Search options (Page 45 of 54)

First a question: Why did you link to the old version of the deck?  I spent the first 5 minutes looking over the old version thinking up feedback before I realized that I should be looking at the other one.

Second, while I'm the one imsully is noting about the need for versatility , I have to agree with him that you need consistency.  If you cannot put at least 2x of a card, it's likely not worth it or had better not be an integral part of your plan.  For example, if you're running a vampire deck and throw in a copy of Exquisite Blood as a 1x just for grins, that's fine, but if it's potentially important to your strategy, it NEEDS to be at least 2x if not more.  This will both increase the consistency but also will make the deck easier to learn to play, as you don't have to sit and figure everything out from scratch all the time.

I'm also going to go one step further than imsully to say that I really think the deck is lacking in direction and would likely get wiped out pretty quickly at an FNM (I don't mean to be harsh).  Of course there is likely to be variation in the meta at each LGS, but I'm just not seeing the power play here.  If you want to do a crazy blue/white spirit deck, run it, but at current there are a lot of pieces that aren't fitting in.

Here are a few questions/comments/suggestions:

1) Jace's Phantasm - I understand the pull toward including a possible one-drop 5/5 flyer, but I'm not seeing any mill elements here.  So were you just planning on waiting until they have 10 cards via spells or casualties from combat/removal?  If that's the case, you might as well be waiting to hard-cast Avacyn.

2) Serra Avenger - again, a nice, tempting card, but those spots could be better utilized with either spirit creatures (there are quite a few of them), spells to pull Lingering Souls out of the graveyard (Archaeomancer or better in your case Runic Repetition), or some sort of removal, i.e., Oblivion Ring.

3) Blade Splicer - same story here.  You're making tokens, so that's good, but those tokens aren't playing into the strength of the deck.  Why not go with 2x more Drogskol Captain to ensure the spirits are that much stronger?

4) Mirran Crusader - I would sideboard him.  He doesn't fit the scheme, doesn't have flying, and his protections only work in some instances.  You could easily use those spots to either include additional Phyrexian Metamorphs or something else to that end.

5) You're splashing black just for one Unburial Rites?  If it's an Avacyn casting strategy, why not just run Defy Death?  It might cost one more, but it's in a primary color AND would give her two +1/+1s.

6) Why not just run 3x Ponder?

7) Take or leave this one - personally I like Divine Reckoning over Day of Judgment.  Same cost, but you can maintain a creature advantage if you have the biggest one, AND it has flashback, giving you double the board clears for the same number of slots in the deck.

8) Why Spectral Flight when most of your creatures are already flying?  You could take advantage of Favorable Winds and pump all those spirits even more.  If you're looking for a pump enchantment, Spirit Mantle is still standard legal and gives your guy both +1/+1 and protection from creatures (not a bad deal there).  Others that would better serve you are there.

9) The sideboard needs some work here, but I'll leave that up to you to figure out as you're more familiar with the decks your opponents are more likely to be running.

Then you can simplify your land base in a way that it will be much more consistent.  I think there's a lot of promise here and it could be pulled together without spending too much or putting forth too much effort.  Soon you'll be pumping lots of spirit tokens that can dive in for plenty of flying damage.  Confetti will stream from the rafters, music will be playing, etc., etc.

Mass Appeal could actually prove useful in there too.  Especially if you drop the artifact diggers.

Outside of what imsully said, I would say there are two things here that could be changed for some improvement.

1) Rolling Temblor - really this is a great card if you have a deck chock full of flyers or are worried about your opponent rolling out an army of tokens.  However, the beauty of Krenko, Mob Boss is that YOUR army of tokens will likely be larger than theirs, meaning the last thing you want to do is drop a spell that does two damage to every creature without flying.  Without at least two Goblin Chieftains on the battlefield, this card will essentially neutralize your entire deck.  The obvious card to substitute in is Bonfire of the Damned, but I'm not going to say you should go drop $80 or more for two cards.  I would likely go with 2x Goblin Grenade in their place.

2) You really don't have any means by which to draw more cards once your hand is spent, and given that it's a goblin deck, that reality could be much sooner than expected.  Just spitballing here, but Rummaging Goblin will at least help ensure you can dig through to get the spells you really want (a big plus if you're over 60 cards).  I've always been a believer that Elixir of Immortality is great when you're using things that require you to discard, as your curve might not be to the point where you want a six-drop, but you can discard it for something more useful, recycle the library, and find it the next go round.

Other options to help with the drawing situation could be Descendants' Path - as it has a pretty good chance of helping you out, as all your creatures are goblins; Staff of Nin?  It has a cost of six, but that's about when you'll be needing more cards anyway.  You get to ping things and draw more.

I'll keep thinking about it, but that's just what comes to mind now.

It's one of those things that the higher dollar cards are obviously at a premium, and unless the person offering it is dying to unload it, you likely would have to give up some value (within reason).  Unless it's a roughly even swap (i.e. Thundermaw for Sublime Archangel or Cavern of Souls, etc) i don't think it's unreasonable to expect.

I know that I've received countless offers for 2-3 five or six dollar cards that are comprised of like 1-2 one dollar cards and a bunch of junk rares/uncommons.  In those instances, I'm VERY unlikely to do the trade unless I'm picking up a LOT of value.  I've instituted a rule that I go by low values (because 1. you could just go buy them at that price, and 2. it doesn't inflate the values of penny cards) and that the person trading up will have to give up value.  I get that you have to start somewhere, but man...

I could be tempted... let me dig around with some of what you have.  Do you prefer avg or min prices?  (I'm on min now with the blip in TGC averages).

I'll second that Goblin Grenade would be nice; but, as an alternative, you could kill multiple birds with one stone by subbing Arms Dealer in for the Mogg Flunkies.  Given that you'll be pumping goblins out like an assembly line, you won't mind sacking a few of them to pick off their flyers (or other obnoxious creatures).

The other problem I can see here is when you get decked.  Then what?  I've found that the best decks are the ones that find a way to keep your hand full or at least to pull what you're really looking for.  The only thought I really have there that fits this deck would be Rummaging Goblin/Mad Prophet (the former obviously benefits more with Krenko).   The other alternative would be Descendants' Path which could let you drop more creatures out for nothing - all the more reason to stick to only 1 or 2 types.

I'll openly admit, I was having a brain fart when I thought you could exile lands with Oblivion Ring.  In either case, I can see it still being FAR more useful than Pacifism, so I've swapped that up.  I dropped the Scroll of Avacyn for Abundant Growth as those can help both if the mana comes out stacked in favor of green, provide the red for Gisela, OR, they're a one green "draw a card."

On the one hand I can see where Rancor is the "cat's meow" for a lot of people, but really, in a lot of instances if your creatures aren't giving you a board advantage already... either way, it can only solve so many problems on its own.

For the board clearing, I thought Divine Reckoning is a good option.  I don't end up clearing my own enchantments and will likely have a larger creature on the board than them, so why not drop it?  Also, it has flashback, so for only two slots I can technically clear the board four times.

Ground Seal - I was really just looking for a placeholder there, so it'll be easy to swap out.

Nevermore - you're correct that it wouldn't stop Delver decks cold, but man, if you could get that out, so many players have ZERO creativity and just build the exact same decks with only five cards in them.  And if you were to draw into one at the right time, you could TOTALLY stop countermagic.  That's a luxury most of us would pay for, right?

Gisela will make a cameo and we'll see how she works out.

Thanks, as always, for the input.

How did said Humans and Angels deck fare for you?