CommonLot's Prelim 19-12-31

CommonLot's

Prelim 19-12-31

Type:

Deck Idea
Format (invalid)

staStandard

Approx. Value:

$7,193.40

0 Likes

0 Comments

Avg. CMC 2.89

Card Color Breakdown

Card Type Breakdown

Main Deck - 2281 cards, 247 distinct

Columns

	Name	Edition	$	Type	Cost
	Name	Rarity	$	Type	Color
Creature (933)
2	Anafenza, Kin-Tree Spirit		$0.21	Legendary Creature - Spirit Soldier
20	Arboreal Grazer		$0.15	Creature - Beast
2	Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier		$4.61	Legendary Creature - Angel // Legendary Creature - Angel
8	Arclight Phoenix		$2.39	Creature - Phoenix
8	Bloodsoaked Champion		$0.10	Creature - Human Warrior
8	Bomat Courier		$0.21	Artifact Creature - Construct
2	Bone Picker		$0.11	Creature - Bird
48	Bonecrusher Giant // Stomp		$0.16	Creature - Giant // Instant - Adventure	//
15	Brazen Borrower // Petty Theft		$5.81	Creature - Faerie Rogue // Instant - Adventure	//
4	Burning-Tree Emissary		$0.31	Creature - Human Shaman
2	Bygone Bishop		$0.18	Creature - Spirit Cleric
4	Cauldron Familiar		$0.69	Creature - Cat
10	Cavalier of Thorns		$1.27	Creature - Elemental Knight
4	Charming Prince		$2.36	Creature - Human Noble
1	Crackling Drake		$0.08	Creature - Drake
2	Decimator of the Provinces		$1.06	Creature - Eldrazi Boar
12	Deputy of Detention		$0.23	Creature - Vedalken Wizard
4	Dimensional Infiltrator		$0.21	Creature - Eldrazi
4	Dread Wanderer		$0.48	Creature - Zombie Jackal
2	Dreadhorde Arcanist		$1.22	Creature - Zombie Wizard
8	Eidolon of the Great Revel		$4.27	Enchantment Creature - Spirit
3	Elite Guardmage		$0.15	Creature - Human Wizard
38	Elvish Mystic		$0.38	Creature - Elf Druid
12	Elvish Rejuvenator		$0.06	Creature - Elf Druid
18	Empyrean Eagle		$0.19	Creature - Bird Spirit
1	Emrakul, the Promised End		$40.19	Legendary Creature - Eldrazi
5	Fae of Wishes // Granted		$0.19	Creature - Faerie Wizard // Sorcery - Adventure	//
4	Favored Hoplite		$0.21	Creature - Human Soldier
3	Feather, the Redeemed		$0.56	Legendary Creature - Angel
4	Gadwick, the Wizened		$0.55	Legendary Creature - Human Wizard
11	Ghalta, Primal Hunger		$3.49	Legendary Creature - Elder Dinosaur
5	Gilded Goose		$1.73	Creature - Bird
4	Gingerbrute		$0.15	Artifact Creature - Food Golem
27	Glorybringer		$0.23	Creature - Dragon
16	Goblin Chainwhirler		$0.93	Creature - Goblin Warrior
28	Goblin Rabblemaster		$1.16	Creature - Goblin Warrior
2	God-Eternal Oketra		$7.88	Legendary Creature - Zombie God
4	Gruul Spellbreaker		$0.23	Creature - Ogre Warrior
4	Gurmag Angler		$0.19	Creature - Zombie Fish
3	Gutterbones		$0.37	Creature - Skeleton Warrior
4	Hanweir Garrison		$4.13	Creature - Human Soldier
1	Hanweir Militia Captain // Westvale Cult Leader		$0.51	Creature - Human Soldier // Creature - Human Cleric
4	Harbinger of the Tides		$0.42	Creature - Merfolk Wizard
4	Haunted Dead		$0.08	Creature - Zombie
2	Hope of Ghirapur		$1.92	Legendary Artifact Creature - Thopter
2	Hypnotic Sprite // Mesmeric Glare		$0.12	Creature - Faerie // Instant - Adventure	//
2	Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet		$8.48	Legendary Creature - Vampire Warrior
19	Kari Zev, Skyship Raider		$0.22	Legendary Creature - Human Pirate
1	Knight of Autumn		$0.55	Creature - Dryad Knight
8	Knight of the Ebon Legion		$1.88	Creature - Vampire Knight
3	Korvold, Fae-Cursed King		$12.97	Legendary Creature - Dragon Noble
12	Legion Warboss		$0.34	Creature - Goblin Soldier
1	Liliana, Heretical Healer // Liliana, Defiant Necromancer		$3.46	Legendary Creature - Human Cleric // Legendary Planeswalker - Liliana
36	Llanowar Elves		$0.62	Creature - Elf Druid
4	Lotleth Troll		$0.19	Creature - Zombie Troll
32	Lovestruck Beast // Heart's Desire		$0.15	Creature - Beast Noble // Sorcery - Adventure	//
1	Massacre Girl		$0.56	Legendary Creature - Human Assassin
4	Master of Waves		$0.70	Creature - Merfolk Wizard
19	Mausoleum Wanderer		$2.31	Creature - Spirit
4	Mayhem Devil		$0.73	Creature - Devil
4	Merfolk Trickster		$1.00	Creature - Merfolk Wizard
4	Militia Bugler		$0.08	Creature - Human Soldier
12	Monastery Swiftspear		$0.41	Creature - Human Monk
14	Murderous Rider // Swift End		$0.60	Creature - Zombie Knight // Instant - Adventure	//
4	Narcomoeba		$0.26	Creature - Illusion
7	Nebelgast Herald		$0.11	Creature - Spirit
1	Nullhide Ferox		$0.26	Creature - Beast
2	Phyrexian Revoker		$0.23	Artifact Creature - Phyrexian Horror
4	Prized Amalgam		$0.31	Creature - Zombie
6	Questing Beast		$5.50	Legendary Creature - Beast
5	Rankle, Master of Pranks		$0.91	Legendary Creature - Faerie Rogue
18	Rattlechains		$0.21	Creature - Spirit
8	Reflector Mage		$0.35	Creature - Human Wizard
12	Rekindling Phoenix		$0.63	Creature - Phoenix
10	Rhonas the Indomitable		$4.83	Legendary Creature - God
4	Rotting Regisaur		$2.14	Creature - Zombie Dinosaur
4	Satyr Wayfinder		$0.13	Creature - Satyr
8	Scavenging Ooze		$0.35	Creature - Ooze
14	Scrapheap Scrounger		$0.22	Artifact Creature - Construct
25	Selfless Spirit		$2.69	Creature - Spirit Cleric
4	Skilled Animator		$0.02	Creature - Human Artificer
36	Soul-Scar Mage		$1.87	Creature - Human Wizard
4	Soulflayer		$0.19	Creature - Demon
12	Spectral Sailor		$0.13	Creature - Spirit Pirate
28	Spell Queller		$1.15	Creature - Spirit
15	Steel Leaf Champion		$0.79	Creature - Elf Knight
4	Stitcher's Supplier		$2.30	Creature - Zombie
4	Stonecoil Serpent		$0.64	Artifact Creature - Snake
16	Supreme Phantom		$0.26	Creature - Spirit
9	Surrak, the Hunt Caller		$0.33	Legendary Creature - Human Warrior
7	Sylvan Caryatid		$6.58	Creature - Plant
5	Syr Faren, the Hengehammer		$0.05	Legendary Creature - Human Knight
4	Tempest Djinn		$0.16	Creature - Djinn
4	Tenth District Legionnaire		$0.09	Creature - Human Soldier
3	Thassa, God of the Sea		$3.21	Legendary Enchantment Creature - God
4	Thorn Lieutenant		$0.12	Creature - Elf Warrior
4	Thraben Inspector		$0.24	Creature - Human Soldier
9	Tireless Tracker		$1.41	Creature - Human Scout
8	Torbran, Thane of Red Fell		$1.82	Legendary Creature - Dwarf Noble
6	Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger		$24.29	Legendary Creature - Eldrazi
8	Ulvenwald Hydra		$1.77	Creature - Hydra
4	Viashino Pyromancer		$0.04	Creature - Viashino Wizard
8	Vizier of Tumbling Sands		$0.20	Creature - Human Cleric
9	Walking Ballista		$16.71	Artifact Creature - Construct
1	Whirler Rogue		$0.08	Creature - Human Rogue Artificer
1	Wicked Wolf		$0.24	Creature - Wolf
9	World Breaker		$0.83	Creature - Eldrazi
1	Yahenni, Undying Partisan		$0.48	Legendary Creature - Aetherborn Vampire
2	Yorvo, Lord of Garenbrig		$0.27	Legendary Creature - Giant Noble
8	Young Pyromancer		$0.58	Creature - Human Shaman
4	Zetalpa, Primal Dawn		$0.23	Legendary Creature - Elder Dinosaur
1	Zurgo Bellstriker		$0.42	Legendary Creature - Orc Warrior
Instant (252)
1	Abrade		$0.19	Instant
7	Aspect of Hydra		$0.17	Instant
2	Assassin's Trophy		$3.13	Instant
7	Boros Charm		$4.96	Instant
6	Cast Down		$0.23	Instant
31	Collected Company		$9.01	Instant
4	Defiant Strike		$0.04	Instant
3	Depose // Deploy		$0.08	Instant // Instant	//
9	Dig Through Time		$0.61	Instant
2	Dromoka's Command		$0.50	Instant
2	Expansion // Explosion		$0.26	Instant // Instant	//
2	Expedite		$0.25	Instant
11	Fatal Push		$1.79	Instant
1	Fiery Temper		$0.11	Instant
4	Gods Willing		$0.10	Instant
8	Grisly Salvage		$0.82	Instant
8	Izzet Charm		$0.32	Instant
8	Lightning Axe		$0.19	Instant
32	Lightning Strike		$0.14	Instant
6	Magma Spray		$0.02	Instant
8	Opt		$0.09	Instant
6	Quench		$0.04	Instant
4	Reckless Rage		$1.32	Instant
2	Searing Blood		$0.25	Instant
2	Shock		$0.03	Instant
4	Shrapnel Blast		$0.27	Instant
2	Sinister Sabotage		$0.09	Instant
6	Spell Pierce		$0.18	Instant
5	Stubborn Denial		$3.55	Instant
3	Titan's Strength		$0.09	Instant
2	Unbreakable Formation		$0.30	Instant
2	Unsubstantiate		$0.18	Instant
44	Wild Slash		$0.13	Instant
4	Wizard's Lightning		$0.15	Instant
4	Wizard's Retort		$0.16	Instant
Sorcery (112)
7	Chart a Course		$0.20	Sorcery
4	Creeping Chill		$0.11	Sorcery
8	Doublecast		$0.15	Sorcery
1	Finale of Promise		$1.89	Sorcery
8	Gather the Pack		$0.15	Sorcery
4	Gird for Battle		$0.06	Sorcery
8	Hidden Strings		$0.20	Sorcery
8	Light Up the Stage		$0.18	Sorcery
12	Nissa's Pilgrimage		$0.43	Sorcery
8	Pore Over the Pages		$0.11	Sorcery
2	Shimmer of Possibility		$0.05	Sorcery
2	Skewer the Critics		$0.19	Sorcery
13	Strategic Planning		$0.01	Sorcery
8	Sylvan Scrying		$0.39	Sorcery
8	Thoughtseize		$11.49	Sorcery
4	Traverse the Ulvenwald		$0.88	Sorcery
7	Treasure Cruise		$0.34	Sorcery
Artifact (40)
2	Aethersphere Harvester		$0.26	Artifact - Vehicle
15	Embercleave		$6.48	Legendary Artifact - Equipment
4	Ghostfire Blade		$0.19	Artifact - Equipment
4	Heart of Kiran		$0.31	Legendary Artifact - Vehicle
4	Oketra's Monument		$1.37	Legendary Artifact
7	The Great Henge		$56.18	Legendary Artifact
4	Witch's Oven		$0.90	Artifact
Enchantment (23)
4	Curious Obsession		$0.76	Enchantment - Aura
4	Ensoul Artifact		$0.44	Enchantment - Aura
1	Experimental Frenzy		$0.17	Enchantment
4	Favorable Winds		$0.32	Enchantment
4	Leyline of Anticipation		$1.82	Enchantment
4	Trail of Crumbs		$0.41	Enchantment
2	Vessel of Nascency		$0.13	Enchantment
Planeswalker (48)
20	Chandra, Torch of Defiance		$1.69	Legendary Planeswalker - Chandra
2	Domri Rade		$1.00	Legendary Planeswalker - Domri
4	Domri, Anarch of Bolas		$2.44	Legendary Planeswalker - Domri
2	Gideon, Ally of Zendikar		$2.47	Legendary Planeswalker - Gideon
1	Ral, Storm Conduit		$2.66	Legendary Planeswalker - Ral
6	Teferi, Time Raveler		$7.60	Legendary Planeswalker - Teferi
3	The Royal Scions		$0.51	Legendary Planeswalker - Will Rowan
9	Ugin, the Spirit Dragon		$28.25	Legendary Planeswalker - Ugin
1	Vraska, Golgari Queen		$3.60	Legendary Planeswalker - Vraska
Land (873)
2	Arch of Orazca		$0.36	Land
10	Battlefield Forge		$2.36	Land
3	Blast Zone		$0.36	Land
4	Blood Crypt		$14.35	Land - Swamp Mountain
16	Blooming Marsh		$6.22	Land
31	Botanical Sanctum		$3.40	Land
25	Breeding Pool		$16.60	Land - Forest Island
1	Castle Ardenvale		$0.48	Land
13	Castle Embereth		$0.26	Land
11	Castle Garenbrig		$6.37	Land
7	Castle Locthwain		$4.52	Land
1	Castle Vantress		$1.37	Land
4	Darksteel Citadel		$0.74	Artifact Land
2	Dragonskull Summit		$2.14	Land
4	Fabled Passage		$5.79	Land
100	Forest		$0.08	Basic Land - Forest
8	Game Trail		$0.51	Land
26	Glacial Fortress		$1.57	Land
31	Hallowed Fountain		$7.74	Land - Plains Island
2	Hanweir Battlements		$4.58	Land
7	Hashep Oasis		$0.19	Land - Desert
2	Hinterland Harbor		$1.28	Land
8	Inspiring Vantage		$7.30	Land
49	Island		$0.09	Basic Land - Island
10	Llanowar Wastes		$3.28	Land
8	Lotus Field		$5.58	Land
2	Lumbering Falls		$0.30	Land
6	Mana Confluence		$42.15	Land
156	Mountain		$0.10	Basic Land - Mountain
37	Mutavault		$11.63	Land
6	Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx		$36.69	Legendary Land
16	Overgrown Tomb		$11.50	Land - Swamp Forest
18	Plains		$0.09	Basic Land - Plains
10	Port Town		$0.33	Land
9	Radiant Fountain		$0.14	Land
35	Ramunap Ruins		$0.54	Land - Desert
4	Rootbound Crag		$4.30	Land
8	Sacred Foundry		$18.60	Land - Mountain Plains
8	Sanctum of Ugin		$1.64	Land
1	Scavenger Grounds		$1.30	Land - Desert
1	Sea Gate Wreckage		$0.24	Land
1	Sheltered Thicket		$0.40	Land - Mountain Forest
10	Shivan Reef		$1.07	Land
12	Shrine of the Forsaken Gods		$0.28	Land
2	Spire of Industry		$0.44	Land
12	Spirebluff Canal		$9.86	Land
10	Steam Vents		$13.49	Land - Island Mountain
15	Stomping Ground		$11.11	Land - Mountain Forest
5	Sulfur Falls		$1.17	Land
10	Sunpetal Grove		$3.26	Land
35	Swamp		$1.22	Basic Land - Swamp
16	Temple Garden		$12.41	Land - Forest Plains
8	Temple of Mystery		$0.20	Land
8	Thespian's Stage		$2.31	Land
6	Unclaimed Territory		$0.50	Land
4	Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth		$40.93	Legendary Land
2	Watery Grave		$13.06	Land - Island Swamp
2	Westvale Abbey // Ormendahl, Profane Prince		$6.76	Land // Legendary Creature - Demon
3	Woodland Cemetery		$2.03	Land
10	Yavimaya Coast		$0.79	Land

Sideboard - 570 cards, 136 distinct

	Name	Edition	$	Type	Cost
	Name	Rarity	$	Type	Color
Creature (148)
4	Arborback Stomper		$0.04	Creature - Beast
7	Deputy of Detention		$0.23	Creature - Vedalken Wizard
3	Desecration Demon		$0.70	Creature - Demon
1	Dire Fleet Daredevil		$0.62	Creature - Human Pirate
4	Eidolon of the Great Revel		$4.27	Enchantment Creature - Spirit
4	Eldrazi Obligator		$0.21	Creature - Eldrazi
4	Embereth Shieldbreaker // Battle Display		$0.08	Creature - Human Knight // Sorcery - Adventure	//
2	Giant Killer // Chop Down		$0.27	Creature - Human Peasant // Instant - Adventure	//
2	Glorybringer		$0.23	Creature - Dragon
2	Goblin Chainwhirler		$0.93	Creature - Goblin Warrior
3	Goblin Rabblemaster		$1.16	Creature - Goblin Warrior
2	Hazoret the Fervent		$1.44	Legendary Creature - God
2	Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet		$8.48	Legendary Creature - Vampire Warrior
10	Knight of Autumn		$0.55	Creature - Dryad Knight
1	Lavinia, Azorius Renegade		$0.55	Legendary Creature - Human Soldier
3	Lifebane Zombie		$0.24	Creature - Zombie Warrior
1	Lyra Dawnbringer		$3.65	Legendary Creature - Angel
1	Massacre Girl		$0.56	Legendary Creature - Human Assassin
2	Mentor of the Meek		$0.21	Creature - Human Soldier
2	Nylea's Disciple		$0.08	Creature - Centaur Archer
4	Oblivion Sower		$0.72	Creature - Eldrazi
2	Questing Beast		$5.50	Legendary Creature - Beast
13	Rampaging Ferocidon		$7.15	Creature - Dinosaur
7	Reclamation Sage		$0.17	Creature - Elf Shaman
2	Rekindling Phoenix		$0.63	Creature - Phoenix
7	Remorseful Cleric		$0.26	Creature - Spirit Cleric
1	Ripjaw Raptor		$1.23	Creature - Dinosaur
12	Scab-Clan Berserker		$0.26	Creature - Human Berserker
12	Scavenging Ooze		$0.35	Creature - Ooze
4	Shifting Ceratops		$0.16	Creature - Dinosaur
1	Sphinx of the Final Word		$0.64	Creature - Sphinx
2	Spirit of the Labyrinth		$1.26	Enchantment Creature - Spirit
9	Thought-Knot Seer		$2.09	Creature - Eldrazi
7	Tireless Tracker		$1.41	Creature - Human Scout
3	Tocatli Honor Guard		$0.34	Creature - Human Soldier
1	Walking Ballista		$16.71	Artifact Creature - Construct
1	Wicked Wolf		$0.24	Creature - Wolf
Instant (211)
14	Abrade		$0.19	Instant
3	Abrupt Decay		$2.82	Instant
11	Aether Gust		$0.15	Instant
2	Ajani's Presence		$0.10	Instant
1	Azorius Charm		$0.42	Instant
3	Beckon Apparition		$0.06	Instant
2	Blessed Alliance		$0.17	Instant
6	Chandra's Defeat		$0.07	Instant
2	Destructive Revelry		$0.18	Instant
16	Disdainful Stroke		$0.09	Instant
1	Dive Down		$0.12	Instant
8	Dovin's Veto		$3.71	Instant
2	Electrickery		$0.77	Instant
2	Failure // Comply		$0.17	Instant // Sorcery	//
7	Fatal Push		$1.79	Instant
2	Feed the Clan		$0.14	Instant
3	Fiery Impulse		$0.81	Instant
2	Flame Sweep		$0.07	Instant
23	Fry		$0.14	Instant
2	Golgari Charm		$1.22	Instant
12	Heroic Intervention		$9.42	Instant
2	Icy Blast		$0.69	Instant
6	Magma Spray		$0.02	Instant
22	Mystical Dispute		$0.24	Instant
5	Natural State		$0.08	Instant
7	Negate		$0.16	Instant
5	Noxious Grasp		$0.09	Instant
2	Ob Nixilis's Cruelty		$0.04	Instant
5	Searing Blood		$0.25	Instant
7	Settle the Wreckage		$4.33	Instant
4	Smash to Smithereens		$0.27	Instant
8	Spatial Contortion		$0.19	Instant
1	Spell Pierce		$0.18	Instant
3	Stubborn Denial		$3.55	Instant
3	Summary Dismissal		$0.33	Instant
1	Surge of Righteousness		$0.09	Instant
3	Ultimate Price		$0.17	Instant
3	Valorous Stance		$0.09	Instant
Sorcery (76)
1	Anger of the Gods		$0.32	Sorcery
1	Beacon Bolt		$0.12	Sorcery
2	Broken Bond		$0.26	Sorcery
3	By Force		$0.42	Sorcery
2	Collective Brutality		$1.22	Sorcery
2	Declaration in Stone		$0.26	Sorcery
2	Devout Decree		$0.06	Sorcery
2	Driven // Despair		$0.32	Sorcery // Sorcery	//
5	Duress		$0.05	Sorcery
1	Enter the Infinite		$4.19	Sorcery
1	Finale of Revelation		$3.69	Sorcery
1	Fumigate		$0.32	Sorcery
2	Hunt the Hunter		$0.04	Sorcery
17	Lava Coil		$0.06	Sorcery
1	Lost Legacy		$0.12	Sorcery
4	Mizzium Mortars		$0.70	Sorcery
2	Prey Upon		$0.05	Sorcery
6	Roast		$0.18	Sorcery
2	Supreme Verdict		$1.80	Sorcery
2	Sweltering Suns		$0.15	Sorcery
4	Thought Distortion		$0.20	Sorcery
12	Thoughtseize		$11.49	Sorcery
1	Witch's Vengeance		$0.13	Sorcery
Artifact (47)
1	Aetherflux Reservoir		$10.38	Artifact
5	Aethersphere Harvester		$0.26	Artifact - Vehicle
19	Damping Sphere		$0.64	Artifact
2	Embercleave		$6.48	Legendary Artifact - Equipment
2	Grafdigger's Cage		$2.70	Artifact
1	Heart of Kiran		$0.31	Legendary Artifact - Vehicle
4	Perilous Vault		$0.41	Artifact
2	Pithing Needle		$0.57	Artifact
11	Tormod's Crypt		$0.25	Artifact
Enchantment (61)
4	Authority of the Consuls		$12.86	Enchantment
6	Baffling End		$0.07	Enchantment
4	Chained to the Rocks		$0.66	Enchantment - Aura
5	Cindervines		$0.22	Enchantment
4	Deafening Silence		$1.47	Enchantment
1	Detention Sphere		$0.61	Enchantment
1	Experimental Frenzy		$0.17	Enchantment
20	Leyline of the Void		$2.67	Enchantment
1	Omniscience		$7.25	Enchantment
1	Precognition Field		$0.21	Enchantment
10	Rest in Peace		$1.40	Enchantment
3	Shapers' Sanctuary		$1.01	Enchantment
1	Spirit Bonds		$0.42	Enchantment
Planeswalker (26)
4	Chandra, Awakened Inferno		$2.70	Legendary Planeswalker - Chandra
2	Chandra, Torch of Defiance		$1.69	Legendary Planeswalker - Chandra
1	Dovin, Grand Arbiter		$0.41	Legendary Planeswalker - Dovin
1	Gideon, Ally of Zendikar		$2.47	Legendary Planeswalker - Gideon
1	Jace, Wielder of Mysteries		$4.62	Legendary Planeswalker - Jace
3	Karn, Scion of Urza		$5.63	Legendary Planeswalker - Karn
1	Kiora, Behemoth Beckoner		$0.79	Legendary Planeswalker - Kiora
3	Narset, Parter of Veils		$0.83	Legendary Planeswalker - Narset
1	Ral, Izzet Viceroy		$0.65	Legendary Planeswalker - Ral
1	Saheeli, Sublime Artificer		$0.32	Legendary Planeswalker - Saheeli
1	The Royal Scions		$0.51	Legendary Planeswalker - Will Rowan
2	Ugin, the Spirit Dragon		$28.25	Legendary Planeswalker - Ugin
2	Vivien, Arkbow Ranger		$1.71	Legendary Planeswalker - Vivien
2	Vraska, Golgari Queen		$3.60	Legendary Planeswalker - Vraska
1	Xenagos, the Reveler		$1.01	Legendary Planeswalker - Xenagos
Land (1)
1	Mountain		$0.10	Basic Land - Mountain

Comments