Search options (Page 47 of 54)

Not related to the trades at hand... I read the link you posted Scurvey, but I noted it was from 2010.  Did the dude manage to pull it off?

You have a good start here, but at the moment your creatures don't really help your overall objective.

First off, are you worried about maintaining a specific format?  At current it says your deck qualifies as "Extended."  That's ultimately going to decide which cards you're going to keep or need to pick up.

One creature that the best mill decks just NEED is Hedron Crab.  Every time you play a land, they lose three cards.  Play one on the first turn and another on the second turn and you've already cost them three cards and on turn three when you play a land, BAM, that's nine total cards down already.  Also, they're good blockers for early game.

For other creatures, Fog Bank and Guard Gomazoa give you incredible blockers that can stop practically anything without getting killed.  The only real problem you would have there is with trample damage.

Thought Scour and Mind Sculpt are GREAT.  But you should also pick up Traumatize, Increasing Confusion, and Jace's Erasure.  Each of those will give you more spells that can drop a LOT of cards quickly.

Another fun card to work with in a Mill context is Geralf's Mindcrusher which can serve as a big creature if you get stuck trying to win with damage, OR, you can pair it with Nephalia Smuggler/Deadeye Navigator/Ghostly Flicker/Conjurer's Closet to flicker and repeat the ETB effect, causing your opponent to drop cards five at a time.  If you have Altar of Dementia you could make them drop another 10 cards when you sack it and then just flicker it to lose the undying counter - rinse repeat.

Trepanation Blade is a good piece to pair with any creature as it normally will cost them 3-4 cards per attack, if not more.  Keening Stone can be a good win condition as it can snowball VERY quickly.

I would also recommend consolidating your countermagic as it's really scattered at the moment.  More Mana Leaks, Unsummons (or even Boomerang).  If you're open to any format, Temporal Adept is a great option that can essentially give you as many Boomerangs as you could want.

Lastly, Jace, Memory Adept is perfect for mill decks.  His +0 ability results in an opponent dropping 10 cards.  If you can protect him at all, that can REALLY add up quickly.

I hope all of that helps make sense.  The best part being not much I've suggested is all that expensive.  Jace is pretty pricey (~$10) and Altar of Dementia is mid-range (~$3-5), but outside of those, pretty much any of these should be around a dollar or less to pick up.

Good luck!

While the UW infect would be mean (especially if you put in Infinite Reflection to pair with either Sublime Archangel or Blightsteel Colossus), I think there's less potential there as about half of the deck will be rotating out.  Then again, that might be the incentive to get the playtime out of it now while you still can.

I'd still go the green route myself, but I'm more partial to green than blue.  That and the inclusion of Ajani, Caller of the Pride when thinking about Sublime Archangel and Champion of Lambholt is just nuts.  If you get Ajani to his ultimate, the game is over no matter which way you look at it.  I can see where some changes could be made to make it a bit more flexible/versatile, but I'll let you figure out which way to go before really getting into any of that stuff.

Your obvious trample options will be Rancor and Ring of Kalitas.

Just remember that Infinite Reflection will make your creatures all copies of the Sublime Archangel and will rock some MAJOR exalted, but only one can attack at a time... It'll be interesting to see if that combo pans out or not, as I can imagine plenty of other creatures that could prove equally useful with Infinite Reflection that you could attack with multiples of.  My first thought would be to pair that with Elderscale Wurm if you're going green.  7/7 trample and you cannot die unless they kill all of them?  Yes please.

Sadly I have a move, a TON of work, and a conference to get through first.  My guess would be either mid-late August or early September. 

Oh I totally agree a color coding or something more recognizable would be great.  At current it turns blue if the person is online, but otherwise, yeah, that's about all there is.

I'm thinking there are two separate things here that you could run with, but I'm not sure both can work in the same deck.

First, I think Exalted is about to be beaten to death and I'd actually say to run it mono-white with tokens out the arse.  Pair Sublime Archangel with some major token generation... yeah... that'd get sick pretty quick.  It gives you ENORMOUS attacks while keeping back an absolute ton of chump blockers.  You end up putting Akroma's Memorial and BAM!

Second, run along similar lines to what you are now, but you need more mana ramping toward the ultimate goal of Avacyn and Planar Cleansing.  From my, admittedly limited, experience with exalted, it's really tough to have quality blockers given what has exalted.  And the rate at which your mana curve climbs, I don't know that you'll still be around when you finally have the mana to dump a Planar Cleansing or Avacyn.  Somberwald Sage?  Or at least SOMETHING to help speed the playing of the major angels.  Rites of Flourishing?  They'll rotate in October, but could help you speed things up.  Because the way it strikes me, you're playing the game for the BIG stuff, so who cares what big things they're sitting on, yours are better.  So you need to speed things up so you can lower the boom on them.

As another thought, why no Cathedral of War?  If you're going exalted, might as well go all in, right?

In either case you're onto something good here, I just think you're stuck on the fence between the two ways to run with it.

Yeah.  Someone had suggested those, but I wasn't wanting the entire deck to be rotating come RTR release.... It should be workable to lose BOP and Beast Within.

So I've been running a LOT of hand simulations on this deck and it struck me that I'd still be susceptible to a lot of removal once I'm out of Sheltering Words.  So I dropped Chandra, the Firebrand and one of the Sheltering Words to be replaced by 2x Ring of Evos Isle.  I won't get any counters, but that's a guaranteed hexproof for two colorless.

Were there any other thoughts on sideboard items or anything else here?

Okay, I'll lead off by admitting that Standard isn't my strong suit.  Having said that much, the deck as it currently sits isn't Standard legal anyway.  Bloodhall Ooze, despite being what looks like a pretty mean card in a RGB deck, is the one tripping you up there.

That aside, I'm really just not seeing how you're really going to beat the opponent unless you manage to overwhelm them or keep trading pieces while Undying keeps yours in play.  That or just stalling until Curse of the Pierced Heart wears them down.  Am I wrong here?  What are the win conditions you're looking for here?

Given the setup you're running, I would say your best option(s) would be to either run a crazy sacrifice engine to produce something cool or, perhaps more reasonably, to focus on control and board clearing effects, as you don't really care if your creatures die or not (gotta love undying).  I'm thinking Mutilate or Killing Wave  (also Black Sun's Zenith would be an option until it rotates)are really going to be your winners here, as you can drop just wipe out EVERYTHING, and chuckle as your items come back into play thanks to undying.  You're still going to want your spot removals for bigger creatures that they'll pay the life for or that you can't quite catch with Mutilate.  Thankfully, since you don't care about sacking creatures, you can run Bone Splinters for this.

Then, if you're making undying your main mechanic, you could rock Mikaeus, the Unhallowed and Undying Evil to protect some creatures that might not have it.  This opens the door for you to use fun items like Blood Artist, Pitchburn Devils, Rage Thrower, and Flayer of the Hatebound (who already has undying on his own).  Then all your critters dying turns into a weapon.  Vexing Devil would help out, as you either get a 4/3 you can give undying to, or they lose four life (which adds up quickly).

Beyond that, and I know most of the suggestions I've made thus far are black, but Demonic Rising could work well here too, as you end up sacking down to one creature and then get a 5/5 demon for the trouble.  Good sack engines in Standard include Bloodflow Connoisseur (that you already have in there) and Disciple of Griselbrand, who could help you gain a fairly good amount of life in the process.

Anyway, those are some thoughts.  Just be careful with this strategy though, as Tormod's Crypt has made a reappearance in M13 and I could almost guarantee it will be a sideboard staple at most FNMs soon, given that it completely screws over any reanimator decks.

For the Elemental deck, I just see a lot of options where you can end up giving elemental creatures +1/+1 counters which would be more consistently effective than relying on the evoke ability for your creatures.  Don't forget that Tormod's Crypt (which they reprinted in M13) would wipe your graveyard clean, so that automatically would take out the majority of Splinterfright's or Lord of Extinction's strength.  Also, I totally spaced saying it, but there is very little in the deck to help against flyers.

For the mana ramping, Everflowing Chalice and Cultivate help, but look at their costs.  Everflowing Chalice will need you to spend at least two to kick it in order to help at all, likely four if you want it to be better than just a BOP.  Cultivate helps get lands, but at a three-drop.  They help accelerate things, but I always like to do my mana acceleration earlier rather than later.  Those help, but BOP, Somberwald Sage or even things as simple as Llanowar Elves or Avacyn's Pilgrim can make a lot of difference, as they provide mana ramping earlier and chump blockers later.

Lastly, the reason the card art isn't showing is just from a few typos/spelling errors (it happens to all of us).  I normally preview my replies first to ensure that all the cards display properly, but I'm a stickler for details.