Helios52 wrote:

Techincally the Mods dont actually do anything. They pretty much serve as mediators to help sort out the details and then its really just Sebi and Catinca that hold the power to approve the feedback.


from what i've seen of this sebi guy, it's obviously a power trip on his part.  ah well. when in rome...

Helios52 wrote:
Mattssacre wrote:
morph66 wrote:

26 (100% positive)

The rating system on this site is very flawed. This person has obviously had a lot of shady transactions in the last little while, but everyone that trades with him still see's the perfect score on 26 transactions. How can he be this shady with so many people and still not warrent a bad feedback?

First off the whole Plus/Minus system is flawed to begin with.  Even though ebay's system sucks, it would be nice to have something like that here.  Individual rating for communication, shipping time, card condition, etc.  Too many people are scared to give zero's or negatives because they don't want to receive a bad comment back.

There is no perfect system. Both Deckbox and eBay rating systems are based on people's bias opinion so the flaw lies more with people than the system. If you didnt have to get approval to get negative feedback (which is how it was BEFORE the new update),  it would turn into a pissing match over what happened and who really deserves the negative feedback and the deckbox team having to constantly change peoples rating.


much better to just give everybody gold stars

and no i had no idea all other sites do it. I still think it's a pretty piss poor way to track members. I mean this guy has been over 3 weeks late on several people's orders and he still doesn't bite a bad feedback? sorta pathetic, the mods should do a better job of i.p banning people who can't hold to their word. Also should be a minimum age limit to subscribe. As it stands a ten year old could make an account and do some real damage...

Mattssacre wrote:
morph66 wrote:

26 (100% positive)

The rating system on this site is very flawed. This person has obviously had a lot of shady transactions in the last little while, but everyone that trades with him still see's the perfect score on 26 transactions. How can he be this shady with so many people and still not warrent a bad feedback?

First off the whole Plus/Minus system is flawed to begin with.  Even though ebay's system sucks, it would be nice to have something like that here.  Individual rating for communication, shipping time, card condition, etc.  Too many people are scared to give zero's or negatives because they don't want to receive a bad comment back.


to many people are afraid to leave zeros or negatives? You aren't allowed to leave a negative score unless a moderator approves it, which is a complete joke to the system.

26 (100% positive)

The rating system on this site is very flawed. This person has obviously had a lot of shady transactions in the last little while, but everyone that trades with him still see's the perfect score on 26 transactions. How can he be this shady with so many people and still not warrent a bad feedback?

205

(12 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

As a newer poster to these forums i'm finding the guy's that have been here a long time are just very inconsistent in setting the vibe. On one hand someone asks me for stuff from my inventory, I ask for a couple of bucks more to satisfy my trade needs and i'm accused by a 250+ feedback guy that i'm a thief a scammer and out of my mind. Then 20 minutes later you got other regulars who are like "Let the guy overprice his stuff, he just won't sell it."

Alot of confusion is caused because you guy's seem to change your mind on what is acceptable or not. My 2 cents of course.

offered you a sphinx and verdict

dude gum, thanks

208

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

don't care

209

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

don't care

210

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

Kei_Asaki wrote:

Telling people that we're not their personal store, that people will be laughing at them, and any comments like that is very aggressive and verges on straight out bullying.

Kei_Asaki wrote:

Your first post in this thread, you said that this isn't his local game store

those 2 things are not the same bud. Just saying...

211

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

don't care

212

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

don't care

ahh ok cool, so as long as your card is still in the new sets, you can still have the old version

so what goes out in 2 weeks? is that innistrad? or is there more stuff

215

(12 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

it's to high, too high!!

ok cool, do i have alot of stuff in there that isn't standard?  is there a place where i can get lists of what is acceptable for each type of game?  thanks

I guess the goal would be to muster up some courage and go to a friday night magic. Right now I just use my cards to play casual with a buddy.

The problem is i don't even know what format FNM is, or any of the rulings. I've basically just been collecting cards... The point is i need some kind of inspiration.

came up with this but i don't think i'm to big a fan.
http://deckbox.org/sets/475170

nullkarmaexception wrote:

Why exactly are we mad at this guy?  How do we know he is a scammer?  I think that's quite a heft accusation to throw around on here without any proof.


So you think he bought 12 copies of each game to get those promos?  12 bonescylth slivers, that's 10 copies of the xbox360 version. The proof sort of is in the way these cards are given out. Unless you are implying that he traded for all 12 promo cards.

220

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

don't care

221

(18 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

don't care

222

(3 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

I don't know why its so hard for people to put down the card tags, so we don't have to look up the cards you want.

223

(3 replies, posted in Reddit MTG Trades)

you don't have anything in your tradelist worth over 4$,,,,

dude your wishlist is like 90 000$  you have like 16 pages of cards.
Do you have a specific cardlist for just the 400 cube? I know i have at least 100$ worth of the stuff you need.

weell i have a bunch of stuff you need. but i don't want to go through all my cards to have you trade with someone else, so i need some kind of guarantee here lol