and see if I can find something closer to my needs rather than shiny wants =P Will definitely keep you in mind over the next couple days.

Have a LP Angus Mackenzie that I'm not attached to, figured I'd put it out there for the Commander crowd.

Trade Started

Awesome, I will let him know. Good work with the quick fix

Was bragging on your site today and when a buddy went to sign up he never received a confirmation email to register the new account. I though it was just user error perhaps and tried to create one myself, only to run into the same issue.

Good to know you all will be keeping everything in order! smile

While I'm sure you don't need any further justification of the matter, the user refereed to in the OP was one of the first traders I came across on this site and nearly drove me away from it. I handled it the best I could and went forward with DeckBox and have since come across many great people. Would be a shame to think users like the before mentioned could so easily dissuade people from using this site. So thanks for keeping on top of things.

-Phillip



sebi wrote:
mrturk1001 wrote:

I will admit that I am an offender as well, and don't give a DAMN if I get banned for posting this. If this does get deleted, it will be re-posted everywhere until I get banned.

This was a very easy wish to grant, no need for threats.

Also, LOL

97

(2 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

trade started

Trade sent

Trade sent