thebop's Puzzle Thief

BEN POPPEN's profile
MTG COLLECTION
- Inventory
- Tradelist
- Wishlist
- MTG DECKS (273)
- - Casual Brews
  - - mod 3 CMC Spirit Control
    - leg Broken and Slow
    - mod Crazy Cat Lady
    - leg Glitter Kittens
    - mod Spurits
    - leg Turtle Power
    - leg Vigilance
    - mod Wulvez
  - Cube Thoughts
  - - Reject Rares
  - EDH Brews
  - - vin **MOGIS REAL
    - vin **NEW OMNATH REAL
    - leg Ertai, the Corrupted
    - leg GOLD Naya Mayael EDH
    - leg New Rules EDH
    - leg Teysa EDH Idea
    - leg Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts
    - leg Tsabo Tavoc EDH Rough Draft
    - vin Vela EDH Start
  - Horrible Ideas
  - - Alternate WinCons
    - - mod Even Dumber
      - mod Hoarders
      - vin Self Mill
      - vin Suicide White (Dumb Blonde)
    - leg Because
    - sta Beebles
    - mod Feud Storm
  - LEGACY HATE
  - - vin Legacy Hate Brew 1
    - vin Legacy Hate Brew 2
    - leg Legacy Hate Brew 3
    - leg Legacy Hate Brew 4
    - leg Legacy White Budget
  - Modern Ideas
  - - mod Dank
    - mod Jund Derp
  - Multiplayer Plagues
  - - mod Global Wither
    - leg Group Hug
    - mod Look, Ma! No Hands!
    - mod R/B Bummer
  - Real Decks
  - Standard 2014
  - Standard Brew Ideas
  - - leg Alligaterz
    - mod Arcanist Combo
    - mod Augur Spree
    - mod Azor's Again
    - mod Bant Life Gain
    - mod Biomass Hydrastomp
    - mod Boros Sliver Legion
    - mod Colorless Standard
    - mod Copy of ShadowCity
    - mod GB Heroic DeathBeats
    - mod Hybrid Monowhite
    - mod Immortal Servitude
    - leg Master of Cruelties?
    - mod New Standard UR
    - mod Orzhov
    - mod Red Mess
    - mod Sac Race
    - mod Simic Obvious Aggro
    - mod Some Rocks
    - mod standard deathtouch trap
    - mod Standard Stall Out
    - mod Vraska Brew
  - leg **Alesha
  - com **MOGIS FINAL
  - mod America
  - mod Aristocratish
  - mod Athreos Festering Cauldron
  - mod Athreos Midrange
  - mod Athreos Value Town
  - mod Bant Infinite
  - mod batttle of wits mortal combat
  - mod Bestows
  - leg Better Punisher
  - mod Blue Combo
  - mod Booby Trap
  - vin Booby Trap Modern
  - mod Boros Lock
  - mod Boros Mid
  - mod Breaking Thassa's Ire
  - vin Brrrrrrrrrago
  - mod Bubbling Cauldron
  - mod BUG arcanist
  - mod Bug Combo
  - mod Burn
  - mod Burning Inquiry
  - leg Burns
  - mod BW Bestow
  - mod can't be countered
  - mod Cancer
  - leg Chance Encounter
  - mod Chimera Pump
  - mod Chromanticore
  - mod Cipherness
  - mod Codex Shredder
  - mod Collosus
  - mod Constellation?
  - mod Control Bounces
  - mod Copy of Athreos Midrange
  - mod Copy of Draw Cards
  - mod Copy of Filibuster
  - mod Copy of GreatAmericanScry
  - leg Copy of How many fetchlands are you running?
  - mod Copy of Midrange Infect
  - leg Copy of Monoblack Suicide
  - mod Copy of Pigpen
  - leg Copy of Puzzle Thief
  - leg Copy of Saproling
  - mod Copy of Simic G/U 3.0
  - vin Copy of Suicide White (Dumb Blonde)
  - mod Copy of Superbitches
  - mod Copy of Weener Assault Squad
  - mod Copy of Wildcard
  - mod Deciet
  - mod Defender Shift
  - mod Dega
  - mod Dega Storm Lock
  - mod Delver
  - mod Do I look like a man with a Plan?
  - mod Douche Tempo
  - mod Draw Cards
  - mod Elocute
  - leg Empress Galina
  - vin Empress Galina 1.0 (WIP)
  - mod Enchantment Control
  - mod Espercrats
  - mod Felhide Twin
  - mod Fill the Grave
  - mod Flash Tempo
  - mod Flash Tempo
  - mod For Kyle
  - mod Fuck it. LETS GO!
  - mod Fuck Removal
  - mod Giant
  - leg goblin tokenz
  - mod Goblinblossom
  - mod GR Land Tempo
  - mod Grand Architect Painter
  - mod Greenvolve
  - leg Grenzo EDH
  - mod Grixis
  - mod Grixis Morph
  - leg GW EDH TEEG
  - mod Have fun blocking
  - mod Heroes
  - mod High CMC UR
  - mod High Priests
  - leg How many fetchlands are you running?
  - mod Hydra Tricks
  - mod IDK Standard
  - mod infinite life
  - mod Infinite Mana
  - mod Infinite Reanimator?
  - mod Inspiration
  - mod Inspired Modern
  - vin Interrogation
  - vin Intet the Dreamer (Game Breaker) EDH
  - mod Izzet Tricks
  - mod Jund #1
  - mod Jund Current
  - mod Jund Mill
  - mod Jundsplosion
  - mod Junk
  - vin Junk Annoying
  - mod Junk Mill
  - mod Junk Rampimator
  - leg Keranos
  - mod KeyRune Challenge
  - mod Kiora Trial
  - vin Kruphix Current
  - leg Kruphix EDH
  - vin Land Grant Shenanigans
  - leg Legacy Athreos
  - leg Legacy Burn
  - leg Legacy Hate Brew #5
  - mod Legacy Troll Brew
  - mod Legendary Hatebears
  - mod Luck
  - leg Marchesa Instigator
  - mod Master Sneak
  - mod Midrange Infect
  - mod Mill Stomp
  - mod Mind Games
  - mod miracles
  - mod Modern
  - mod Modern Athreos 2
  - mod Modern BR
  - mod Modern Fling
  - mod Modern Friends
  - mod Modern Jund Fake
  - leg Modern Mazes End
  - mod Modern Ooze
  - mod Modern Rule Bears
  - mod Modern Suppression Field
  - mod Modern Suspend
  - vin MOGIS
  - vin Mogis EDH
  - mod Mono Green Ramp
  - leg Monoblack Suicide
  - mod Monoblue Arcanist
  - mod Monogreen
  - mod Monowhite
  - leg Most Legit Jund
  - vin Nath of the Gilt Leaf
  - mod Naya Lock
  - mod Naya Midrange
  - vin New Brew
  - mod New Jund
  - vin New Urza
  - mod Nivix Chimera
  - mod No Blocks
  - mod notion thief
  - vin Oona EDH
  - mod Ordeal Sac
  - mod Orzhov Mill?
  - mod Pain
  - mod Pantheon
  - vin Pauper
  - mod Pigpen
  - vin Pitch Cards
  - mod Platemail
  - mod Populate?
  - mod Power White
  - mod Purphoros
  - leg Puzzle Thief
  - mod Rakdos Armagedon
  - mod Rakdos Mid
  - mod Rampchantmess
  - mod Reanimate
  - vin Reaper King Tokens
  - mod Reckoner
  - leg Reject Rares
  - mod Restore Balance
  - vin Revised Jund Bros
  - mod RG
  - mod Rig and Armor
  - mod Rogue Tribal Modern
  - mod Rogue Tribal??
  - mod RUG Infinite Combo
  - mod RUG Infinity
  - mod Sanguine Sacrifice
  - leg Silly Chandra
  - mod Skybind Control
  - mod Slivers
  - vin Smothered
  - mod Soul sisters
  - mod Squid Pro Quo
  - leg Squirrels
  - mod Stall out
  - vin Standard Meta Call
  - mod Stormfire
  - mod Super Dumb Infect
  - mod Superbitches
  - mod Superheroes
  - vin Surgical Hate
  - mod Taxed
  - vin Teysa Combo
  - leg Teysa Combo Lock
  - vin Teysa Tiny Leader
  - mod Thasa
  - mod The Douchiest
  - mod The Worst
  - mod Theft
  - leg Thraximundar EDH Idea
  - mod Token Grixis
  - mod Torpor Orb Black
  - mod Torpor Orb White
  - mod Tricks
  - mod Turn 3 Bobo?
  - mod UB
  - mod UR Control
  - mod UR Fast
  - mod Waste Not
  - mod WB Artifact Aristocrats
  - mod Weener Assault Squad
  - mod Whitechant
  - mod Why Not Both?
  - leg Worldfire Mana Clash
  - vin Zurgo, Punisher

Ben Poppen's

Puzzle Thief

Type:

Deck Idea
Format (legal 👍)

legLegacy

Approx. Value:

$515.40

Buy

0 Likes

0 Comments

Avg. CMC 2.22

Card Color Breakdown

Card Type Breakdown

Aetherdrift
releases on February 14, 2025!

Buy on CardKingdom Buy on TcgPlayer

Aetherdrift
releases on February 14, 2025!

Buy on CardKingdom Buy on TcgPlayer

Main Deck - 60 cards, 15 distinct

Columns

	Name	Edition	$	Type	Cost
	Name	Rarity	$	Type	Color
Creature (8)
4	Notion Thief		$1.62	Creature - Human Rogue
4	Spellskite		$4.99	Artifact Creature - Phyrexian Horror
Instant (16)
4	Doom Blade		$0.29	Instant
4	Mana Leak		$0.17	Instant
4	Remand		$0.33	Instant
4	Spell Snare		$6.96	Instant
Sorcery (4)
4	Thoughtseize		$7.50	Sorcery
Artifact (4)
4	Teferi's Puzzle Box		$7.68	Artifact
Enchantment (4)
4	Jace's Erasure		$0.21	Enchantment
Land (24)
4	Cavern of Souls		$39.02	Land
7	Island		$0.13	Basic Land - Island
4	Polluted Delta		$14.21	Land
2	Reliquary Tower		$2.41	Land
3	Swamp		$1.38	Basic Land - Swamp
4	Watery Grave		$14.20	Land - Island Swamp

Sideboard - 15 cards, 4 distinct

	Name	Edition	$	Type	Cost
	Name	Rarity	$	Type	Color
Creature (4)
4	Pestermite		$0.40	Creature - Faerie Rogue
Enchantment (4)
4	Splinter Twin		$14.12	Enchantment - Aura
Land (7)
3	Mountain		$0.11	Basic Land - Mountain
4	Steam Vents		$14.60	Land - Island Mountain

Notes

So the plan is set up Notion Thief + Teferi's Puzzle Box + Jace's Erasure, so that when you pass the turn they put their hand on the bottom of their library, you get to draw that many cards, then they mill that many cards. They don't have a hand the rest of the game and you are drawing a new one every turn to keep things in order.

Also no one will ever play around Timeshifted black Fog.

Troll by boarding into Splinter Twin with Cavern of Souls always naming "Rogue" regardless

Current Proxy Legend:

Remand = Negate
Spellskite = Ratchet Bomb
Notion Thief = Whispering Madness
Teferi's Puzzle Box = Accorder's Shield
Thoughtseize = Duress
Spell Snare = Shock
Mana Leak = Lightning Strike
Scalding Tarn = Orzhov Guildgate

Comments

No comments yet.