Search options (Page 3 of 54)

The deck can be seen here: http://deckbox.org/sets/935332

I'm not going to pretend that I know a ton about modern, but I'm admittedly a bit surprised to see that list doing so well given its reliance on standard legal cards (most of which don't have the power level needed to cut it in modern).

As for the effect of DTK in modern, there haven't been a ton of cards spoiled thus far that even begin to crack the threshold for modern playables.  I'm thinking Narset has a chance, as does Anticipation (not too far off from Impulse which saw play in its day), one or two of the commands might make the cut, and a few others.

There isn't a card that actually removes the only 4x restriction that I'm aware of (not even conspiracies).  Sadly, outside of Relentless Rats and Shadowborn Apostle you will have to just look for functional reprints a la Llanowar Elves = Fyndhorn Elves = Elvish Mystic.

- Glen Elendra gets -1/-1 counters, so it won't work with Sage of Fables.  You need the biomancers to make that work.

- Rhystic Study is really easy to get around and, as long as the opponent is willing to pay 1 more for their spells, you draw nothing.

- Prime Speaker Zegana will almost always be rather large and being able to draw 4+ cards is pretty solid... even if they remove  her, you've gotten the benefit out of her.

- As for the evasion, if you're doing things right, your stuff should be big enough that you don't need evasion.  You can go through their stuff.

- Mirrorweave won't transfer counters, although it would be funny to target Kalonian Hydra and attack with 3-4 creatures...

- The list is a bit better, but I think it would be best to focus in more on the key strategy and make the list tighter and more consistent.  I think you can pull most of the proliferate stuff in exchange for more card draw and/or removal options.

Not being a modern player for the most part I can't really say too much other than that you definitely need a way to beat Abzan.  I could also see where Smallpox might be worth looking at putting in there.

I can also say that Waste Not is a trap.  I can see where it would work in Legacy with Dark Ritual at your disposal, but in modern (and standard for that matter) it just doesn't get the job done.  Without the perfect mix of cards it just doesn't do much for you and you end up having to try to replenish your hand AND the opponent's hand at the same time to generate any benefit off of it.  To that end, if you do decide to run it, Burning Inquisition, Reforge the Soul, and things of that nature are what you're looking for (because they trigger the discard but also end up replenishing the opponent's hand.  It's actually pretty weird that for Waste Not to work you actually WANT the opponent to have cards in hand - once they're in top-deck mode, it card is just a waste of space.

This is a pet peeve of mine so please don't take this as personal, but you really have to explain more about the deck and the play environment for us to offer any meaningful comments.  Specifically, we need answers to the following:

- What format are you looking to play?  Is this for standard, modern, edh/commander, tiny leaders, casual kitchen table?
- In that same vein, where are you looking to play this?  Are you looking to make waves in a major tourney or just whoop up on your buddies?
- What is the strategy YOU envision the deck using?  Put another way, if you could have an ideal opening hand, what would be in it and why?  What is the overall plan?
- What is the budget you're looking to use to make the deck better?  Are you open to spending a bit or does it have to be cards out of your existing inventory?

The simplest way I can say this is this: The more detail you give us, the more we can tell you (and the more likely we'll actually spend the time to say anything - no effort on your part, no effort on ours)

This is a pet peeve of mine so please don't take this as personal, but you really have to explain more about the deck and the play environment for us to offer any meaningful comments.  Specifically, we need answers to the following:

- What format are you looking to play?  Is this for standard, modern, edh/commander, tiny leaders, casual kitchen table?
- In that same vein, where are you looking to play this?  Are you looking to make waves in a major tourney or just whoop up on your buddies?
- What is the strategy YOU envision the deck using?  Put another way, if you could have an ideal opening hand, what would be in it and why?  What is the overall plan?
- What is the budget you're looking to use to make the deck better?  Are you open to spending a bit or does it have to be cards out of your existing inventory?

The simplest way I can say this is this: The more detail you give us, the more we can tell you (and the more likely we'll actually spend the time to say anything - no effort on your part, no effort on ours)

So first off, I don't know anyone who is outright going to build a deck for you.  The whole idea of this portion of the site is to look for comments on existing decks or get pointers on how to improve your general deckbuilding practice.

That being said, I took a brief look at your inventory and you certainly have the fetches and some of the bigger value cards to look at building Esper (blue-white-black) or at least Azorius given the Flooded Strands and Elspeth, Sun's Champions you already have.  Personally, unless you're super attached to the foil strand, you can trade it for 95% of the remaining cards you would want.  I would recommend building a more controlling build that centers around Elspeth and Ugin, the Spirit Dragon as your primary win conditions.  This means you'll need plenty of removal and counters... think End Hostilities, Banishing Light, Dissolve, Dissipate, and things of that nature.  Other cards to consider including are Aetherspouts, Whelming Wave, Suspension Field, Dig Through Time, etc.

Beyond that, once you have a build pieced together I'd imagine you'll get much more input.

I do think that Mardu midrange has the pieces to be truly competitive, but you just need to look at the top lists of that strategy to draw inspiration.  Outpost Siege is another pretty solid addition from FRF that can give you some needed card advantage.  Keep with it.  There's no need for ANOTHER abzan midrange player out there.

So a few thoughts...

1) Mardu Shadowspear really just doesn't do much here.  If you're looking for something to just put in the way to stabilize against aggro, then Typhoid Rats is just better.  But if you're looking at an aggro strategy, well, the curve would need to be flipped and you need to focus on EITHER Butcher of the Horde or Brutal Hordechief but definitely not both.

2) Mogis just seems bad here.  Sure, he could get turned online once in a blue moon and his ping is decent, but realistically Palace Siege is easier to cast and does essentially the same thing with the added benefit of life gain for you.  Alternately, you can have it on khans mode to recur things like Rabbles when they inevitably get killed.

3) Purphoros is just being cute.  The only time in which he's really going to be all that effective is if you're running things like Hordeling Outburst, which I would imagine you don't want to steer toward.  The number of times he'll make a difference is likely few and far between, especially as a 1x.

4) Deflecting Palm strikes me as a SB card, but then again, I haven't seen a single list that uses it to great effect.

5) I'm generally seeing things in your SB that you would likely want maindeck, i.e., Banishing Light or Sorin, Solemn Visitor.  Your SB is also missing any sort of a sweeper like Drown in Sorrow or Anger of the Gods.

6) I'd also think to run with something like Outpost Siege could be effective given the "card draw" it generates for you.  I watched someone run it at gameday and it single-handedly was the reason he won the round.

Decisions will vary based on your meta, but this deck seems caught between trying a more aggressive route or just going with a mid-range strategy.  If you're going aggro, B/W warriors or something to that end would be more effective.  If you're going mid-range, I'd say to be sure to go that route.

From the look of your current build you're not really focused on the hornets as much as you're trying to do something with large toughness creatures.  If you want to go hornets, then look for ways to really get them.  Look at the Sidisi Whip decks that have been doing well for a while as a baseline to work from and then move out from there as you like.

As a side note, the fight effect cards you have are sub-optimal.  You would be better suited with Savage Punch and Setessan Tactics to force fights with your Hornet Nests and the hornets generated.  I would also suggest looking at Whip of Erebos as a means to get more hornets when you've milled the queen or if you need to recur the nest for another fight.

So, first off, I see that almost all of the cards are from more recent sets.  This isn't a problem, but I would suggest looking through some of the older sets as there are a considerable number of really good soldiers to work with.

Second, are you playing primarily 1-on-1 or are you playing multiplayer games?  That will determine the sorts of cards you want to slide in here.

I'd suggest tossing out the abzan counter scheme as it's a bit too conditional and requires more work than it's worth.  Things like Door of Destinies, Glorious Anthem, Legion's Initiative, and the like all pump without counters needed.  They're more resilient to other players' disruption.  I'd also suggest looking into sliding Elspeth, Sun's Champion into the deck for even more soldiers.  Note the forthcoming duel deck for Elspeth actually will have a number of cards you would benefit from, i.e., Veteran Armorer and Veteran Swordsmith.

I could go on, but I'd also suggest looking for other builds out there to identify cards you'll want to go pick up over-time.  For instance, this build, http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/rw-soldier-edh/, uses Agrus Kos, Wojek Veteran as the commander for extra pumps.  And, more generally, that build sticks to the tribal theme more closely.

Good luck!