I was working and working and working, but I just could not get this to creep up to solid 4-star territory. While its 15 creatures are particularly low for me, there are a number of ways I can take advantage, between Wight of Precinct Six, Gruesome Encore, and a bevy of grinding cards. I am just not convinced this will be able to stand its ground very well, and it doesn't necessarily provide the level of grind I have become accustomed to. Still, I would expect it to be no worse than even against Dave. The 18/9/10/3 curve is quite favorable, averaging 1.95 and providing ample opportunity to perform early. Combo decks will find this to be a particular problem, and decks that produce large creatures could have their own difficulties.