Search options

A few more notes here:

One:

Because of things like Player Priority, there is a chance someone could send a creature to the graveyard, stack the Vat ability, and then stack an ability that would destroy the Vat. (Perhaps that would be useful if they had gained control of an opponent's creature and feared the Vat may be taken control of in a subsequent turn)

Two:

Since it is a "May" ability:
603.5. Some triggered abilities’ effects are optional (they contain “may,” as in “At the beginning of your upkeep, you may draw a card”). These abilities go on the stack when they trigger, regardless of whether their controller intends to exercise the ability’s option or not. The choice is made when the ability resolves. Likewise, triggered abilities that have an effect “unless” something is true or a player chooses to do something will go on the stack normally; the “unless” part of the ability is dealt with when the ability resolves.
114.1. Some spells and abilities require their controller to choose one or more targets for them. The targets are object(s), player(s), and/or zone(s) the spell or ability will affect. These targets are declared as part of the process of putting the spell or ability on the stack. The targets can’t be changed except by another spell or ability that explicitly says it can do so.

This means that the player does not have to choose whether or not to imprint a dying creature until all players have passed up responding to the trigger.

Three:

Since cards that get "exiled this way" or "exiled by card X" are put in exile in their own pile, even though the Vat may have been destroyed at the top of the stack, each exile effects resolving later still have the linked "If you do," rule and the ability will recognize they were exiled by an effect from the same source and dumps the previously exiled cards back into the graveyard. 

Essentially, If there was an exiled card, and multiple creatures die, you pick which one remains in exile and the rest go to the graveyard regardless of when in the stack the Vat is destroyed.

If the Vat re-enters play, or another Vat is played, a new pile is started in exile and the previously exiled card cannot have a token made out of it.

No, you may not pay 0. The 0 specifically replaces the mana cost, not "any cost to cast". Since a flashback cost is a separate type of alternate cost, it cannot be replaced by the "trap" cost this way.

Similarly to this, you cannot choose to Overload a card you've targeted with Snapcaster.

No, that would mean that you could not play additional lands for turn after you played Cultivate or other similar spells.

The Duel boxes in my experience tend to be more fun, especially when they are matched against each other as intended. (they usually have one or two cards that are just devastating to each other, and not many other decks)

On the other hand, the Event Decks have a sideboard and all, so you can even tweak it a little right out of the box without digging into your collection. One of my favorite things about these is that the strategies are pretty accessible to new players, so you can have them get an event deck, and maybe a half dozen other powerful cards to swap in, and they can go to a tournament with you without feeling like they brought a deck that let them down.

I'm not a judge, but I would say yes. The last part of the ability, "If you do, return each other card...", is not a separate triggered ability, but a conditional statement regarding how you handle the resolution of the imprint trigger.

Not just to bump the thread, but I agree that MTG should have a compassionate playerbase.  It's the sort of game that' is as relaxed or competitive as you want to make it.

I remember a few years ago going down to my local comic shop to buy a few singles on a friday night and seeing a new face asking around if he could get in a few practice rounds with his new deck.  Next thing I know, one of our local "pro" players is sitting next to him, walloping him with a turn 4 win with his elf-ball deck. I was flabbergasted that anyone would think this was OK to do with a new player. I subsequently told the new kid that I was sorry that happened, told him not everyone who plays there is a jerk and asked if he wanted to play a slow relaxed game.  I took an awful mana-screwed hand that started to turn around on turn 6, but we had to call it short in order to make way for the evening's draft event.  I'm sure it helped make him feel better about his own abilities and the environment he was playing in. 

On the other hand, competition is a healthy motivator, and I do keep a few decks together, that while they would never win a vintage/legacy tournament, have a healthy handful of old faithfuls (dual lands, and powerful things like demonic tutor, balance etc) Just to troll around and show new arrogant players that there are more ways to win than they think, and if they learn to play a better game/build a better deck, then maybe one of these days they'll beat the kid who doesn't use creatures while they still have a deck left to draw from.

I guess in conclusion, there's a lot more to it than who has what cards, and most of what keeps players wanting to sit down to duel together is sportsmanship. Unfortunately, some people just never get around to learning that aspect of the game. If you sent the kid to school with power 9 in his deck, I'd bet the gloating winner would just be a sore loser, and no one really learned anything.

In any case, I'm glad you took the initiative to get involved with your nephew on common ground. It's good to see family coming together over such a classic game.

To my knowledge, this one hasn't been going up, and probably won't for some time.

As I understand the only Duel box to have shot up in value was the Divine vs Demonic. While the overall power of the cards in that box were lower than Jace VS Chandra, it had a demonic tutor in it, and a really sweet new art on Akroma.

Even though the anime style art on the planeswalkers is pretty sweet, most people are content with the english versions they already have.

Maybe you want to hang onto it the way it is for now, but I wouldn't expect the price to go up until another couple years when supply of sealed boxes runs dry.

Personally, I've begun buying 2 of each box to either A) combine the best cards into one supercharged deck of each theme B) have the original decks that are well matched to teach people to play, and still have the cool alt arts to put in my edh decks, or C) use one while the other collects dust, and hopefully value.