Bill 's Red
 
Type: Deck Idea
Format (legal 👍) legLegacy
Approx. Value:
$135.10

0 Likes 0 Comments
Avg. CMC 3.22
Card Color Breakdown
Card Type Breakdown

Please consider subscribing to a Deckbox Premium Account, which provides many useful collecting, trading and deckbuilding features and removes ads! View More Details
Remove ads
Main Deck - 522 cards, 366 distinct
Columns
Name  Edition $ Type Cost
Rarity Color
Creature (522)
1 Aether Membrane
$0.35 Creature - Wall
1 Akoum Battlesinger
$0.10 Creature - Human Berserker Ally
1 Akoum Hellkite
$0.19 Creature - Dragon
1 Akroan Sergeant
$0.02 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Alesha, Who Smiles at Death
$0.12 Legendary Creature - Human Warrior
2 Ambush Party
$0.14 Creature - Human Rogue
2 Anaba Bodyguard
$0.06 Creature - Minotaur
1 Anaba Shaman
$0.06 Creature - Minotaur Shaman
2 Anarchist
$0.03 Creature - Human Wizard
1 Ancient Hydra
$0.21 Creature - Hydra
1 Ancient Kavu
$0.07 Creature - Kavu
1 Arc Mage
$0.16 Creature - Human Spellshaper
1 Arc Runner
$0.13 Creature - Elemental Ox
1 Armorer Guildmage
$0.13 Creature - Human Wizard
1 Arms Dealer
$0.14 Creature - Goblin Rogue
1 Atarka Efreet
$0.03 Creature - Efreet Shaman
1 Atog
$0.22 Creature - Atog
3 Balduvian Barbarians
$0.05 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Balduvian War-Makers
$0.09 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Balthor the Stout
$0.42 Legendary Creature - Dwarf Barbarian
1 Barbarian Guides
$0.16 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Barbarian Lunatic
$0.10 Creature - Human Barbarian
2 Barbarian Outcast
$0.12 Creature - Human Barbarian Beast
2 Barrage Ogre
$0.09 Creature - Ogre Warrior
2 Barrage Tyrant
$0.16 Creature - Eldrazi
4 Battle Rampart
$0.02 Creature - Wall
2 Battle-Rattle Shaman
$0.20 Creature - Goblin Shaman
2 Beasts of Bogardan
$1.80 Creature - Beast
2 Belligerent Whiptail
$0.01 Creature - Wurm
4 Berserkers of Blood Ridge
$0.03 Creature - Human Berserker
2 Bird Maiden
$0.30 Creature - Human Bird
2 Blade-Tribe Berserkers
$0.15 Creature - Human Berserker
2 Blaster Mage
$0.09 Creature - Human Spellshaper
2 Blistering Barrier
$0.16 Creature - Wall
2 Blisterstick Shaman
$0.05 Creature - Goblin Shaman
2 Blood Hound
$0.38 Creature - Dog
2 Bloodcrazed Goblin
$0.06 Creature - Goblin Berserker
2 Bloodfire Colossus
$0.26 Creature - Giant
2 Bloodfire Dwarf
$0.31 Creature - Dwarf
2 Bloodfire Kavu
$0.13 Creature - Kavu
2 Bloodrock Cyclops
$0.14 Creature - Cyclops
2 Bloodthorn Taunter
$0.12 Creature - Human Scout
2 Bogardan Firefiend
$0.29 Creature - Elemental Spirit
2 Bola Warrior
$0.12 Creature - Human Spellshaper Warrior
2 Bone Shaman
$0.10 Creature - Giant Shaman
2 Branded Brawlers
$0.06 Creature - Human Soldier
3 Brassclaw Orcs
$0.11 Creature - Orc
1 Brimstone Mage
$0.14 Creature - Human Shaman
1 Brutal Deceiver
$0.08 Creature - Spirit
2 Caldera Kavu
$0.10 Creature - Kavu
3 Canyon Minotaur
$0.05 Creature - Minotaur Warrior
1 Capricious Efreet
$0.17 Creature - Efreet
1 Cavern Crawler
$0.11 Creature - Insect
1 Ceremonial Guard
$0.13 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Chainflinger
$0.15 Creature - Beast
1 Chancellor of the Forge
$0.90 Creature - Phyrexian Giant
1 Chandler
$0.26 Legendary Creature - Human Rogue
1 Chandra's Spitfire
$0.09 Creature - Elemental
1 Chasm Guide
$0.04 Creature - Goblin Scout Ally
1 Cinder Elemental
$0.09 Creature - Elemental
1 Cinder Wall
$0.04 Creature - Wall
1 Cosi's Ravager
$0.08 Creature - Elemental
1 Craven Giant
$0.08 Creature - Giant
1 Crazed Firecat
$0.28 Creature - Elemental Cat
1 Crimson Hellkite
$0.49 Creature - Dragon
1 Cunning Sparkmage
$0.33 Creature - Human Shaman
1 Cyclops Gladiator
$0.12 Creature - Cyclops Warrior
1 Deathforge Shaman
$0.08 Creature - Ogre Shaman
1 Desolation Giant
$0.15 Creature - Giant
1 Dragon Whelp
$0.04 Creature - Dragon
1 Dwarven Berserker
$0.21 Creature - Dwarf Berserker
1 Dwarven Grunt
$0.29 Creature - Dwarf
1 Dwarven Lieutenant
$0.30 Creature - Dwarf Soldier
1 Dwarven Miner
$0.70 Creature - Dwarf
1 Dwarven Nomad
$0.21 Creature - Dwarf Nomad
1 Dwarven Patrol
$0.15 Creature - Dwarf
1 Dwarven Pony
$1.14 Creature - Horse
1 Dwarven Recruiter
$1.60 Creature - Dwarf
2 Dwarven Soldier
$0.12 Creature - Dwarf Soldier
1 Dwarven Strike Force
$0.27 Creature - Dwarf Berserker
1 Dwarven Thaumaturgist
$1.58 Creature - Dwarf Shaman
1 Dwarven Trader
$0.16 Creature - Dwarf
1 Dwarven Vigilantes
$0.10 Creature - Dwarf
1 Dwarven Warriors
$0.24 Creature - Dwarf Warrior
1 Earth Elemental
$0.03 Creature - Elemental
1 Ekundu Cyclops
$0.12 Creature - Cyclops
1 Ember Beast
$0.02 Creature - Beast
1 Embersmith
$0.02 Creature - Human Artificer
2 Emrakul's Hatcher
$0.21 Creature - Eldrazi Drone
1 Enslaved Dwarf
$0.29 Creature - Dwarf
1 Enslaved Scout
$0.15 Creature - Goblin Scout
1 Enthralling Victor
$0.10 Creature - Human Warrior
1 Eron the Relentless
$0.17 Legendary Creature - Human Rogue
2 Fallen Ferromancer
$0.19 Creature - Phyrexian Human Shaman
1 Fault Riders
$0.08 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Ferrovore
$0.06 Creature - Beast
1 Fickle Efreet
$0.35 Creature - Efreet
2 Fiery Hellhound
$0.02 Creature - Elemental Dog
1 Fire Ants
$0.39 Creature - Insect
2 Fire Elemental
$0.02 Creature - Elemental
1 Fire Servant
$0.63 Creature - Elemental
1 Firebrand Ranger
$0.22 Creature - Human Soldier Ranger
1 Firemantle Mage
$0.04 Creature - Human Shaman Ally
1 Fireslinger
$0.22 Creature - Human Wizard
1 Flailing Manticore
$0.35 Creature - Manticore
2 Flailing Ogre
$0.09 Creature - Ogre
1 Flailing Soldier
$0.13 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Flame Spirit
$0.05 Creature - Elemental Spirit
1 Flameborn Hellion
$0.05 Creature - Hellion
1 Flameborn Viron
$0.04 Creature - Phyrexian Insect
1 Flamekin Brawler
$0.11 Creature - Elemental Warrior
1 Flametongue Kavu
$0.14 Creature - Kavu
1 Flowstone Crusher
$0.11 Creature - Beast
1 Flowstone Giant
$0.13 Creature - Giant
1 Flowstone Overseer
$0.31 Creature - Beast
1 Flowstone Salamander
$0.17 Creature - Salamander
1 Flowstone Shambler
$0.05 Creature - Beast
1 Flowstone Wall
$0.07 Creature - Wall
1 Furnace Scamp
$1.67 Creature - Phyrexian Beast
1 Galvanoth
$0.28 Creature - Beast
1 Gerrard's Irregulars
$0.09 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Ghitu Fire-Eater
$0.13 Creature - Human Nomad
1 Gnathosaur
$0.04 Creature - Dinosaur
1 Goatnapper
$0.19 Creature - Goblin Rogue
1 Goblin Arsonist
$0.06 Creature - Goblin Shaman
1 Goblin Artillery
$0.11 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Balloon Brigade
$0.05 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Bushwhacker
$5.03 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Chariot
$0.09 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Chirurgeon
$0.35 Creature - Goblin Shaman
2 Goblin Digging Team
$0.06 Creature - Goblin
2 Goblin Elite Infantry
$0.09 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Gardener
$0.16 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Gaveleer
$0.11 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Glider
$0.10 Creature - Goblin
2 Goblin Hero
$0.10 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Kaboomist
$0.36 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin King
$11.39 Creature - Goblin
2 Goblin Matron
$0.21 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Piker
$0.03 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Raider
$0.11 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Ringleader
$0.46 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Rock Sled
$0.07 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Roughrider
$0.03 Creature - Goblin Knight
1 Goblin Ruinblaster
$0.18 Creature - Goblin Shaman
1 Goblin Sappers
$0.12 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Sharpshooter
$24.01 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Shortcutter
$0.03 Creature - Goblin Scout
1 Goblin Soothsayer
$0.42 Creature - Goblin Shaman
1 Goblin Spelunkers
$0.11 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblin Swine-Rider
$0.11 Creature - Goblin
2 Goblin Tunneler
$0.10 Creature - Goblin Rogue
1 Goblin Vandal
$0.16 Creature - Goblin Rogue
1 Goblin War Buggy
$0.20 Creature - Goblin
1 Goblin Wardriver
$0.32 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Goblins of the Flarg
$0.27 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Gorilla Shaman
$0.35 Creature - Ape Shaman
1 Gray Ogre
$0.03 Creature - Ogre
1 Grim Lavamancer
$0.31 Creature - Human Wizard
1 Grizzled Wolverine
$0.09 Creature - Wolverine
1 Grotag Siege-Runner
$0.07 Creature - Goblin Rogue
1 Grotag Thrasher
$0.04 Creature - Lizard
1 Guttersnipe
$0.21 Creature - Goblin Shaman
1 Halberdier
$0.08 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Hammer Mage
$0.31 Creature - Human Spellshaper
1 Heart Sliver
$1.42 Creature - Sliver
1 Hell-Bent Raider
$0.27 Creature - Human Barbarian
2 Hellspark Elemental
$0.24 Creature - Elemental
1 Highland Berserker
$0.06 Creature - Human Berserker Ally
3 Hill Giant
$0.06 Creature - Giant
1 Hired Giant
$0.30 Creature - Giant
1 Hissing Iguanar
$0.06 Creature - Lizard
1 Hooded Kavu
$0.09 Creature - Kavu
1 Humble Defector
$0.13 Creature - Human Rogue
2 Hurloon Minotaur
$0.15 Creature - Minotaur
1 Hurloon Shaman
$0.26 Creature - Minotaur Shaman
1 Incurable Ogre
$0.04 Creature - Ogre Mutant
1 Inferno Titan
$0.25 Creature - Giant
1 Inner-Flame Acolyte
$0.14 Creature - Elemental Shaman
1 Invader Parasite
$0.28 Creature - Phyrexian Insect
1 Jackal Familiar
$0.10 Creature - Jackal
1 Jackal Pup
$0.10 Creature - Jackal
1 Joven
$0.28 Legendary Creature - Human Rogue
1 Jund Battlemage
$0.13 Creature - Human Shaman
1 Kamahl, Pit Fighter
$0.26 Legendary Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Karplusan Giant
$0.28 Creature - Giant
1 Kavu Aggressor
$0.08 Creature - Kavu
1 Kavu Glider
$0.08 Creature - Kavu
1 Kavu Recluse
$0.10 Creature - Kavu
1 Kavu Runner
$0.13 Creature - Kavu
1 Kavu Scout
$0.08 Creature - Kavu Scout
1 Keeper of Kookus
$0.10 Creature - Goblin
1 Keldon Arsonist
$0.14 Creature - Human Soldier
2 Keldon Berserker
$0.06 Creature - Human Soldier Berserker
1 Keldon Firebombers
$1.55 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Keldon Warlord
$0.16 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Kiln Fiend
$0.12 Creature - Elemental Beast
1 Kird Ape
$0.18 Creature - Ape
1 Kolaghan Aspirant
$0.02 Creature - Human Warrior
1 Kolaghan Forerunners
$0.05 Creature - Human Berserker
1 Koth's Courier
$0.16 Creature - Human Rogue
1 Kozilek's Sentinel
$0.03 Creature - Eldrazi Drone
1 Kris Mage
$0.15 Creature - Human Spellshaper
1 Kuldotha Phoenix
$0.22 Creature - Phoenix
1 Kuldotha Ringleader
$0.01 Creature - Giant Berserker
1 Kyren Glider
$0.06 Creature - Goblin
1 Kyren Legate
$0.20 Creature - Goblin
1 Kyren Sniper
$0.13 Creature - Goblin
2 Laccolith Grunt
$0.04 Creature - Beast
1 Laccolith Titan
$0.28 Creature - Beast
1 Laccolith Warrior
$0.14 Creature - Beast Warrior
1 Laccolith Whelp
$0.08 Creature - Beast
1 Lagac Lizard
$0.05 Creature - Lizard
1 Latulla, Keldon Overseer
$0.37 Legendary Creature - Human Spellshaper
2 Lava Runner
$0.41 Creature - Lizard
4 Lavafume Invoker
$0.12 Creature - Goblin Shaman
2 Lavastep Raider
$0.03 Creature - Goblin Warrior
2 Lesser Gargadon
$0.09 Creature - Beast
2 Lightning Berserker
$0.09 Creature - Human Berserker
6 Lightning Elemental
$0.04 Creature - Elemental
2 Lightning Hounds
$0.13 Creature - Dog
2 Lizard Warrior
$0.09 Creature - Lizard Warrior
2 Loafing Giant
$0.18 Creature - Giant
4 Longhorn Firebeast
$0.14 Creature - Elemental Ox Beast
2 Lowland Giant
$0.13 Creature - Giant
2 Mad Dog
$0.10 Creature - Dog
2 Mage il-Vec
$0.12 Creature - Human Wizard
2 Magma Giant
$0.25 Creature - Giant
2 Magmaw
$0.06 Creature - Elemental
2 Makindi Sliderunner
$0.02 Creature - Beast
2 Manic Vandal
$0.09 Creature - Human Warrior
2 Minotaur Tactician
$0.13 Creature - Minotaur
2 Mire Kavu
$0.11 Creature - Kavu
2 Mogg Bombers
$0.13 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Conscripts
$0.27 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Fanatic
$0.14 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Flunkies
$0.05 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Jailer
$0.16 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Raider
$0.26 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Sentry
$0.22 Creature - Goblin Warrior
2 Mogg Squad
$0.17 Creature - Goblin
2 Mogg Toady
$0.08 Creature - Goblin
2 Molten Ravager
$0.13 Creature - Elemental
2 Mons's Goblin Raiders
$0.09 Creature - Goblin
4 Mountain Goat
$0.20 Creature - Goat
2 Nettle Drone
$0.11 Creature - Eldrazi Drone
2 Obsidian Giant
$0.14 Creature - Giant
2 Ogre Arsonist
$0.99 Creature - Ogre
2 Ogre Battledriver
$0.73 Creature - Ogre Warrior
2 Ogre Menial
$0.05 Creature - Phyrexian Ogre
2 Ogre Resister
$0.01 Creature - Ogre
2 Ogre Sentry
$0.02 Creature - Ogre Warrior
6 Ogre Taskmaster
$0.04 Creature - Ogre
2 Ogre Warrior
$0.09 Creature - Ogre Warrior
2 Ondu Champion
$0.03 Creature - Minotaur Warrior Ally
4 Orcish Artillery
$0.08 Creature - Orc Warrior
3 Orcish Captain
$0.22 Creature - Orc Warrior
1 Orcish Farmer
$0.06 Creature - Orc
1 Orcish Healer
$0.33 Creature - Orc Cleric
1 Orcish Lumberjack
$0.64 Creature - Orc
1 Orcish Spy
$0.12 Creature - Orc Rogue
1 Orcish Veteran
$0.15 Creature - Orc
1 Oxidda Daredevil
$0.16 Creature - Goblin Artificer
1 Oxidda Scrapmelter
$0.11 Creature - Beast
1 Pardic Arsonist
$0.22 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Pardic Collaborator
$0.25 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Pardic Firecat
$0.20 Creature - Elemental Cat
1 Pardic Lancer
$0.13 Creature - Human Barbarian
1 Pardic Swordsmith
$0.08 Creature - Dwarf
1 Petradon
$0.29 Creature - Nightmare Beast
1 Petravark
$0.12 Creature - Nightmare Beast
1 Pitchstone Wall
$0.25 Creature - Wall
1 Plated Geopede
$0.06 Creature - Insect
1 Possessed Barbarian
$0.24 Creature - Human Barbarian Horror
1 Pouncing Kavu
$0.10 Creature - Kavu
2 Priest of Urabrask
$0.31 Creature - Phyrexian Human Cleric
1 Primordial Ooze
$0.15 Creature - Ooze
2 Prodigal Pyromancer
$0.09 Creature - Human Wizard
1 Pygmy Pyrosaur
$0.05 Creature - Lizard
1 Rage Nimbus
$0.26 Creature - Elemental
3 Raging Goblin
N/A Creature - Goblin Berserker
1 Raging Gorilla
$0.25 Creature - Ape
1 Raging Spirit
$0.08 Creature - Spirit
1 Raka Disciple
$0.10 Creature - Minotaur Wizard
1 Razor Swine
$0.10 Creature - Phyrexian Boar
1 Reckless Cohort
$0.01 Creature - Human Warrior Ally
1 Reckless Ogre
$0.12 Creature - Ogre
1 Ridgeline Rager
$0.04 Creature - Beast
1 Robber Fly
$0.24 Creature - Insect
1 Rock Badger
$0.06 Creature - Badger Beast
1 Rockslide Elemental
$0.26 Creature - Elemental
1 Rogue Kavu
$0.11 Creature - Kavu
2 Sabretooth Tiger
$0.09 Creature - Cat
1 Sawtooth Ogre
$0.12 Creature - Ogre
1 Scarred Puma
$0.15 Creature - Cat
1 Scoria Cat
$0.22 Creature - Cat
1 Scoria Elemental
$0.02 Creature - Elemental
1 Screamreach Brawler
$0.03 Creature - Orc Berserker
1 Searing Spear Askari
$0.10 Creature - Human Knight
1 Seismic Mage
$0.33 Creature - Human Spellshaper
1 Shatterskull Recruit
$0.01 Creature - Giant Warrior Ally
3 Shivan Dragon
$0.11 Creature - Dragon
1 Shock Troops
$0.04 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Skitter of Lizards
$0.06 Creature - Lizard
1 Slag Fiend
$0.16 Creature - Phyrexian Construct
1 Slash Panther
$0.07 Artifact Creature - Phyrexian Cat
1 Slavering Nulls
$0.05 Creature - Goblin Zombie
1 Slimy Kavu
$0.10 Creature - Kavu
1 Slingshot Goblin
$0.11 Creature - Goblin
1 Soldier of Fortune
$0.23 Creature - Human Mercenary
1 Spark Mage
$2.09 Creature - Dwarf Wizard
1 Sparkmage Apprentice
$0.04 Creature - Human Wizard
1 Spikeshot Elder
$0.30 Creature - Goblin Shaman
1 Spitting Drake
$0.17 Creature - Drake
1 Sprinting Warbrute
$0.03 Creature - Ogre Berserker
1 Spur Grappler
$0.09 Creature - Beast
1 Squee, Goblin Nabob
$0.20 Legendary Creature - Goblin
2 Stalking Vengeance
$0.26 Creature - Avatar
4 Stone Giant
$0.08 Creature - Giant
4 Storm Shaman
$0.13 Creature - Human Cleric Shaman
2 Stormbreath Dragon
$1.68 Creature - Dragon
2 Suq'Ata Lancer
$0.16 Creature - Human Knight
2 Tahngarth, Talruum Hero
$0.94 Legendary Creature - Minotaur Warrior
2 Talruum Champion
$0.16 Creature - Minotaur
4 Talruum Minotaur
$0.05 Creature - Minotaur Berserker
2 Terra Ravager
$0.14 Creature - Elemental Beast
2 Thunderscape Apprentice
$0.12 Creature - Human Wizard
2 Thunderscape Battlemage
$0.21 Creature - Human Wizard
2 Thunderscape Familiar
$0.27 Creature - Kavu
2 Tor Giant
$0.12 Creature - Giant
4 Torch Slinger
$0.04 Creature - Goblin Shaman
2 Tormentor Exarch
$0.12 Creature - Phyrexian Cleric
2 Trained Orgg
$0.08 Creature - Orgg
2 Tuktuk Scrapper
$0.23 Creature - Goblin Artificer Ally
2 Tuktuk the Explorer
$0.26 Legendary Creature - Goblin
2 Tundra Kavu
$0.09 Creature - Kavu
2 Tunneling Geopede
$0.20 Creature - Insect
2 Urabrask the Hidden
$1.22 Legendary Creature - Phyrexian Praetor
3 Uthden Troll
$0.16 Creature - Troll
1 Valakut Invoker
$0.02 Creature - Human Shaman
1 Valakut Predator
$0.05 Creature - Elemental
1 Varchild's Crusader
$0.13 Creature - Human Knight
1 Vent Sentinel
$0.03 Creature - Elemental
1 Vestige of Emrakul
$0.04 Creature - Eldrazi Drone
1 Veteran Brawlers
$0.28 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Viashino Grappler
$0.24 Creature - Viashino
1 Viashino Outrider
$0.13 Creature - Viashino
1 Viashino Spearhunter
$0.01 Creature - Viashino Warrior
2 Viashino Warrior
$0.05 Creature - Viashino Warrior
1 Vile Aggregate
$0.08 Creature - Eldrazi Drone
1 Volcanic Dragon
$0.03 Creature - Dragon
1 Vulshok Heartstoker
$0.02 Creature - Human Shaman
1 Vulshok Refugee
$0.10 Creature - Human Warrior
1 Wall of Diffusion
$0.12 Creature - Wall
2 Wall of Fire
$0.02 Creature - Wall
1 Wall of Heat
$0.36 Creature - Wall
1 Wall of Stone
$0.29 Creature - Wall
1 Wandering Goblins
$0.10 Creature - Goblin Warrior
1 Warbringer
$0.09 Creature - Orc Berserker
1 Warmonger
$0.32 Creature - Minotaur Monger
1 Whip Sergeant
$0.03 Creature - Human Soldier
1 Whipkeeper
$0.11 Creature - Dwarf
1 Wild Colos
$0.09 Creature - Goat Beast
2 Wild Jhovall
$0.25 Creature - Cat
1 Zada, Hedron Grinder
$0.22 Legendary Creature - Goblin Ally
1 Zerapa Minotaur
$0.08 Creature - Minotaur
Sideboard - 0 cards, 0 distinct
No cards here. :(

Comments
Log in to comment