Search options (Page 8 of 12)

Kaalia decks usually focus on cheating into play the biggest, baddest, fattest dudes in the game, so right away you can probably safely cut anything that isn't big or bad enough. I'd also be looking for ways to protect Kaalia herself, and ways to get just the guys I need into my hand.

I'd make the same cuts as Nighthawk, plus:
- Serra Avenger
- Furnace Whelp
- Lightkeeper of Emeria
- Dread Cacodemon

and start adding things like:
+ Griselbrand
+ Ryusei, the Falling Star
+ Kokusho, the whatever Star
+ Dragon Mage
+ Demonic Tutor
+ Lightning Greaves
+ Swiftfoot Boots
+ Enlightened Tutor
+ Necropotence

I think part of the problem is that people aren't providing much when they ask for help to begin with.

For example, this is a bad OP:

"hey guys this is my deck advice welcome <link>"

If I saw this, I wouldn't know where to begin. It doesn't tell us anything about what advice you need, what your budget is, whether you're planning to play casually or competitively, what your good/bad matchups are; it doesn't even tell us what format your deck is!

Think about what your deck is trying to do. Do you want to fill the board with a swarm of dudes and overwhelm your opponent? Do you want to deplete their resources until they are stuck top-decking and you have a full hand? Do you want to stick a single big threat early, and then make sure your opponent stays one step behind? Do you want to durdle around until you deal them 20 damage in a single turn? All of these things affect the way you build your deck; despite what you might think from tournament results, you can't just jam 4x Thragtusks in every green deck.

On the other hand, if you posted something like:

"Hey, this is a Standard deck I'm building and I want to do better at my local FNM with it. The goal is to drop a bunch of humans onto the board, cycle through my deck generating mana and drawing cards, and eventually burn them out with Burn at the Stake/Devil's Play. I don't have much difficulty against aggressive strategies like mono-red, but blue-white flash decks constantly beat me. Also I don't have much money so I'd like to stick to commons/uncommons. <link>"

Now I know exactly what you're asking for, which makes it MUCH easier to provide constructive criticism. I might ask why you are using white for Increasing Devotion, when your deck would be more consistent and faster with Burning-Tree Shamans (for example). And I'm not going to give useless advice like "run four Bonfires of the Damned", since you've already said you can't/won't.

Pretty sure I've got a spare Watery Grave I can send you.

I'll take those Huntmasters, started a trade with you.

I'd get as many shocklands as I possibly could, or maybe even as many Scars of Mirrodin fast-lands. Relatively stable value and used in every format. I wouldn't get anything that's currently Standard-legal.

What? No. What?

When you use an activated ability, you have to pay the cost for it. In Mortarpod's case, that cost is "Sacrifice this creature". There is no way for you to also sacrifice that creature to something else and get both effects. By the time you have priority to do anything, the creature has been sacrificed and is gone.

Nothing "knocks off" the germ token, you can't unequip equipment. You can use the ability twice by sacrificing the creature Mortarpod is equipped to, then equipping it to another creature, then sacrificing that creature as well.

Come to think of it, if I were to cut the green for red, I'd do something like:

2 Legion Loyalist
4 Invisible Stalker
4 Geist of Saint Traft
4 Silverblade Paladin

4 Boros Charm <- this does literally everything you want
4 Spectral Flight
4 Pursuit of Flight
4 Ethereal Armor
3 Madcap Skills
2 Detention Sphere
2 Gift of Orzhova

23 lands

Edit: To clarify, this is focused on replacing green pump and enchantments with red pump and enchantments; this may make it more of a glass cannon build. Legion Loyalist comes down as an alpha-striker if you end up with two guys out (perhaps a suited up stalker paired with a Paladin). Increasing Savagery and Rancor are gone, replaced with Madcap Skills, Pursuit of Flight and Gift of Orzhova (Holy Mantle would also be an option here). I think Boros Charm is the big reason to play red here, as it protects your guys against sweepers, can turn attacks from damaging to lethal, and can even deal that last 4 damage that you can't quite push through.

Note that white is now the biggest mana requirement here, so that should be considered when balancing the mana base.

I like this idea but I think green offers you more than you realize. Rancor is dangerous specifically because it comes back to your hand, which makes everything you play a threat. If you have a Geist with Madcap Skills, I can wrath the board with Supreme Verdict or Mutilate, or just double-block it, and you lose both cards instead of getting your aura back. The mana fixing that Avacyn's Pilgrim and Abundant Growth provide help make sure you have exactly the mana you need; getting stuck with a bunch of auras and the wrong land will feel like the worst thing.

If you do want to consider red, I'd run Pursuit of Flight over Curse of Stalked Prey. If you're getting in for double-strike damage with any of your guys, you're probably already winning, so the Curse is redundant.

This is true because Chromatic Star has two different effects. When it's put into the graveyard, you draw a card, no matter how it ends up there. So if you sacrifice it as part of its ability, you get the mana, then the triggered ability goes on the stack, and you draw a card if/when it resolves. If you sacrifice it some other way, say with Reshape, you still get to draw that card.

Compare that to Chromatic Sphere, where the two abilities are linked. If I sacrifice a Chromatic Sphere to Reshape, I don't get to draw anything because it's card draw is part of its activated ability, which I'm not using.

It sounds like you're pretty new to the format, so you definitely want to start by looking at what sets are legal and what cards are banned (all of which is here: http://www.wizards.com/magic/tcg/resour … /sfrmodern).

Wild Defiance was popular when infect decks were being run in Standard, as they let you turn free Phyrexian mana spells into pump spells (you could cast Mutagenic Growth, Dismember and Apostle's Blessing on your own guy to make him lethal without spending any mana). In Modern, the pump spells are good enough, and as you point out it's pretty bad to cast on turn 3 instead of attacking. Wild Defiance is a "win-more" card; if you play it and are able to win, you probably would have won without it.

Games can last a long time, which is a problem for a "glass cannon" build like Infect; if you haven't killed your opponent by turn 4 or 5, you're in a lot of trouble. Fetches don't really speed up the format, but they do make it trivially easy to run 3-4 colour decks. Tron can't afford them because they already have 12 slots devoted to their namesake lands. The mono-white thing you saw may have been Soul Sisters, which doesn't run fetchlands because (a) it's mono-white, and (b) the deck works by running cards that synergize with life-gain, and the damage from fetchlands can be relevant.

The way most modern infect decks play go something like this:

T1: Noble Hierarch or Glistener Elf
T2: Infect creature
T3: Cast some combination of Might of Old Krosa, Groundswell, Rancor, Apostle's Blessing, Vines of Vastwood and Mutagenic Growth, swing for 10 poison at once.

A good infect player will mulligan aggressively to get one of these hands. The bloodrush option exists, but to be honest is probably slower and less reliable than existing builds. You're already running blue, green and black for the infect creatures and tricks, and adding red for bloodrush and Assault Strobe means you have to hit just the right land drops. If you cut either blue or black, what happens when you don't get one of your infect creatures out? In general, if you play an infect creature, it will be bolted/unsummoned/exiled almost immediately, which means you may not even want to run it out on Turn 1. On turn 2 you can put it out and have Vines as protection, but that means you need to deal all 10 in a single strike. Countering combat tricks is a losing strategy in this matchup, so the uncounterability of Bloodrush doesn't help as much as you might think.

Death & Taxes gets played quite a bit online, but I've never seen it in person and wouldn't call it a "stereotypical" build. Here's the most common decks that you'll realistically run into:
- Jund (BRG good stuff)
- UWR Midrange
- Splinter Twin combo
- Storm (just had a key component banned so this may become less popular)
- Birthing Pod, either with Kiki-Jiki or Melira to infinite combo
- GW Hatebears
- Scapeshift
- Tron

Other builds:
- Death & Taxes
- Zoo
- Gifts Ungiven/Reanimator
- Infect
- UW or UWR Cryptic Control

If you're looking for a list to use Bloodrush in, look at Living End. It's a combo deck that uses lots of huge cycling creatures to fill the graveyard quickly, then casts a Cascade spell to cast Living End for free, wrathing your opponent's board and bringing your whole army in. It's already in Jund colours anyways, and it's a good way to start re-filling the graveyard for the next Living End if you need one.