Any news on an oversized Commander 2014 option?  The oversized Commander 2013 option has been really helpful, so far I've been listing my oversized C14 cards with the deprecated promo attachment and foil.

Great changes.  Any chance you'll be offering an "Oversized Commander" option for the C14 walkers, like you have for C13?  Right now I have my oversized C14 cards listed as promo & foil, but that's a band-aid solution.

3

(10 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

Paul_K wrote:

Other reasons would be if something happens to these bazaar websites there is an individual list.  TCGPlayer charges tax for those in NY state so different options may be helpful to avoid the extra money.  Not everything is listed on TCGPlayer.  I also am a firm believer in a variety of options from a psychological viewpoint over a one stop shop.

My pleasure, thanks for putting together a handy list!  Also, https://www.echomtg.com/ is great to track collection value. 

Small stores sell sealed product through TCGplayer, just like singles - that's how I found miniaturemarket, buying a box on TCG and they were lowest. 

If you're in the US and not paying taxes on purchases at the point of sale, you're legally required to pay state/county sales taxes on your tax filings.  Since tracking down all online purchases of physical products shipped to your state is a pain in the rear, I prefer paying sales tax up front!  Amazon didn't used to charge sales tax and I had to go through my order history and figure it out sad

4

(10 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

So many of the little stores are on tcgplayer that it almost doesn't make sense to look for them individually.  The only exception for me is I've found great prices on sealed product, boxes in particular, at miniaturemarket.  They're usually $80-$100 for recent sets and pre-orders, and they offer free shipping on orders over $99, so it is pretty easy to throw something else in.

I play a fair bit on MTGO, so http://www.magicev.com/ is handy.  For a quick printable price guide, dawnglare is good.  Metamox is a good price & staple reference as well.  If I want to watch some pro-level magic, mtgcoverage.com has everything.

To analyze drafts or brews, I use deckstats because it has useful statistics. I like it better than tappedout or even deckbox, though I put my finished brews up here to see what I need to complete them! It also links to edhrec.com, which is amazing for EDH. 

The once or twice a year I go to a GP or PTQ, I use http://metadeck.me/ to proxy up a gauntlet to test my deck against.  You can get 12 decks on the same proxy and it'll populate the decks for you, pretty handy.

If you're a collector, mtgcb shows you how far you are to collecting each set.

Edit: Erp, looks like miniature market was already on the list!

5

(389 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

When sellers go on vacation and their cards are not available to buy, their prices shouldn't show up on the card page.  For example, Eidolon of the Great Revel shows a "buy it now" price of $1.16 based on two sellers who are on vacation.  The cheapest price it can actually be bought at is $5.50 as of right now.

6

(389 replies, posted in Site Discussion)

POST PRICING UPDATE

Lim-Dûl's High Guard $5.00

7

(28 replies, posted in Announcements)

This seems much better - the random $25 commons and uncommons seem to be gone, and pricing sanity seems to be restored generally.  I'm looking forward to partner stores to further rationalize and stabilize prices.  Thank you for the quick update, and improvement to the site!

8

(197 replies, posted in Announcements)

Amazon prices are a disaster, I'm going to suspend all non-accepted trades and go inactive until something more reliable can be arranged.  Mtgprice.com also offers an API which may be somewhat better just amazon prices.  Any chance you could try something like that out?

9

(92 replies, posted in Announcements)

The update seems to have compressed the address boxes in trades to a single line.  That's fine shipping to countries I'm accustomed to, but it makes international shipping harder because I don't know where the address line breaks should be.  Any chance that gets changed back?

10

(21 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

fairportmagic wrote:

Weird, Rochester seems to have a decent supply if modern masters

FML, I'm moving back.  Who needs a job anyway?

11

(21 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

Anyone else pull anything good? 

All the stores out here in albany sold out during pre-orders, except one, and I couldn't make it to their draft (and $40 seemed steep), so I missed this one.

12

(21 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

Wow, congrats on Bob!  That more than pays for the draft!

13

(21 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

The stores around me sold out of boxes and aren't selling packs.  I'm going to try and do a draft tomorrow if it isn't too packs, although $35 for a draft just feels steep.  Here's to hoping for good pulls I guess...

Anyone else doing anything with MM?

14

(11 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

Paul_K wrote:

according to wizard's formula mythics are 1/8, rares are 7/8.

This is a good rule of thumb, and probably perfect for this situation.  If you want packs to match sealed packs rarity-wise, mythics should be replace rares about 1/8th of the time.  The exact distribution changes very slightly from set to set, but it is always very close to 1/8.*

Since timeshifted stuff is all from earlier sets, any way you can assign each timeshifted card the rarity from its first printing?  If not, it may be better to exclude timeshifted cards entirely than slot them all as rare. 

I'd suggest excluding any card worth more than $X, so your beta timewalk doesn't get randomly picked.  It'd make it kind of like a reject rare draft (which is quite fun actually). 

One other suggestion, could the app work off of tradelists rather than inventory?  That way you don't have to draft something from an existing deck, and we know it is all stuff we're happy to part with. 


*  Just FYI, you can figure out the exact proportion in a set like this.  Count all the rares in a set, e.g. 53 in GTC.  Count all the mythics, e.g. 15 in GTC.  Double all the rares since they get printed twice on a sheet, e.g. 106 in GTC.  Add rares & mythics & divide by mythics, e.g. 15/(15+106) = 12.39% of the rare slots with have a mythic in GTC.  12.39% is very close to 12.5% of 1/8.  DGM is slightly different because each sheet have shock lands too, but otherwise the math works for any set.

15

(9 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

It was $2 shipping total, so you could get 3 packs shipped for ~$23 which wasn't terrible. 

If you find a better deal somewhere, please share!

16

(9 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

Massdrop.com sells sleeves periodically, if you don't need the sleeves right now it may be worth waiting.  Voting is up now on a few ideas.

* https://www.massdrop.com/vote/deck-protectors--sleeves
* https://www.massdrop.com/vote/kmc-sleeves

They did dragonshield 100-packs for $7 before, so they can get good deals. 

If you can't wait, check out this site: http://www.potomacdist.com/list.asp?code=4040 - box of matte black KMC sleeves for $54 (that's ten packs of 80 count sleeves) or a pack of 80 sleeves for $9.  Not a terrible price.

17

(10 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

So Burning Earth - is it going to be a thing?  Seems to slow for eternal formats, I was really hoping they'd reprint Price of Progress to punish greedy mana bases in modern, but maybe a thing in standard?  Lots of players run very few basics, so turning off lands on T4 seems ok if I'm playing RDW.  It is no hellrider, but I could see siding it in over Exava.  Sure beats the new Ogre Battledriver.

EDIT: Also, another llanowar/fyndhorn elves, shock & doom blade are back, and they're printing a strictly worse caravan vigil.  Also, opportunity - just EDH or can control decks use it because it is actually an instant, albeit 6 mana.  And ratchet bomb is back, which is awesome.

18

(9 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

I'd kick in for two or three.

19

(21 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

Paul_K wrote:

so you're saying that getting a box at msrp of 249.99 is a must?  But would we (rochester group) be willing to spend $40 on a draft?

We'll have to wait for spoiler confirmation as well as spoilers of the rest of the set.  But it is a pretty amazing set.  Not sure if it will justify $250, since each box only has 24 rather than 36 packs, that'd mean each pack would need more than $10 worth of value ON AVERAGE to break even.  But it looks to be a steal at $120 and I'm planning on doing as many drafts at my LGS as I have time and they have product (so probably just 1, but hopefully 2 drafts).

20

(21 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

I don't mean to be spamming topics here, but anyone see what they've spoiled for modern masters?  Goyf & Bob are a good start, but the good Elspeth, Kataki, Path at uncommon, Swords, Shackles, Ravager, Doubling Season, Vial, Finks at uncommon, & Knight of Reliquary?

Amazing.  I'd be surprised if the set doesn't sell out entirely before it hits shelves, drafts are packed, and boxes go for twice MSRP.  The set is nuts.

21

(10 replies, posted in Rochester NY MTG)

skyth wrote:

It's not just for EDH.  It does enable a combo (Thragtusk+Worldfire).  It's also for Timmy type players that go 'Hey, this is a cool effect'.  I don't think it was designed with EDH in mind, and was quickly banned from EDH.

I think it was entirely for EDH since it never has & never will see constructed play outside of EDH.  It is a big timmy effect and works into a strange johnny combo, but one that can only really be played in EDH - it is too slow anywhere else (lets be honest, thragfire omnidoor was never a real deck).  WoTC just didn't think of floating mana to re-cast your general, hence the ban.

Obzedat works, as does any exile effect like O-ring, fiend hunter, AoS, or any "EOT" blink effects like glimmerpoint stag, aetherling, or any of these.

Creature enchantments are typically a bad idea because they're an easy way to get 2-for-1'd unless the creature has hexproof.  But it has been that way forever, and this change doesn't really except make it somewhat harder to kill legendary targets.  WoTC surely didn't intend this to improve Geist, though that's a clear side effect. 

I'm fairly confident this change is, in part, because WoTC thought the current rule was unintuitive (why should your clone kill my Ruric Thar?).  I'm speculating this change anticipates a legendary-themed block, because otherwise why the change now rather than 2 years ago or 2 years from now? 

To me, Renounce seems like a great way to get rid of voltron generals, where they often hit the board early, maybe after a mana dork, and have some kind of protection.  Sure you can play around it by ensuring you've got another multicolored creature on the board, but it is hard to play around a single card in EDH. 

Renounce also gets around Lightning Greaves, Swiftfoot Boots, Whispersilk Cloak, and the many variants that everyone slaps on generals, which is nice.  You can't rely on it, since it is a 1-of, but I think it is more useufl now that clone effects don't work anymore, so we're left with just Wraths.

I don't know, I've never seen Geist killed by a clone effect in modern.  Do any modern lists run phantasmal image or metamorph?  Most of the time, I see players just blocking it & taking 4 from the flier.  Definitely a powerhouse, but I don't know if this change actually impacts how its played. 

They tried to give answers to geist in the latest set, stuff like renounce the guilds.  I don't think it'll work to keep a lid on Geist in standard, but I think renounce has just become an EDH staple...

Helios52 wrote:
Avon wrote:

Does that mean I can play a planeswalker's ability twice in a turn? For example, I have Garruk, Primal Hunter at loyalty 4 and I draw off the -3 thing. Then, I decide he's too weak so I cast another Garruk, Primal Hunter. Can my new one get a 3/3 Beast and become loyalty 4?

Yes. Its the same thing as if you decide to kill a planeswalker by using the last of his counters for an ability and then play another.

Yes, except you don't need to use all the loyalty counters, you can just kill them off at any point you've got a duplicate.  I think this is especially relevant for planeswalkers with high starting loyalty - like Karn Liberated in modern tron decks.

Should note that none of this goes into effect until M14 is released in mid/late July.  Between now and then, we've got modern masters.

May also be worth picking up some of the better legendary creatures, as Sigarda/Thrun may see even more eternal or EDH play, though goodness knows Geist is already everywhere.

As a side note, this is pretty good confirmation that Theros, the next block which is going to be Greek-themed, will have a legendary subtheme.  Like Kamigawa, if you remember that block, which incidentally is the last time they changed the legend rule (before Kamigawa, the first legend of a particular name stayed and a later ones died when they hit the board). 

I also think some of the spoiled enchantments are pretty good evidence Theros will be heavy on enchantments too.