If you want it, let me know, and I'll check your list.

27

(46 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Zooligan wrote:

Where's the best place to get the penny sleeves and rigid top loaders for a good price?  eBay?  What search terms do you use?

Walmart usually has 100 penny sleeves for $1 and 50 or so toploaders for a dollar or two.

I am, but your wishlist is small, and I don't have anything on it. Check my list, maybe?

29

(0 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Yep.

Closer to $150 than $200. Ebay completed shows 3 at $150, 2 at ~$170.

Just out of curiosity, how much are you selling the dragon for? Is it English?

32

(28 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

UnstableFlux wrote:

No, but I don't value the dual deck one any more than the Guildpact one.

Probably a good idea, because the dual deck one is worth about $6 less than guildpact. q:

33

(6 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Caravan vigil is just basic land smoothing. Farseek is actual acceleration. If you want that turn 3 sublime archangel or turn 4 thragtusk, only one of them will get you there.

34

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I'll trade my foil worldspine wurm for your foil worldspine wurm.

35

(5 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Because I don't. q:

Start a trade if interested.

I'd be interested in an Izzet die if you could find something on my tradelist for one.

Anyone want to make this trade?

38

(3 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I asked him to ship first, he agreed and we exchanged addresses.

I didn't send my cards (since he actually didn't give me his address yet).

Well, which is it? I assume the second one. If addresses were not exchanged, the trade is not considered completed.

39

(50 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

The rules of the site say:

"The sender is responsible for the cards to get to the destination, or to prove that he sent them."

and under guidelines it says:

"As the rules state, you are responsible for proving you send the cards and for their arrival at the destination."

I guess it just depends on if a tracking number proves that he sent them?

W:
3x Craterhoof Behemoth
1-2x Angel of Serenity
1x Griselbrand
2x Chromatic Lantern
2x Thragtusk
4x Loxodon Smiter

H:
Mirari's Wake
Earthcraft
Rofellos (fine)
Terminus
Sol Ring (CMD)
Nevinyrral's Disk (4th)
Primeval Titan
Chord of Calling
Defense of the Heart
Kitchen Finks
Sower of Temptation
Debtors' Knell
Spiritmonger
Black Market
Akroma's Memorial (M13)
Path to Exile (DD)

and a bunch more. When trading your Standard cards for my EDH/Modern cards, please offer a bit more value on your end.

Send me a trade!

On Magictraders, you are advised to wait 2 weeks for domestic mail, 1 month for international (Including from Canada to US or vice versa). For domestic, if it's been 2+ weeks, the other trader should resend or compensate you in some other agreed-to way. If it turns out that the Post Office screwed up somewhere along the way, and you end up receiving the first trade later, just send that one back or send back what you agreed to as compensation, depending on what you agree to.

test

He wants:
3x Restoration Angel
3x Thragtusk

He has:
Elspeth, Knight Errant (DD)
Hallowed Fountain
Karn Liberated
Life From The Loam (DD)
Divinity of Pride (ex)
Prismatic Omen (Good Condition)
Genesis (NM-)
Terminus
Kitchen Finks
Rakdos, Lord of Riots
Green Sun's Zenith
Isochron Scepter (DD)
Ajani Goldmane (Lorwyn, EX)
4x Dungrove Elder
Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord
Dragonskull Summit
Worldspine Wurm

up

Haves: http://deckbox.org/sets/93870?s=i&o=d

Wants:
1 Overgrown Tomb
2 Blood Crypt
1 Cavern of Souls (Lower priority than the Shocks)
1 Bonfire (Lower priority than the others)

Hoping to get as much of it as possible by Saturday (10/27) so I'm looking for quick trades, preferably just 1 or 2 large ones.

46

(9 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Interested in the Wrath of Gods, Vamp Tutor, Enlightened Tutor and a Yawgmoth's Will. Let me know values and if you see anything for them. Thanks!

When I talked to him last, he seemed to think it should stay up with the changes I made to it, but that could just be because I thought there was no way to delete it. I know he doesn't want his rep sullied though (and it shouldn't be), so I think this is the best course of action. The topic quite visibly shows that people should trade with him, I think. He didn't know the rules before, but now he does, and it's clear he wasn't being malicious or anything, and is really an exemplary trader. If he does wants me to request that it all be deleted, I certainly will.

EDIT: Also, thanks for explaining the Mod thing. (:

That reminds me, why do some people (Like you, for instance) have Moderator by their name? At first I thought you guys were mods, but then it became clear that you aren't. Is it just a title you get that's determined by post count?

EDIT: Also, I think the thread should stay up, because it shows that GalacticFisher is a good trader. That way, anyone who saw this thread last night knows that they should trade with him, as that may not have been the impression they walked away with last night.

imsully2 wrote:
Peripheryy wrote:
reignofkindo wrote:

GalacticFisher has sent me a message offering me the Aristocrat we agreed to, free of charge. Pretty sure that makes him a God among Men. He made everything right and then some, he just wasn't aware of the rules since some people never bothered following them with him. I'd ask that no one avoid trading with him, as he couldn't possibly have made this more right. I do think that JAKElolz does need some sort of Mod intervention though, as he has done this to at least two people now. But anyway, cheers to GalacticFisher!

Good man.

This is why I don't love the putting out of screen names unless the person has been given the opportunity to right the wrong before posting about it, this trader's reputation seems to have been given a black mark (Even if its small now) based on a misunderstanding of the rules. I applaud GalacticFisher as he seems to have more than righted the wrong and I think perhaps we should give a bit more time before we distribute out names. I'd also like to recommend that this thread be deleted, if this other user needs his own thread then so be it

Two things:

1. I'm not the one who said his name. I omitted it for a reason.

2. You can't delete threads. I've done everything I can by changing the title, the OP, and making that last post.

GalacticFisher has sent me a message offering me the Aristocrat we agreed to, free of charge. Pretty sure that makes him a God among Men. He made everything right and then some, he just wasn't aware of the rules since some people never bothered following them with him. I'd ask that no one avoid trading with him, as he couldn't possibly have made this more right. I do think that JAKElolz does need some sort of Mod intervention though, as he has done this to at least two people now. But anyway, cheers to GalacticFisher!